7 ms·
(Not the OP) For background, this is the company that supposedly locates gunshot sounds in cities (and sometimes battlefields) by microphone triangulation. It d
by solardev 4y ago
(Not the OP) For background, this is the company that supposedly locates gunshot sounds in cities (and sometimes battlefields) by microphone triangulation. It doesn't work all that well and is selectively deployed in minority areas and is used by police to selectively enforce crimes, sometimes also altering the evidence. Vice did a few articles on them and the company tried to sue but had it tossed out. Shady all around.
https://www.vice.com/en/topic/shotspotter https://www.vice.com/en/topic/shotspotter
https://www.techdirt.com/2022/07/08/judge-tosses-defamation-suit-brought-by-shotspotter-against-vice-media-for-reporting-on-its-shady-tactics/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/07/08/judge-tosses-defamation-...
- monksy 4y agoYou're telling me that cities are picking minority areas to put these in just for ill intent? Also, the devices don't "enforce crimes", they only alert approximate areas where a gunshot/firework may have gone off at.
- warkdarrior 4y agoHopefully what is being enforced is the law, not the crimes.
- elil17 4y agoSometimes police manage to enforce both…
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI don't think anyone truly intends ill. However, someone who chooses a technology that doesn't have real evidence of working as well as it's advertised, and then uses applications of that technology on primarily minority populations, the result can only be concluded as illness on the people.
- lkschubert8 4y agoI'm hard pressed to believe that there aren't some folks who have ill intent. The problem is weeding them out from people who are just using crappy metrics and people who just barely know what's going on.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI mean, I genuinely think most people don't intend ill. The most nasty, abusive people I know simply believe that they are in the moral right. In fact, believing that being morally right justifies their behavior is the biggest sign to me of a dangerous person, not a person who knowingly thinks evil things.
- dmix 4y agoThe only question then is whether the police biased these installations in minority neighborhoods without connecting it to high amounts of shootings, which could easily be proven with data. That's the sort of thing that would be useful in court if it's true. Are local police required to publish where they are deploying ShotSpotters? Shootings and racial demographic data is certainly already public. I've read the entire Vice court report and don't remember seeing that data. Haven't read the Chicago one. Edit: reading the original Motherboard source all of the examples were described as small 'pilot programs' so they were usually only a single part of each city, in Cleveland for example : > the Cleveland Police Foundation—has been deployed in a small section of Southeast Cleveland that city officials have described as a high-crime area. > Those neighborhoods also happen to be among the least white in the city and those hit hardest by economic recession and the pandemic, according to local community organizers. > The area the division chose for Shotspotter accounted for 37 percent of all shots fired calls, 37 percent of felonious assaults, and 45% of all homicides within district four, Sergeant Jennifer Ciaccia wrote to Motherboard in an email. https://www.vice.com/en/article/88nd3z/gunshot-detecting-tech-is-summoning-armed-police-to-black-neighborhoods https://www.vice.com/en/article/88nd3z/gunshot-detecting-tec... (Motherboard didn't provide crime stats in the other 3 example cities cited, only the demographic profile which was consistently non-white)
- elil17 4y agoThey didn’t comment on motives, just on reality. That is where these systems are deployed.
- daenz 4y agoAnother way of phrasing it is: these gunshot detection systems are deployed where the vast majority of gunshots occur.
- elil17 4y agoWell the system wouldn’t really be a problem if it wasn’t faulty. It’s the false positives that are an issue. You could put it next to the house of the biggest gun nut in America and it still wouldn’t be a fair system because it just doesn’t work well.
- daenz 4y agoAccording to the data from the uncharitable vice article, their numbers seem pretty good.
- ALittleLight 4y agoIt's worded in a way that implies racism. You could write "high crime areas" or "low socioeconomic status neighborhoods" or any of a dozen equally accurate terms. Instead, the author chose something vague (are they being placed in Jewish neighborhoods? Chinese neighborhoods? Indian? Hispanic?) And suggestive.
