4 ms·
Surely it is true that my own views are also influenced by partisan propaganda. :) However, I think a much stronger influence is that I understand elementary e
by kragen 4y ago
Surely it is true that my own views are also influenced by partisan propaganda. :) However, I think a much stronger influence is that I understand elementary economics, have lived outside Argentina, have operated an Argentine corporation, and have traded forex futures in real markets.
Certainly it is true that the agricultural sector is one of the most powerful in Argentina and that the real estate sector trades in dollars, but most of the rest of your comment is not even wrong, reflecting fundamental misunderstandings of a flat-earth level.
The assertion that the agricultural sector in Argentina is "speculating on the dollar" is incoherent. Speculating on the dollar is an activity dominated by big international investment banks and hedge funds, which make enormous leveraged bets on whether the dollar, the yen, the euro, or other real currencies will go up or down by 0.05%. The agricultural sector in Argentina is not able to do this because of legal prohibitions, and at any rate does not have nearly enough money to engage in the activity profitably.
When people in Argentina talk about the dollar "going higher" what they mean is that the fake Monopoly money we call the Argentine peso is losing value relative to the dollar, whose own changes in value are usually a rounding error by comparison, though not this year. Argentine pesos are an irresponsible speculative investment that are guaranteed to lose value; no prudent investor would hold them.
Anybody who owes debts denominated in Argentine pesos—most notably, the government—has a vested interest in inflation, the devaluation of the peso ("the dollar going higher"). Conversely, anyone who is owed debts denominated in Argentine pesos has a vested interest in the peso appreciating, or, since that's not going to happen, in the peso losing value more slowly. However, overall, the rampant inflation of the peso is one of the factors that makes the Argentine economy unstable and unproductive, which is the bigger factor in play here.
I suspect your reasoning is something along the lines of "the agricultural sector is a big exporter, so they get paid in dollars, so if those dollars are worth AR$600 instead of AR$300 then they make more money." But that is nonsense; if a dollar is "worth" AR$600 instead of AR$300, that's because the peso has lost half its value, so that AR$600 only buys you roughly the same amount of fertilizer, Monsanto seeds, farmhand labor, silage bags, etc., that you could have bought with the AR$300 without the additional inflation. Moreover when inflation is fast enough it becomes difficult to carry out any transactions at all.
It's relevant to point out to other readers that the official dollar, the fake value the exporters of agricultural as well as other goods get paid, is AR$129.25 × AR$137.25 today. That means that for every dollar of soybeans you export legally, you get paid AR$129.25, which is "worth" US$0.41. That is, the central bank confiscates 59% of your revenues (not your profits!) in order to subsidize imports and rich people going abroad for vacations. Unfortunately, soybeans are too bulky to smuggle out of the country.
Government confiscation of 59% of export revenues in order to subsidize Chinese imports goes a long way to explaining how we have ended up in such a terrible economic situation. Argentine makers trying to compete with Chinese imports have the central bank subsidizing 57% of the price of their foreign competition; Argentine consumers only pay 43% (137.25/316). So a hypothetical Argentine product of the same quality must be 57% cheaper than the Chinese product in order to compete. Government mandates of "Industria Argentina" result in companies importing fully manufactured products in kit form from China or Korea and paying unskilled workers a minimal amount to assemble the kits.
Export-led industrialization was the key policy that replaced poverty with prosperity in Taiwan, Japan, PRC, Korea, Indonesia, Singapore, and Malaysia. The Argentine currency policy has been precisely the opposite since *spit* Menem, with brief exceptions under Kirchner and *spit* Macri. Even back to Perón we focused on import substitution rather than exports, although actively sabotaging exporters with monetary policy seems to have started with Menem.
I don't have any idea how big the illegal dollar market is, and neither do you, but it evidently possesses significant liquidity. It has a high impact in people's minds because it's a reliable source of information about what the peso is actually worth; the government has not been a reliable source of that information since Kirchner coerced INDEC into falsifying the inflation numbers, a policy that has continued under Fernández de Kirchner, Macri, and Fernández and which was followed with the "cepo" policy of fake exchange rates that have gutted the Argentine economy over the past 11 years.
Hopefully that answers all of the questions you asked adequately; please feel free to ask for clarification if you feel that any of my answers were incomplete.
- mmustapic 4y agoHow can you say that the agricultural sector in Argentina speculating on the dollar is incoherent? For starters, if the dollar goes up, the inflation doesn't necessarily follow. Otherwise that means that the salaries (among other things) follow the dollar, and that's not true at all. Second, this whole week there were talks about a special exchange rate for the sector to tempt them to export more, because the government needs more dollars for energy imports. So by just waiting they get a better deal, that's clearly speculation. You can argue if this is right or wrong, if it's good or bad for the economy or the people, but speculation it is.
- kragen 4y agoWe're talking about exporters' reluctance to engage in transactions where they reduce a long position in the dollar in order to take a long position in the peso. The peso is an unstable speculative asset with extremely poor prospects of producing a return even in the short term. The dollar is, by contrast, a relatively stable currency, though much less so this year than for the previous 35 years, and though it, too, faces a continuous decline in its value. Holding pesos is speculative. It's not just speculation — it's speculation done badly and irresponsibly, like buying a lottery ticket, because the peso's prospects for increasing in value are quite poor indeed. Holding dollars is, by comparison, not speculative at all. We are facing a piece of absurd doublespeak in which "speculation" is being used to mean "refusing to foolishly invest in an unstable commodity", namely, the peso. Speculation in dollars is not impossible. You need servers in London, New York, or Tokyo that respond to second-by-second price changes, and you need access to forex markets with very, very tight spreads — otherwise the spread will give all of your potential speculative profits to market makers, because forex price movements in real currencies are fractions of a tenth of a percent most days. This is not what the agriculture sector in Argentina is doing. (Let's leave aside for the moment that this is also a transaction in which the central bank confiscates 59% of the value of the currency being traded in order to subsidize vacations abroad for the rich, and to subsidize imports so that they are impossible for Argentine domestic industry to compete with.) — ⁂ — Salaries and other prices do follow the dollar relatively closely, though there is both volatility and a secular decline in Argentina's productivity over time. The current salario mínimo is $45540 per month, which was US$210 earlier this month, though now it's US$150. (Presumably that will change in the next month or two.) When I moved to Argentina in 02006 it was $800, equal to about US$260. See https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anexo:Salario_m%C3%ADnimo_en_Argentina https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anexo:Salario_m%C3%ADnimo_en_A.... The minimum wage did not track the dollar perfectly; US$210 differs from US$260 by 24% (or 19% calculated the other way round — a 1.3% decline per year), but $800 would now be worth US$2.61, or US$3.70 earlier this month, and US$210 differs from US$3.70 by 5600%. 24% is a significant tracking error but it's insignificant compared to 5600%. This calculation understates the decline of the salario mínimo in real terms, because the dollar has experienced a total of 47% inflation since 02006, according to the US BLS CPI. US$1 in 02006 is US$1.47 today; 1.47 · US$260 · AR$216/US$ gives AR$82600 as the equivalent salario mínimo at the blue dollar rate earlier this month, and using today's mid-market blue dollar rate of AR$306/US$ it would be AR$117000. Over 16 years that's a 5.7% decline per year in the buying power of the salario mínimo, though obviously that's a very noisy estimate. I would welcome other salary data. For example, how has the median Argentine salary changed over this time? How about the mean salary, which is essentially the per capita GDP?