7 ms·
Gassée: Thank God Apple chose NeXT over my BeOS
- mcritz 15y agoI keep hearing that Apple acquired NeXT over Be because of every reason aside from quality of the technology. Was BeOS worse than NeXTSTEP?
- spooneybarger 15y agoWorse is subjective. It was 'less ready for prime time'. It was amazing technology. It is still the most reliable desktop I ever had. It could play more videos/music etc at once with my 32 megs on a dual 66 ppc than my macbook pro w/ 4 gigs on memory and some 2.8ish dual core processor does today. Anecdote- I used to blow people ( including myself away ) by downloading large video and music files from the internet and then launching them and playing on a loop. I got up to play in the 20-30 range at once without any lack of responsiveness and with no stutter etc.
- 4ad 15y agoBeOS was a real time OS, all other client operating systems were not, and still aren't, real time. The responsiveness of BeOS and its multimedia capabilities were due to this design choice. It felt better when you were using the GUI, and maybe this is all that matters to most users, but the implementation was significantly poorer compared to NeXTSTEP. A real time OS has some advantages as a desktop OS, everything is instant and without lag, but the total throughput of the system is significantly lower. To make a stupid car analogy, a RTOS is a Ferrari while a conventional OS is a massive off-road vehicle. Personally I think a RTOS is the way to go for a desktop OS.
- sharmajai 15y agoGood points. No wonder QNX feels so snappy on the playbook. I sometimes don't understand people's hate for the playbook, it is a wonderful tablet. IMHO it is a much better tablet than kindle fire (which is inspired heavily by the playbook btw), with TAT integration and two extra cameras and an active bezel. I time and time again feel that Google should buy rim and integrate QNX and Android.
- artmageddon 15y agoDo you have any recommendations for a current real-time OS to use? I'd like to try one out on a desktop...
- BerislavLopac 15y agoWindows CE, apparently... ;) But there seem to be some other interesting examples, like QNX: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_real-time_operating_systems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_real-time_operating_sys...
- zokier 15y agoLinux can be configured as RTOS too, but I doubt that it would improve desktop responsiveness.
- 4ad 15y agoRTAI and Xenomai can be considered real time Linux and both require application support. Applications don't just become real time, they must be programmed that way. Common Linux desktop application are not programmed this way. RTLinux is more widely used than RTAI or Xenomai, but it's a completely different model, it's more like a hypervisor. Again, it doesn't help. While the OS provides the serivices, applications must be programmed specifically to use it.
- luriel 15y ago"Real time" can mean many different things. And how "fast" and "real time" a desktop feels usually has little to do with the technically real time (or lack of thereof) of the kernel. That said, Plan 9 has an interesting implementation of real time capabilities: http://doc.cat-v.org/plan_9/real_time/ http://doc.cat-v.org/plan_9/real_time/
- jonhohle 15y agoBeOS is not a realtime OS. It's scheduler is just optimized for multimedia tasks and GUI responsiveness. The popular realtime OS from the BeOS glory days days was QNX (and it's Photon graphical interface), but it certainly never "felt" faster than BeOS on the same hardware.
- 4ad 15y agoBeOS was definitely a real time OS. BeOS had two scheduling classes, threads with a priority level between 1-99 were time shared threads where the quantum was proportional with 2^priority_level, threads with a priority level between 100 and 120 were real time threads, they could preempt any other thread, including any kernel thread, they were locked to a CPU and never preempted. And when a real time thread was created, it preempted any time shared thread immediately, the scheduler run at creation, it wasn't only added to a scheduling queue like time shared threads. QNX is a still very popular realtime OS in the embedded world today. Btw, the OS run by the BlackBerry devices is QNX. Usually you'll find QNX in control systems like avionics.
- cubicle67 15y agoMemory's pretty hazy here, so someone correct me where I'm wrong One of the major deficiencies in Apple's OS at the time was lack of real multi user capabilities; like Windows pre XP. NeXT, coming from BSD, had this built in but BeOS was pretty much a single user OS
- i386 15y agoNo the problem wasn't multiuser support it was multitasking (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_multitasking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_multitasking).
