3 ms·
Tricky. Is it supposed to be Socrates speaking, or someone he interrogates? Plato's dialogues are full of speeches from people expounding theses that are themse
by marginalia_nu 4y ago
Tricky. Is it supposed to be Socrates speaking, or someone he interrogates? Plato's dialogues are full of speeches from people expounding theses that are themselves contradictory (and directly contradict Plato). There is for example a platonic dialogue that is chock full of convincing nonsense arguments, almost like a satire.
Both of them are nailing the ye olde Benjamin Jowett English.
The first one does seem possibly a bit at odds with some of his cosmology.
The second one seems superficially closer to some of his conclusions about the form of the good, but it also seems really internally inconsistent.
Some strange things:
First he asks:
> Is not beauty wise?
Then he bluntly asserts:
> For wisdom and beauty are the same, as I dare say that you yourself well know.
Plato usually isn't the one to just assert things like this. If this text is Plato's, it's definitely not one of Socrates' speeches.
> There is an inferior sort of wisdom which means caution, and is only a craft, and is concerned with the body; but the higher wisdom is the co-knowing of the soul, or is philosophy, and of this the intelligent is a part.
This also feels like it contains parts from a discussion about epistemology which is out of place when the topic is the forms, he typically contrasts crafts (techne) with knowledge (episteme). Here he just dismisses something as a craft completely out of the blue.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoExcellent analysis! Thank you.