3 ms·
Here's my current PKM app rundown, from my own notes on the subject: # NotePlan 3 Pros: Native, and so nice to use. Cons: Bottom line: the author doubled the
by kstrauser 4y ago
Here's my current PKM app rundown, from my own notes on the subject:
# NotePlan 3
Pros: Native, and so nice to use.
Cons: Bottom line: the author doubled the subscription price in the upgrade from version 2 to 3, and is experimenting with doubling the price again to $120/yr. Few plugins.
# Obsidian
Pros: Tons of useful plugins. Huge community support.
Cons: Lacking daily notes like NotePlan and Logseq. Not native.
# Logseq
Pros: Data entry is very ergonomic.
Cons: As of 2022-07, still regularly seeing updates that fix data loss. Moving toward proprietary sync service? Not native.
# iA Writer
Pros: Native. Great UI. Already paid for it. One-time purchase.
Cons: Lacks daily notes. Just recently added wiki links. No backlinks. No plugin API or Shortcuts support. No Mermaid.js diagrams.
- hairofadog 4y agoI send iA Writer an email about once a year begging for the option to allow creating notes with date-stamped filenames (e.g. `2022-07-27.md`) but I think my emails are being redirected into the void. (They do have shortcuts support, though, for whatever it's worth...)
- kstrauser 4y agoI wrote a shortcut to create a new note every day, but admit it's a bit of a pain in the neck. Are you sure about Shortcuts support, though? It doesn't appear as a supported app in Shortcuts, and their website only documents x-callback-url.
- hairofadog 4y agoOh, I just use the x-callback-url – I guess I didn't realize there was another kind of Shortcuts support, sorry! They do have a couple of sample shortcuts for clipping web content: https://ia.net/writer/support/general/urlschemes#ios-shortcuts https://ia.net/writer/support/general/urlschemes#ios-shortcu... But yeah, I have one that creates a datestamped note, but it's not super useful if you're not already in the app.
- kstrauser 4y agoFor comparison, here's the list of Drafts's actions that can be automated directly from Shortcuts, all without crafting URLs: https://docs.getdrafts.com/docs/automation/shortcuts https://docs.getdrafts.com/docs/automation/shortcuts
- claytonjy 4y agoObsidian has daily notes, though as a Core Plugin which needs to be enabled in settings. I haven't used NotePlan or LogSeq, so maybe those daily notes are very different, but once I made a nice template I found Obsidian's to be quite nice.
- kstrauser 4y agoTo expand on that, NotePlan has beautiful daily note support, with built-in keystrokes for things like "go to yesterday's note", "go to tomorrow's note", or "move the currently selected action(s) to tomorrow's note (but keep a link back to today so that I can easily see the context in which those actions were originally written)". Obsidian has fine support for automatically creating a correctly named note, optionally pre-populated from a template, but lacks all the extra niceties. That's not a failure on its part, just something that it doesn't do as nicely out of the box as NotePlan.