- kls 15y agoAs well as Multiprocessor support, cooperative memory management AKA lack of OS controlled memory management and a host of other issues. Remember OS7 shared lineage from the original OS1, some sins that they hacked to make it work back then, where hard to remove after the fact. While they where technical marvels at the time (1984) they became handcuffs later on.
- philwelch 15y agoI have (fond?) memories of using Get Info on various applications and setting how much memory they would take from the OS, and then going to About This Macintosh to check how much memory I had left over. Incidentally, up until version 7.6, the Mac OS was simply called "System", as in "System 6" and "System 7". (Systems 1-5 were rapidly iterated through and forgotten--even System 6 still ran on a Mac Plus). Mac OS 7.6 was the first version that was designed to run on clones, hence the change from generic "System" to "Mac OS".
- kls 15y agoMost people at the time felt that BeOS was the better choice. BeOS was ready and could have replaced MacOS the next day, it was already being marketed as a replacement for MacOS and I think that is why Gassée tried to kill the deal, I think he truly thought that people where going to buy a Mac and switch to BeOS. The only thing that BeOS was missing was apps, had he been able to convince more flagship app makers like Photoshop to develop their apps for BeOS he may have succeeded, it really was the only thing that was missing. Meanwhile NeXT was reworked over the next couple of years just to get it running on the hardware and then the first versions of OSX where horribly slow. So Apple spent lost 2 years and had a slower product by going with NeXT when BeOS was ready to go, most people at the time did not see the logic. Today history has plaid out and the truth is they where not just buying an OS they needed much more.
- lobster_johnson 15y ago> BeOS was ready BeOS was arguably less ready than NeXTSTEP, lacking a network stack and printing (as has been pointed out elsewhere), and had very few apps and very few users, whereas NeXT was already deployed and in use by a lot of people. > and could have replaced MacOS the next day Not at all. One of the main points that MacOS had to support Mac application. There is no way that Apple ever would have released a Mac operating system (be it Copland, Rhapsody or MacOS X) without a "yellow box" MacOS System 8 layer. Didn't happen with NeXTSTEP either -- a lot of stuff, like QuickTime and Finder, had to be ported over first.
- microtherion 15y ago"yellow box" was more or less the NeXTStep stuff, the Classic emulation was the "blue box". http://lowendmac.com/musings/boxes.shtml http://lowendmac.com/musings/boxes.shtml Originally, Carbon was not in the plans at all (the yellow box corresponded to what is nowadays referred to as Cocoa). Adding that was a substantial additional task, but probably well worth it.
- lobster_johnson 15y agoYeah, sorry, I meant blue box.
- Nelson69 15y agoThere is a lot of emotion people have in a question like this. I think the best answer is BeOS wasn't as complete as NeXT. Specifically it had a fairly poor network stack (it was being retooled around the time BeOS became part of palm, no idea if it was finished) It lacked the kind of print support MacOS and NeXT had. It lacked the same caliber of internationalization. All fixable stuff but also all stuff requiring some investment. It also remains to be seen how well BeOS would actually scale, it was an RTOS with a UI, it could absolutely do sexy stuff on low powered machines of the day, that doesn't mean it could run a 12core dual i7 machine well. Maybe it could, we really don't know.
- lcargill99 15y agoiZ Corporation's RADAR runs on BeOS. It's a DAW system of exceedingly high quality. We can only guess how well it'd scale, but Be looks to me not to be the sort of software that helps sell hardware.
- tambourine_man 15y agoAlmost nothing runs great on that many cores. Certainly not Xnu.
- RexRollman 15y agoThe one thing I seem to recall, and this is fuzzy, is that BeOS had issues with large applications, like Firefox. I don't know if that was true or not.
- kylec 15y agoI, too, think that getting Steve back was the right move, with NeXTSTEP as an added bonus. I'm just sad that BeOS died an undignified death - a few years ago I bought a BeOS CD off eBay and was very impressed with the OS. It was more responsive on a 100MHz machine than Windows XP was on a 2GHz machine. Yes, I know there's Haiku, but they're really just catching up to where BeOS was 15 years ago. Imagine what BeOS would be like today if it continued to be developed and improved.
