4 ms·
> an "Email" that was identical to current email Please don't. Current email is a mess. One person's email client will set the email background to dark gray an
by mort96 4y ago
> an "Email" that was identical to current email
Please don't. Current email is a mess. One person's email client will set the email background to dark gray and another person's email client will have a dark grey background and the result will be unreadable. One person's email client will put the quoted text at the bottom and another person's client will put the quoted text at the top and the thread will be unreadable. A sender's email client will use quotes in a way which a receiver's client doesn't understand and the receiver's client will show a thread view where each message in the thread also contains a copy of all previous messages in the thread. The sender's email client will use a symbol font which the receiver doesn't have so that symbols look like random letters to the receiver.
Email is terrible. It does need to be radically overhauled. The lack of cryptography is far, far from its only problem.
Plus there's the spam problem, which means you won't be able to send email reliably unless you're a major company. It's federated, but only multinationals are allowed to play.
- layer8 4y agoI think the parent meant identical in concept, not in the technical format. All the valid points you raise could be fixed with a new format and related conventions without changing what email is conceptually (e.g. distributed threaded long-form asynchronous decentralized communication with Subject/To/Cc etc.), as opposed to turning it into a chat system.
- mort96 4y ago> I think the parent meant identical in concept, not in the technical format. That might be true. But I feel like a lot of email proponents have this idea that email is actually pretty good, when in reality, email is an unmitigated disaster and sorely needs drastic changes on the technical front.
- layer8 4y agoEmail is not a disaster in user communities with established conventions, such as B2B (and intra-B) communication and open-source/unix-oriented mailing lists. People in those communities see how systems like Slack and Discord and Signal are completely unsuitable to replace the email mode of communication, and therefore there is a pushback against those who push for such a replacement.
- mort96 4y agoYet for 99% of regular people, email is a complete disaster, and the people who are in extremely insular communities (such as certain FOSS projects) don't realize just how broken email is. There _is_ need for a replacement, since email plain doesn't work.
- layer8 4y agoI’m all for improving/replacing email with something that is the same in spirit and doesn’t constitute a regression for the user communities I mentioned (which at least in the B2B case are quite large). Making email Signal-like isn’t that, however.
- mort96 4y agoSure, I agree. A requirement for a replacement would be that it's federated, and that it's asynchronous (i.e not chat). Signal is neither. I just wish that the people who care about federation and asynchronicity weren't also the people who delude themselves into thinking that email is fine the way it is. (Case in point: my comment about the problems with email is downvoted, presumably by the exact kind of people I'm talking about.)