McElroy is a specific name that originated in two small geographical regions with tightly tied genetics and the two Justins bear a strong resemblance. Most Sco

McElroy is a specific name that originated in two small geographical regions with tightly tied genetics and the two Justins bear a strong resemblance. Most Scotch-Irish people in Canada are related in some way because the initial colonizing wave was quite small. The podcasters are from Milwaukee which shares a border with Canada, is near Canada's most populous city, and was largely settled in that same small wave. Asserting that they're "no relation" would be quite a stretch.