- DanBC 15y agoI too miss the alternative OSs. It'd be great to see what BeOS could have been, along with OS/2.
- agildehaus 15y agoHaiku shows a lot of promise despite how few developers they have. You should really give it a spin, especially when they hit beta. If they finish their Wifi implementation (it works, even with WPA2 now, just doesn't have a complete GUI), bring their Webkit browser up-to-date, and get a bit more stability it would be a pleasant system to use on a day-to-day basis. I honestly think if it had the momentum of a larger community, it could easily be open source's triumph on the desktop.
- frogly 15y agoI loved BeOS back in the day. Such a beautiful and clean interface. I loved the philosophy behind it, and the disdain for 'cruft' as they called it. I still have the discs lying around somewhere...
- rbanffy 15y agoI really hated the small title bars. Never got used (admittedly, never tried that much) to them. We had a BeOS machine at the office in 1998, a beautiful IBM Aptiva S.
- wmf 15y agoBeOS's idealism also held it back. They didn't want any ported apps; everything was supposed to be written from scratch. So no Mozilla, no Java, etc. Unfortunately, the BeOS market was never large enough to justify writing large native apps, so they just never happened.
- ibisum 15y agoI still have my BeBox, darn it. I turn it on every year just to wonder at its humble beauty and try to work out what to do with it, exactly. Then I turn it off.
- thaumaturgy 15y agoGassée is just full of shit here. I was a die-hard BeOS fan even before R5. It really was a remarkable operating system, way, way ahead of its day. But Gassée fumbled it when courting Apple [1], and then sold it to Palm, who promptly killed it. It has taken years for a dedicated group of followers to rebuild it from scratch, and by the time they finished doing that, computer hardware had advanced so much that there was very little demand for a high-performance operating system in the desktop market. So, I guess he can claim to be glad that his baby died a lonely and ultimately unremarkable death thanks largely to his own mishandling of it, but it sounds like sour grapes to me. [1]: I remember reading an article a while back about the meeting between Amelio, Gassée, and Jobs. Reportedly, Gassée thought BeOS was a shoe-in, despite asking an astronomical figure for the sale, so he showed up to the meeting completely unprepared. Steve, in typical Steve fashion, showed up fully prepared and blew Gassée right out of the water. I've spent fifteen minutes searching for that article, and I can't find it [2] -- and it might be apocryphal anyway, according to a post on Slashdot (http://apple.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=129504&cid=10804161 http://apple.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=129504&cid=108...). Still, Gassée and Jobs have had an uneasy relationship in the past (http://folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&story=Handicapped.txt http://folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&story...). [2]: Woo, found it! http://macspeedzone.com/archive/art/con/be.shtml http://macspeedzone.com/archive/art/con/be.shtml edit: aside from that, it was great to see and hear Bill Atkinson, and Gassée had some funny quotes.
- gvb 15y agoThe headline only quotes half of the money quote. The half they don't quote puts the "thank god it didn't happen" in a pretty different light: "because I hated Apple’s management." This is either sour grapes because the deal fell through or else the deal fell through because he let personal issues get in the way of business. I lean strongly towards the latter, given Gassée history and the unreasonable price tag he put on BeOS. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Louis_Gass%C3%A9e#1980s:_Apple_Computer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Louis_Gass%C3%A9e#1980s:_A...
- drumdance 15y agoIn fairness, Jobs hated Apple's management too. In the biography he refers to them as bozos.
- scg 15y agoIf you're curious, here's the HackerNews homepage and a few sample apps on Haiku, the operating system inspired by BeOS: http://bit.ly/sTLZne http://bit.ly/sTLZne
- Samuel_Michon 15y agoLink redirects to http://dl.dropbox.com/u/2038028/public/Screen%20Shot%202011-11-12%20at%203.53.45%20AM.png http://dl.dropbox.com/u/2038028/public/Screen%20Shot%202011-... I personally don't like going to sites without knowing their address. To expand shortlinks, try http://longurl.org/ http://longurl.org/
- zmanji 15y agoAlternatively you can append `+` to the end of any short url and get the same information.
