4 ms·
It's hard to assess economic stability because big crises are low-probability events, but it doesn't seem obvious to me that Bretton Woods US (01944–01971) was
by kragen 4y ago
It's hard to assess economic stability because big crises are low-probability events, but it doesn't seem obvious to me that Bretton Woods US (01944–01971) was systematically less stable than the US after the switch to fiat money in 01971.
Certainly it was far more economically prosperous; the change to a fiat currency coincides with a widely-remarked drop in the GDP growth rate and an even more dramatic growth of inequality, to the point that the lowest quintile in the US has famously seen no real income growth since the switch to fiat money.
But that could easily be a coincidence, because many other things also changed. For example, the Bretton Woods period was a historically anomalous period during which the US was by far the world's dominant economic power; all the other advanced economies had been bombed to smithereens, the PRC and Russia were additionally crippled by communism, and the former colonies in India, Africa, and Latin America were only beginning to recover from colonialism. The dollar itself enjoyed the exorbitant privilege of being the backing for all other currencies. Plausibly the US's dominance during this period allowed it to strip resources from weaker powers in a way that dramatically enhanced its own economic growth, a way that is no longer possible.
Also, you could reasonably quibble that, rather than being a natural division between systems, comparing to Bretton Woods amounts to historical cherry-picking: it's been 51 years since the US transitioned to a fiat currency, and the preceding 51 years include the crash of 01929 and the Great Depression! Any period of world history is economically stable compared to a period embracing the Great Depression.
- Retric 4y agoI am suggesting you compare 1776-1971 vs 1971+ which is the opposite of cherry-picking. Ignoring all US history prior to 1944 is going to give you a very distorted view of what’s normal. Especially as Brenton Woods was a mixed system. The degree to which these differences are a function of various monetary systems is debatable, but it’s very hard to argue that fiat is worse on those timescales.
- kragen 4y agoI don't think it's very hard to argue that fiat is worse on those timescales; few if any fiat money systems have ever survived for a period of 195 years, like 01776–01971, without succumbing to at least one episode of hyperinflation. These are localized but generally worse than the Great Depression. We have numerous examples going back to the Yuan Dynasty, including four already this century: North Korea, Turkey, Venezuela, and most notoriously, Zimbabwe. You could of course argue that Turkey isn't the US: there are important differences between the countries. And that's true, and surely the differences are relevant to the risk of hyperinflation. But the US today isn't the US of 50 years ago, either — economically speaking, it has a lot less in common with the US of 01972 than with today's Turkey (PPP GDP US$37000 per capita).
- Retric 4y agoThe US monetary system didn’t survive for 195 years. We tried several different approaches because it kept failing spectacularly. The Copper Panic of 1789 for example went spectacularly bad. New Jersey in 1787 declared currency from other states was no longer valid and New York banned copper coins entirely. “At the height of the debasement, there was a 430% inflation rate for copper and commerce ceased, forcing several businesses and manufacturers to close down.[1][2]”
- kragen 4y agoWhile there were certainly crises, people's dollars from before the Copper Panic were still worth the same amount after it. The exception was paper money during the Civil War (not just Confederate, as I said!), which became valueless after it. And of course banknotes issued by banks that failed. There are lots of historical cases of debasement of coinage, yes.
- Retric 4y agoFirst dollars where worth too much for day to day commerce back then, the copper panic was a big deal. Also, the top 10 highest US annual inflation rates all occurred before fiat. 1813: 20.3% 1862: 14.8% 1863: 24.7% 1864: 24.6% 1917: 17.4% 1918: 18% 1919: 14.6% 1920: 15.6% 1947: 14.4%
- notch656a 4y agoI see we're allowed to pick arbitrary timescales for measuring inflation. Lets measure a few 50 year periods instead of annual periods: 1970-2020 : ~560% 1920-1970 : ~ 94% 1870-1920 : ~ 53% 1820-1870 : ~ 12% If memory serves, we went completely fiat in ~1974, or roughly the beginning of the 1970-2020 period.
- FabHK 4y agoInflation over half a lifetime is not really relevant. For investors, large savings should be in productive assets (debt or equity), and real rates (on bonds) or real returns (on shares) have been positive. For non-investors, real wages are much more important. But even including the high inflation in the 1970s and early 1980s (which Paul Volcker famously vanquished), that period from 1970 to 2020 averages less than 4% inflation a year. The four decades from 1982 to now have been pretty good on the inflation front. Which is much preferable to +20% one year, and deflation another year, as in decades prior.