4 ms·
The reframing is that it have cops reason to go in armed and expecting an active shooter when 93% of the time there was no reason to expect that, and 4 it of 5
by shadowgovt 4y ago
The reframing is that it have cops reason to go in armed and expecting an active shooter when 93% of the time there was no reason to expect that, and 4 it of 5 times SS reports led to civilians being stopped for no justification.
- pxmpxm 4y agoThe reality is in those areas cops are always armed and expecting active shooters. Look up the gunplay stats for places like Back of The Yards in Chicago.
- shadowgovt 4y agoIn that case, a technology encouraging them to go out expecting armed resistance when no crime has been committed is an obvious danger for the community.
- pxmpxm 4y agoIf you think armed cops are the obvious danger in shotspotter neighborhoods, you've departed objective reality. Eg https://chicago.suntimes.com/crime/2022/7/27/23280415/chicago-shootings-gun-violence https://chicago.suntimes.com/crime/2022/7/27/23280415/chicag...
- shadowgovt 4y ago> If you think armed cops are the obvious danger Yes, I do think that. https://www.npr.org/2022/05/26/1101496374/chicago-police-13-year-old-shot-lawsuit https://www.npr.org/2022/05/26/1101496374/chicago-police-13-... It seems to me that to think otherwise is a "the omelet requires breaking eggs" argument.
- solardev 4y agoLived in Chicago (but not the south side) and can agree that the gun violence there is extreme. It's an war zone every day, with thousands of shootings a year and hundreds of homicides. That said, I don't think anyone is opposed to technology that can locate gunshots and deliver law enforcement to the right places. The gripe is that this company in particular has a history of being opaque and trying to cover up their failings, leading to questions about the effectiveness of their underlying technology and data integrity. The public can't tell whether this is a legitimate social good based on an effective tool or if the company is just ripping off tax payers and sometimes outright working with crooked cops to fabricate probable cause. Not every cop is crooked, and not every acoustic triangulation technology is fake. But this company isn't being transparent or well intentioned enough for the public, or even a limited group of outside experts, to make that determination. And they have a history of being willing to corrupt their data, altering evidence to facilitate false records from crooked cops. The right tools in the wrong hands can still be a problem. We don't know if this is the right tool, but the company has shown itself to be the wrong hands.
- SilasX 4y agoHonest question: what probability of finding a shooter is the “right” threshold to go in armed and expecting a shooter?
- shadowgovt 4y agoYou'd have to ask London police, since they don't. So my Fermi estimate would be somewhere between US and UK rates.
- halostatue 4y agoLet’s tighten that up, some. Canadian police are armed with lethal weapons and need to go into active shooter situations less often than the U.S., which is a wildcard outlier of gun violence, second only to active war zones.
- SilasX 4y agoYou're both misreading the question. The question was not "how often do police go in expecting a shooter?" The question was, "what 'probability of there being a shooter' justifies going in armed/with a protocol that expects one?" User:shadowgovt, if you followed the thread, was asking us to be outraged that they went in when it was "only" 7%: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32259925 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32259925 But yes, "tighten up" those Fermi estimates for a question no one asked and which has no bearing on the discussion.
- SilasX 4y ago>You'd have to ask London police, since they don't. No, I wouldn't, because your facts are wrong. Yes, London police are generally unarmed, but they still get called to respond to situations where there is a likely armed suspect, and in those cases, they send in special units that are armed. The question here -- that you avoided -- is, what is the appropriate probability before sending in such an officer, and is it higher than the 7% in the situation you cited? You were asking others to be outraged that there was "only" a 7% chance of an actual armed shooter. In an attempt to move the discussion forward, I asked what the appropriate value is, so as to appropriately judge whether such intervention was unwarranted. To which your entire response was to shoehorn in an irrelevant factoid about London and falsely imply I'm not aware of it. (And, of course, work in a Fermi reference, because, why not?) If I may make a suggestion: next time someone asks a substantive question, and you don't have a substantive answer, just don't reply. That's a much better approach for the forum than what you just did.