3 ms·
Regulatory capture explains most of these anti-vaping campaigns: > Some studies have suggested that e-cigarette use can be modestly helpful for smokers trying
by hedora 4y ago
Regulatory capture explains most of these anti-vaping campaigns:
> Some studies have suggested that e-cigarette use can be modestly helpful for smokers trying to quit. For example, an analysis of 61 studies found that e-cigarette use was more effective than other approaches to quitting smoking. The study authors estimated that out of every 100 people who tried to quit smoking by vaping, nine to 14 might be successful. When only using other methods, such as nicotine patches or behavioral counselling, only four to seven smokers out of 100 might quit. A separate study suggests vaping may help smokers who aren’t able to quit reduce the number of cigarettes smoked per day — at least for six months, the duration of the study.
Doubling the chances people can effectively stop smoking is no good for profits.
Source: https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/can-vaping-help-you-quit-smoking-2019022716086 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/can-vaping-help-you-quit...
- woodruffw 4y agoHm? My understanding is that most of the "Big Tobacco" companies have gone all in on smokeless cigarettes and other nicotine delivery technologies, since that's where the young (and growing market is). Philip Morris, for example, is the pinnace of "Big Tobacco" and is currently all in on "transforming" themselves into a "smoke-free" company[1]. [1]: https://www.pmi.com/ https://www.pmi.com/
- hedora 4y agoTrue, but the regulations they push through often happen to only impact smaller competitors, or only impact things people are actually using to quit smoking. Also, their VEEV vapes are only available in tobacco and menthol flavors, and those flavors have been shown to be less effective for tobacco cessation. (They also tried to push through laws banning other flavors, if I remember right.) Pre-empting the "think of the childeren" responses; tobacco marketed to kids continues to be widely available: https://shipfest.org/vaping-for-kids-the-top-10-vape-brands-of-2021/ https://shipfest.org/vaping-for-kids-the-top-10-vape-brands-... Check out the Pod Juice Freeze "Strawberry Kiwi Pomberry", for example. If not for the big nicotine warning on the bottom half of the label, I wouldn't be surprised if parents confused it with kids' Pedialyte, or some sort of DIY popsicle mix: https://www.ejuices.com/ https://www.ejuices.com/
- collegeburner 4y agothey try offering in fruity flavors: "yall are trying to hook kids!" they try offering in tobacco flavors: "that's not effective for cessation!" wtf are they supposed to sell then?!
- hedora 4y agoPer the article, they should reformulate to one of the many known-safe ingredients that don't actively destroy lung tissue, and the FDA shouldn't have inexplicably delayed the requirement for five years. Also, law enforcement could enforce existing laws against marketing tobacco to kids. The most effective cessation flavor is supposedly "unflavored". I believe it's been banned (in the same way that strawberry lime pomegranate is "banned" -- not very effectively).
- undersuit 4y agoWhen you make a hedge bet you don't go all in. They are still making normal cigarettes, and last I heard expanding their tobacco productions to take advantage of emerging international markets.
- HWR_14 4y agoBig Tobacco owns the vape companies. New smokers use vapes many times more than all other forms of smoking combined. Trading a slightly higher churn for a 5-6x more uptick in customers is a great trade. Especially if they churn to another product you own.
- hedora 4y agoYes, but this is their plan B. Simultaneously working to regulate away the disruptors and also acquiring some of them is good business sense. They hedged their bets. Anyway, do you have a better explanation for the inconsistent positions tobacco regulators take in the US?
- HWR_14 4y agoPlan B? Vapes are making them more money the money then it's costing them. And they were already an industry dying out (in the US) as new smoker numbers kept dwindling. Meanwhile, they own the biggest vape companies. And I don't see what inconsistent positions are taken. If you tell me them, I'll gladly tell you why.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoThey don’t own ALL vape companies, just those most heavily marketed.