- X-Istence 15y agoIs that true for ALL short URL services?
- Samuel_Michon 15y agoThat's awesome! Thanks a lot.
- Mpdreamz 15y agoDidn't apple choose NeXT largely in part of beOS notoriously hard to skin nature?
- spooneybarger 15y agohard to skin nature?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- sharmajai 15y agoI think hard to change the visual look and feel is what he means.
- i386 15y agoNo. NeXT was cheaper, they got the original visionary back to Apple and NeXT had a revenue stream (From my understanding Be Inc didn't have one to speak of).
- jbellis 15y agoNeXT was not cheaper; Gassee wanted 275M for BeOS, and they bought NeXT for 429.
- rdl 15y agoNeXT was a bigger, more mature company with more assets and revenue, so even if you discount Jobs, buying NeXT for 429mm is less overpriced than Be for 275mm.
- flomo 15y agoOn the other hand, NeXT's main source of revenue was WebObjects, something Apple wasn't really interested in marketing. The operating system was pretty much a back catalog item.
- Steko 15y ago15 years later and he's still trying to spin his terrible negotiating into a positive. Company worth $80 million. Buyout offer at $125 million. Hold out for $275 million. Get nothing and go out of business.
- jstanderfer 15y agoThis isn't completely accurate is Be Inc. did successfully IPO in 1999 and won a lawsuit against Microsoft.
- _delirium 15y agoYeah, even the investors who didn't cash out at the IPO did eventually end up with $35 million for the company: $11 million from the 2001 asset sale to Palm, and $24 million from the 2002 settlement with Microsoft.
- easp 15y agoRemember too, NeXT didn't just have a desktop OS, it had an enterprise application framework, which Apple used to build the Apple Online Store. That may or may not have been an important factor at the time, but given the inroads Microsoft was making in enterprise backoffices at the time, it was probably a consideration for Apple's board and management.
- emehrkay 15y agoI am at this point in the Steve Jobs book. Apple was considering using Windows as well. Bill Gates was furious when Apple bought NeXT, he really wanted Apple to run windows.
- kls 15y agoThey where not considering it, the CHRP Mac's had a PPC version of NT that ran on it, I know because I installed that abomination one time just to see. It was probably the buggiest version of windows I have ever seen.
- philwelch 15y agoNo CHRP Mac ever shipped. The closest anyone ever came was Motorola with the StarMax 6000. The CHRP spec evolved into the New World ROM architecture used from the original iMac to the end of the PowerPC era, though. There was indeed a PPC version of NT that was designed for CHRP. But, separate from that, Apple also seriously considered using a custom version of NT with a Mac-like GUI to replace the Mac OS. It was one of many options under consideration along with Be, NeXT, and Solaris.
- kls 15y agoSorry my post does look to reflect that they did, but yes the full CHRP never shipped, but the portions that allowed NT to run on the PPC did. There was a working version of NT that ran on Apples and the clones.
- SimHacker 15y agoBeOS was missing one important thing that NeXT Step had: Jobs Control.
- WiseWeasel 15y agoI loved Gassée's Freudian slip at 0:10:44: "... now I'm a vulture capi... er, venture capitalist." His story of getting himself fired from Apple by Scully a bit prior to that was also quite amusing and revealing of his frank nature. I also loved Bill Atkinson's story at 18:17 paraphrasing Steve Jobs convincing him to drop out of med school and join Apple: "You know how fun it is to surf on the front edge of a wave? Now think about the poor guy dog-paddling on the tail end of the same wave... it's no fun! You go the same distance, you know, but this guy's just eating the back of the wave; this guy's surfing. Come to Apple and surf!" And finally, for those wanting to skip the bulk of the video and go straight to the part with Gassée discussing NeXT and Be, it's at 58:22.