4 ms·
> I said "offending", not "offensive". Those are conjugates of the same word. What is your actual point? > you just added an impartial characterization Is i
by carapace 4y ago
> I said "offending", not "offensive".
Those are conjugates of the same word. What is your actual point?
> you just added an impartial characterization
Is it accurate or inaccurate characterization of TFA? Can we talk about that? Do you think I misunderstood what the author is trying to say?
> but it's not impartial
Yeah, I said up front that I'm biased against the "sacrifice the oldies for the sake of the economy" meme. I'm also biased against stupidity, which is to say that the author seems stupid to me.
> Here, let me play the same game
I'm not playing a game, and I know what I wrote.
> Mrs. X who refuses to get vaccinated...
I never mentioned getting or refusing to be vaccinated. That's all you.
> ...dies of Covid...
See, that's a euphemism. It's not a tidy, peaceful death. It's "dies in agony drowning in her own dissolving lung tissue" like I said. I'm not employing some rhetorical device, it's a simple plain English description of how Covid kills you.
> abysmal education for tens of millions of American school-aged children
Now there is something we could talk about.
But first let me point out that that's not what the author of the piece was saying. He wrote,
> But since most adults retain almost no academic knowledge, I’m skeptical of the long-term harm [of school closures]. Instead, I rest my case on the indubitable fact that in-person school provides invaluable daycare.
He's not talking about the harms that lockdowns did to children, in fact he discounts them. When I wrote "Young child misses two years of convenient daycare" I wasn't impartial, I'm describing the author's stance (which, as I said, is stupid IMO, I'm biased against it.) Your rewording misrepresents the author's argument.
- - - -
Anyhow, I personally have had a low opinion of public school ever since I was made to attend as a child. It seems to me that the US education system is a sick joke, and that "abysmal education for tens of millions of American school-aged children" is the norm anyway, long before the school closings. I think we should overhaul the whole system, and I while we're at it think we should look to making schools less of a disease vector. Covid won't be the last virus, eh?
If you want to argue about the state of the US school system, I'm "game" to do that. I got strong opinions and I'm willing to share.
If you want to argue about school closings vs. whatever I'm not your guy.
You may have heard of the recent San Francisco school board members recall? We threw out three of our top administrators. Just FYI, I voted to recall them, in part due to their poor handling of school re-opening. I hope that helps you understand that I'm not on "the other side"? We're all in this together. Humanity vs. the virus, eh?
Have a good day.
https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/16/politics/san-francisco-school-board-members-recall-election/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/16/politics/san-francisco-school...
P.S. Last but not least, God bless you and your kids and mom. I'm glad we talked this out. It's clear to me now that you are not one of these "mom should die so the kids can go back to school" folks and I really appreciate that. Take care, and well met.