3 ms·
Strange. Probably the embarrassing parts relate to the after the fact reclassification of reports after the fact by Shotspotter employees. The first system was
by Animats 4y ago
Strange. Probably the embarrassing parts relate to the after the fact reclassification of reports after the fact by Shotspotter employees.
The first system was in Redwood City, CA. I once went to a talk by the designer. They had leased analog audio lines to each microphone. At the microphone end, they had something like a logarithmic amplifier, which traded dynamic range for frequency response. The idea is that you don't want to saturate when it picks up a bang. The audio feeds went to an IBM PC at the police station with some multichannel analog input cards. A program written in LabView running under DOS did the analysis. It was looking for a sharp upward spike from multiple microphones. Then it took the time deltas and computed a position. No attempt to compensate for bounces off buildings, etc. Fairly coarse resolution, down to the side of a block, not a building. It was pretty simple.
- jjeaff 4y agoMy guess is that they don't want to reveal their methods because they are still crude and obvious.
- Gibbon1 4y agoDon't want to reveal their methods cause patent infringement.
- nickysielicki 4y agoHow long ago was this?
- Animats 4y ago1990s.
- gentleman11 4y agoAccurate or not, so we really want companies installing microphones all over where we live that sends the data to the police? That is worse than 1984 because in 1984 the police didn’t have ai profiling everything it finds. Ie, imagine a company that was competent who did this
- Animats 4y agoThe origianl was a 1990s weatherproof omnidirectional microphone on top of a telephone pole, connected to an analog phone line. That would be pretty hopeless at picking up conversations at ground level. Combining signals from microphones maybe a block apart yielded direction. Today, there are steerable microphone arrays.[1] That technology was first demonstrated around 2010. Now it's commercially available. Simple ones with a few channels are used for video conferencing. Surveillance microphone arrays that record a few hundred microphone channels individually exist. These allow steering the beam during playback, so the surveillance operator can choose where to listen long after the recording. Needs a lot of bandwidth and storage, but no worse than HD video. Still, the range of that sort of thing for voice is maybe 10 meters. They're installed on ceilings, not outdoors. [1] https://youtu.be/_kjEmIA38pI https://youtu.be/_kjEmIA38pI
- oceanplexian 4y agoI would guess that the “compensate for bounces off buildings” part is the Achilles heel of this technology. When I worked in telecom we had similar problems with reflections in phone lines, which is a highly controlled environment compared to anything that could potentially reflect sound in a city. And even then we weren’t trying to locate something in 3-dimensional space with reflections, just decode information in spite of them. The more I think about it the more this technology sounds like vaporware except in really ideal conditions, like an open field in the middle of farmland or something.