3 ms·
> I'm not a video professional I am a video professional, and you always keep your originals. However, the part being left out of the conversation is that as a
by dylan604 4y ago
> I'm not a video professional
I am a video professional, and you always keep your originals. However, the part being left out of the conversation is that as a storage pool for editing goes, this isn't deep storage. Content is typically only left on the edit storage while the project is active. Even the TFA mentions he goes all the way to cloud cold storage.
Edit storage has always been expensive, and maintaining capacity was always a juggling act. Just because terms like NAS are being used, one should not think of this type of storage as a dump it and forget it type of storage.
There are many levels of professional. On the high end, the footage from the camera is copied to multiple hard drives on set. These are the backups, and us old timers still use the terms camera originals. These are as sacrosanct as film negatives, only there's magically multiple copies. This data gets transferred to the editor's storage. Once the edit is completed, the edit session and other content used in the edit may be transferred to the camera original drives for archival. On the other end of professional, you take the SD card out of the camera and transfer directly to the edit storage. In these situations, woe be unto thee that doesn't make proper backups. At that point, it's really more pro-sumer than professional, but hey, if they're getting paid, they're professional enough.
- sorenjan 4y agoSo lets say you release a 10 minute Youtube video. You now have 60 minutes of raw footage with multiple takes, you sitting in front of the rolling camera going over the script, ums and ahs, and maybe a take where the phone rang in the middle of a sentence. What are you going to use that footage for in the future, and is this hypothetical use case absolutely dependent on having raw 4K video? I understand that your answer is from a general video production standpoint, but my question was more in the line of "is this really necessary for this kind of content creation?". And yes, I did see the part about editing, but are you really editing nine days worth of footage at once? Would it make more sense to put less but faster storage directly in the workstation?
- dylan604 4y agoAgain, you're limiting to just YouTube creator styles, and I'm including full on editorial for things like corporate training, episodic, feature, music videos, etc. That's my world. Obviously, the longer the final piece, the more footage necessary. However, something short like a music video can require a huge amount of footage that you might not consider. All of those quick edits of just a few frames to seconds of a shot wasn't that short from the camera. Some of those types of shots might not have ever been intended to be used and be something in between takes. It's all creative, so there are no rules in music videos. Doing that kind of editing does require access to all of that footage at any moment. If you're doing supervised sessions with the client sitting next to you means that they on a whim could decide they want to work on a totally different part of the content. When the client is footing the bill by the hour, you don't get to waste time "loading" content. It's really one of those things that until you've walked a mile in another person's shoes, it's best to not go blindly suggesting "better" based on one's limited knowledge. Asking questions for a better understanding is a totally acceptable way of learning, and I'm all for it. We're danger close to the former. Hopefully, I'm not sounding like an asshat leaning towards the latter.
- sorenjan 4y agoThe article is written by a Youtuber for his Youtube content creation. If you're going to extend the scope to feature films and music videos because that's what you're used to, obviously my assumptions won't be valid. I'm not biking to work on a $15k carbon fiber bike or storing my left over dinner in a walk in freezer either. And I repeat another point. Using his own numbers, this editing NAS has space for over 220 hours, more than 9 consecutive days. What kind of music video production even has that much video footage? Like I wrote in my initial comment, I fully understand using plenty of uncompressed video while editing, it's the saving of hundreds of GB per finished and delivered Youtube video I question.
- geerlingguy 4y agoI typically have 5-10 videos in production in a given week (doesn't mean I'm working on them actively, but I'll sometimes shoot parts of different videos depending on the schedule). Some videos are 10 minutes, others are more like 20. On average I end up with 100-200 GB/video by the end. So you're correct that I don't need 14TB (that's overkill) for now... but anyone who plans storage knows you're better front loading the extra capacity if you can afford it, because needs always seem to grow faster as time goes on (e.g. 4K to 8K, ProRes LT to something with more color space maybe...). And right now I keep all my "A-roll" (scripted takes, usually with about double the run time of the actual video), but I'm considering setting up a script to automatically convert those clips to H.265 afterwards so I can still have reasonably good archival footage but at like 1/100th the file size. All B-roll shots (Dolly shots, handheld closeups, illustrations, etc.) I save at full original resolution, because they are often useful in follow-up videos. But that's usually only like 30-40% of that 100-200 GB per project. (Edited to add: sometimes there's a unicorn video that also has raw Timelapse footage where you roll at normal rate then generate a Timelapse afterwards (and use some of the real-time footage). Those can have hours of footage and a couple have gotten beyond 400 GB. But I try to limit that just because of the hassle. Easier to have one camera devoted to the Timelapse, and another for some other shots for real-time use.)
- vineyardmike 4y agoLove the write up and insight into the world of a professional. Don’t take this the wrong way, I’m genuinely curious… what is a video professional doing on HN? Was it a past life? Is tech just a side interest? I see many non-tech professionals on here (doctors lawyers too) and I’m always curious what drew people in!
- dylan604 4y agoI've been banging code since I was 10 copying BASIC from the back of a magazine into a C64. Got into video production in high school. Saw an entire table full of existing video equipment get replaced by a single video card inside of an Amiga. Decided then and there that I'd be doing video on computers. Got a job during college that put me in really cool video/film post house. Learned the entire process of working with film from developing, transferring to video, editing that video, then taking that edit back to film negative editing. Once it went full digital and streaming, because of my knowledge of how the post process works, I knew how to prep video to remove interlacing, 3:2 pulldown, etc for handing off to streaming platforms. That work can require a lot of custom code to automate. So when I get bored and burned out of the video engineering/coding jobs, I go back to production for a little while. When I get tired of being broke as an "artist", I go back to coding for money. Covid killed my last round of production work, so I went back to video engineering for couple of start ups. probably more than you really wanted to know, but that's it summed up in graph. i've learned that if a job requires working with a computer in any way, knowing how to bang code will come in handy even if it's not a coding job. just knowing how to automate a few things here and there makes cubicle life less mundane.