- elil17 4y agoIf something has a racist outcome then I don’t see how its “implied” to be racist. It is racist. They just didn’t say anything about whether it was intentional (which no one can know except people who decided where to put the systems).
- ALittleLight 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- googlryas 4y agoJackson MS uses shot spotter and is 80% black, and no, they aren't deploying it in predominantly white "minority" neighborhoods.
- kbenson 4y agoDo you seriously think by "minority" they meant at the local populace level and not national populace level? When has that ever been the colloquial use?
- ATsch 4y agoIt is pretty frequently done when arguing in bad faith, or (sometimes deliberately) misunderstanding that "minority" refers to power and not numbers.
- fastball 4y agoSince it's the locality that is deciding whether or not to use ShotSpotter isn't that the most reasonable level to be talking about?
- kbenson 4y agoNo, as that would be a purposeful misinterpretation of the intent of the original poster, if it was obvious they didn't mean it to be interpreted that way. Even if the response that used it differently was meant to make a valid point (I believe it was, as they expanded on it later), the way they used minority did nothing to help that point and instead caused unnecessary contention. It would have been far more effective for their point to say "Jackson MS has a population and police department that are both majority black, and they still choose to deploy shotspotter in black neighborhoods.". Then we could jump right to exploring reasons why that might be, including valid uses of shotspotter because of effectivenessas well as other incentives regardless of it's effectiveness.
- fastball 4y agoTo me it read less like misinterpretation and more like reframing.
- daenz 4y agoTop article on that vice link: >In Chicago, a government watchdog says Shotspotter alerts have only led to evidence of gun crime in 9 percent of cases. >fewer than 2 in 10 investigatory stops following ShotSpotter alerts resulted in the recovery of a gun 9% actually seems like a lot? Considering that most criminals don't stick around after illegally discharging a firearm. And 1 in 5 resulting in the recovery in a gun? Vice is really bending over backwards to pretend that these numbers are bad.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jchw 4y agoWell, I'm a layperson to anything related to criminal investigation, but this is a little concerning to me. If you're in a particularly crime ridden area, my concern is how many of those 9% are the right evidence against the right person. It's pretty terrible if all it took to nab the wrong person was shoddy evidence from a shady and secretive company that is accused of having manipulated the evidence in the past. It is still quite terrible even if it's often correct, because that makes it much harder for someone who is innocent to do anything about it. Still, it's possible that the numbers Vice is showing does not demonstrate the problem.
- curiousllama 4y agoHonestly, I'd be surprised if 9% weren't below the rate from random searches. It's tragically quite common - and, to a point, quite rational - to carry a gun in some neighborhoods.
- xbar 4y ago80% of all stops and searches are unfounded. I would not want to live in a community so policed.
- daenz 4y agoI wouldn't want to live in a community with 50,176 gunshot alerts either.
- llanowarelves 4y agoIf true, selective enforcement is bad. But some minority demographics commit disproportionate (edit: violent) crime per capita so you expect some proportional scaling (more crime = more need for crime detection) if they happen to live in cities/areas where that's the case. (Usually big cities)
- gpm 4y ago> Usually big cities I'm surprised to see this is somewhat true in the US. In Canada rural crime rates are higher than urban ones, but that trend doesn't seem to hold for the US (per sources below) Of course extrapolating from "average crime rate" to "location of hotspots" might be suspect in both cases... Stats Canada: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/85-002-x/2019001/article/00009-eng.htm https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/85-002-x/2019001/article... Bloomberg article with some nice graphs, and really good links to sources (at the end of it) - the text focuses on NYC but the second line chart in particular (based off of linked CDC data) does a good job of answering this question: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-06-07/is-new-york-city-more-dangerous-than-rural-america https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-06-07/is-new...
- droopyEyelids 4y agoIf you'll look past the unempathetic title of this website, and the nasty tone of the author, you'll see some of how violent crime clusters in Chicago (data visualization) https://heyjackass.com https://heyjackass.com
- gorbachev 4y agoThat depends entirely on what you consider as crime worth pursuing. For example, it's well documented wage theft is a much bigger crime in terms of monetary value than all forms of robberies combined. But those criminals don't get nearly the same level of enforcement as robbers do.
