4 ms·
Solid point. The paper is a delta-mapper: it provides a p --> ∆p prior to posterior-change. However, it does not tell you anything about p or p'=p+∆p itself. To
by renewiltord 4y ago
Solid point. The paper is a delta-mapper: it provides a p --> ∆p prior to posterior-change. However, it does not tell you anything about p or p'=p+∆p itself. To get true value of p^n, we sum over all ∆p in some way (affected by the path we take through papers addressing).
You're modifying the thing so that future ∆p^{i+k} are added to the delta-mapper so that ∆p is appropriately modified accounting for that ∆p^{i+k}. It's like path-compression in a union-find structure.
It is interesting as a helpful approach but does suffer from the pingback spam problem, right? And I have a slightly sneaking suspicion that it is not an accidental oversight in science that leads to these problems.
- unlikelymordant 4y agoYou can always look at all the papers that cite the paper of interest. That provides the other direction deltas, and is something i do all the time, especially for older papers, looking for papers that might be relevant to me.
- renewiltord 4y agoAh, he was suggesting a "Reverse Bibliography" list on every paper, but we do, in fact, already have that: it's what you're talking about. The "cited in" section all the science search engines offer.
- hinkley 4y agoNot a full reverse list, just for the ones that tried to reproduce the results. The websites can handle the rest.
- renewiltord 4y agoI see. Everything that is "same experimental design" with the same starting hypothesis. I like it.