2 ms·
There are a few classics of middle-brow discourse: - Fallacy Name Summoning: described in article - Edge-Case Generalization: "Humans have two legs". "You hav
by renewiltord 4y ago
There are a few classics of middle-brow discourse:
- Fallacy Name Summoning: described in article
- Edge-Case Generalization: "Humans have two legs". "You haven't accounted for this man born with one leg".
- Single Paper Refutations: Search Google Scholar to find a single paper that does X. Means nothing. Lots of research is non-repeatable. Lots of it is faked.
- Single Paper Confirmations: The same as above but weasel-worded into "there is some evidence that" with rest of discussion operating under the frame of last-paper-submitted wins.
- Gish Gallops of the former: Single Paper Xs, n times. If you scan the space of papers with appropriate keywords, effectively sampling only the ones that will power your argument
Overall, each of these are mostly performed by (mu-eps, mu+sigma) people. You need some intelligence to get here. But it's really tiresome reasoning. For my part, I try to engage at best capacity, but sometimes I get really frustrated. It's a variant of the Blub Paradox. All the people below me on the Epistemology ladder are morons incapable of understanding things. All the people above me have failed to account for some nuance.
In any case, I now have certain heuristics. To be honest, it's quite nice to have these because, while these mid-brow participants are frustrating, they also lead to me taking a break from this website.