- llanowarelves 4y agoMay be true, but we're talking about (alleged) crimes that ShotSpotter can pick up: gets labelled as "violent crimes". Other Spotters for things such as wage theft, fraud, etc would be great. You could (and I would) argue some whole industries are heavily criminal (fraud) and bait people into moral hazard.
- sergiotapia 4y agoImagine working for such a hellscape company or worse, dedicating your life to this bullshit. Really sickening.
- hiptobecubic 4y agoI feel like you wouldn't work for a company like this unless you somehow believed that all the bullshit they were doing was for the greater good. I would imagine police probably also don't see themselves as racist-in-a-bad-way but as heroes, otherwise why would you ever work there? That's where all this "thin blue line" craziness comes from. I mean, I get it, wanting to protect people in your community from crooks and scumbags that hurt them is natural. It's easy to trick yourself into thinking that these little exceptions to civil rights are justified.
- TedShiller 4y ago> selectively deployed in minority areas I don’t think police is deploying this based on skin color
- YLE118 4y agoAn egregious example from the first link: Police said ShotSpotter, a surveillance system that uses hidden microphone sensors to detect the sound and location of gunshots, generated an alert for that time and place. Except that’s not entirely true, according to recent court filings. That night, 19 ShotSpotter sensors detected a percussive sound at 11:46 p.m. and determined the location to be 5700 South Lake Shore Drive—a mile away from the site where prosecutors say Williams committed the murder, according to a motion filed by Williams’ public defender. The company’s algorithms initially classified the sound as a firework. ... But after the 11:46 p.m. alert came in, a ShotSpotter analyst manually overrode the algorithms and “reclassified” the sound as a gunshot. Then, months later and after “post-processing,” another ShotSpotter analyst changed the alert’s coordinates to a location on South Stony Island Drive near where Williams’ car was seen on camera.
- YLE118 4y agoAnd another: In 2016, Rochester, New York, police looking for a suspicious vehicle stopped the wrong car and shot the passenger, Silvon Simmons, in the back three times. They charged him with firing first at officers. The only evidence against Simmons came from ShotSpotter. Initially, the company’s sensors didn’t detect any gunshots, and the algorithms ruled that the sounds came from helicopter rotors. After Rochester police contacted ShotSpotter, an analyst ruled that there had been four gunshots—the number of times police fired at Simmons, missing once. Paul Greene, ShotSpotter’s expert witness and an employee of the company, testified at Simmons’ trial that “subsequently he was asked by the Rochester Police Department to essentially search and see if there were more shots fired than ShotSpotter picked up,” according to a civil lawsuit Simmons has filed against the city and the company. Greene found a fifth shot, despite there being no physical evidence at the scene that Simmons had fired. Rochester police had also refused his multiple requests for them to test his hands and clothing for gunshot residue. Curiously, the ShotSpotter audio files that were the only evidence of the phantom fifth shot have disappeared. Both the company and the Rochester Police Department “lost, deleted and/or destroyed the spool and/or other information containing sounds pertaining to the officer-involved shooting,” according to Simmons’ civil suit
- ta988 4y agoThe microphones are not hidden you can see them, they are just discreet.
- ck2 4y agoSince sound speed varies with air density and air density varies with humidity, and humidity is relative and varies greatly in urban areas because of heat absorption/reflection of buildings vs trees, how would this technology be even remotely accurate or reliable? If it was up in the atmosphere with long consistent pockets of air, maybe. On the ground, no way.
- solardev 4y agoIt's not out of the question for it to work to some extent -- the question is what extent, when, how, and when it doesn't work. We can't make those determinations because the company is covering that up. Even your ears can somewhat locate sound sources in 3D space, just not with perfect accuracy, especially in complex soundscapes like cities.
- cosmotic 4y agoIt's technically not triangulation, it's multilateration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multilateration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multilateration
- solardev 4y agoThank you for the correction!