3 ms·
for a true democracy, all voices must be equal, and no single voice of a private entity can be allowed to have more reach than any other. for that, any media t
by em-bee 4y ago
for a true democracy, all voices must be equal, and no single voice of a private entity can be allowed to have more reach than any other.
for that, any media that is designed to amplify some voices over others would have to cease.
one way to help with that would be by disconnecting ideas from the people who shared them so that good ideas can be shared and discussed without creating leaders that people will be compelled to follow. (imagine if hackernews discussions would not show any usernames, so you would not know who said anything, and any message would have to stand on its own. i believe this would work because practically, i rarely notice who the parent posters that i respond to are, unless we start a longer discussion thread with the same few people. moderators would still see usernames, so they could identify spam accounts.)
this of course completely contradicts the personality cult that is made out of current leadership.
- huetius 4y agoThat sounds like 4chan :) I’m sympathetic; I believe in the ideals of democracy, but it seems to me that those ideals come from outside of democracy itself, and that democracy cannot function without them. An example is the belief that everyone participates in a common rationality, such that there is benefit to be had by allowing different perspectives to be heard. This belief has been undermined in a very deep way in the US, to the point we can fairly clearly say that it is gone. I am deeply worried about what this means in the future, and am skeptical that there are procedural or technical solutions. (As an aside, I think that the traditional left vs right hermeneutic is beyond useless to explain how this belief disappeared, but that’s maybe a different discussion).
- em-bee 4y agoThat sounds like 4chan well, not really, because technically, hackernews works that way too. the difference between 4chan and HN is, who the people are that participate. and what topics they are discussing. even 4chan has different topics and each topic is moderated. it's not a free-for-all. the difference is that on 4chan almost any topic and tone is welcome, whereas on HN it is not. the same would be true for any democratic discourse where we want to address the problems of our community. any person should have an equal voice, as long as that voice contributes to the discussion of the problem at hand. moderation of off-topic or inappropriate contributions still needs to happen. This belief has been undermined in a very deep way in the US, to the point we can fairly clearly say that it is gone. not just in the US but pretty much world wide. I am deeply worried about what this means in the future, and am skeptical that there are procedural or technical solutions there are a few things that i believe are clearly a problem, and by changing those, democracy could be improved. the strongest one is partisan politics, which causes groups to fight with each other instead of letting those interested in solving a problem work on it together. another is the personality cult that is created by candidates around elections. if instead we have write-in nominations only, without allowing any kind of promotion of particular individuals, we would be able to elect those people that the majority feels, actually represent them. that of course doesn't scale, so these elections would only happen at a local level. at regional and national levels the elections would be done by electorates from amongst themselves. so, in order to become president, someone would have to be elected locally into the regional electorate, and then be chosen by the regional electorate and later the national electorate all the way to the top. and while we are at it, let's not have a single president but a committee of elected leaders who can only enact decisions if the majority of them agree. like the supreme court.
- em-bee 4y agoforgot to add another low hanging fruit: ban any form of lobbying
- wvenable 4y agoYou're missing is the time factor. Someone with infinitely more time to post on Hackernews will have their opinions amplified over people who are more casually interacting with the site. The probably with people is that if see the same opinion X number of times they tend to believe it. Nobody is immune to it.
- em-bee 4y agohackernews actually already supports rate-limiting people from posting to much. so it is possible to implement systems where individual voices don't get a chance to dominate. i think that would address this problem.
- wvenable 4y agoI don't have time to create hundreds of alt-accounts or run proxies through alternative servers but there are people who do. I used to run a forum and play this game of cat and mouse.