3 ms·
QI doesn't protect the government, you can still sue it for violating your rights. QI protects agents of the government, you can't personally sue a cop for vio
by vkou 4y ago
QI doesn't protect the government, you can still sue it for violating your rights.
QI protects agents of the government, you can't personally sue a cop for violating your rights. (Either because he was following illegal orders, or because he's an idiot who doesn't know/doesn't care about the law.)
You are correct that QI was a legal fabrication, and is in its current form an incredibly poor one at that.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> QI doesn't protect the government, you can still sue it for violating your rights. Sure, QI doesn't protect the government, but sovereign immunity does. > QI protects agents of the government, you can't personally sue a cop for violating your rights. Yes, you can. And you can win in some cases. But, if they were within the scope of non-discretionary job duty, even if illegal, though, they are protected by absolute immunity, if their act was an illegal exercise of discretion but not within a pattern unambiguously previously litigated as such, they are protected by qualified immunity. > You are correct that QI was a legal fabrication It is no more or less a “legal fabrication” than, say, the exclusionary rule.