4 ms·
The Russian Economy Is Imploding
- unmole 4y agoThe IMF predicts the Russian economy will shrink by 6% in 2022. That's not what I'd call an implosion. The sanctions will obviously have long term effects but the reports of Russia's imminent economic collapse are greatly exaggerated.
- ben_w 4y agoHuh, looks like 6% is a recent forecast, explaining why I thought the predicted percentage was larger. Longer term, the EU is phasing out fuel purchasing from Russia as fast as it can, with an aim to do so by the end of the decade; as this is also tied (loosely) to environmental goals, that isn't likely to be undone even if the Russian government suddenly decided that they were wrong and everyone else was right, apologised for everything, and rebuilt all the damaged cities. If the EU had been able to instantly stop all their purchases from Russia, not just what they have stopped so far, I think that would've been an almost 15% hit to Russian GDP?
- codefreeordie 4y agoBeen hearing these stories since the first day of the war. Maybe it'll be true eventually, but so far it really seems like the west whose economies are in collapse mode
- quattrofan 4y ago
- jprd 4y agoCool. Any sort of defense of your contrarian opinion so we can better understand what you might be trying to communicate?
- codefreeordie 4y agoAt the risk of losing even more hard-won karma points, yeah. Now that it's been a few days and not so many drive-by downvoters are likely to notice. I don't know how things really are in the Russian economy -- propaganda is a hell of a drug, after all. All that I know for sure is that Russia has been "about to fall" for 140ish days according to the media, and it keeps not falling (and their currency is appreciating pretty well and has been the strongest major world currency for much of the summer). However, Western economies are actually doing quite badly, and the Russian war is a significant (but not the only) contributor to that. Europe is in a major energy crunch -- countries in the EU (especially Germany) are sufficiently worried about mass-casualty events caused by energy shortages over winter that they're taking extraordinary measures, including both reactivating long-idled coal power stations and making select train services free to encourage commuters not to use additional energy driving. Europe is enduring high inflation -- and particularly a very tight food market which is in danger of collapse over the winter. In an effort to offset that, the EU has begun importing foodstuffs from the US in larger quantities, including some items that normally are not seen as meeting the EU guidelines. As a result, even against the not-so-hot US dollar, the Euro has declined precipitously -- briefly crossing USD parity. Meanwhile here in the US, we have an increasing everything-shortage, the highest inflation in four decades, and an economy in recession. America will be able to feed it's people this winter, unless it exports a lot more food to Europe, but food prices are continuing to spiral out of control upward as many foodstuffs just aren't available in sufficient quantities to satisfy demand at ~any price. On top of all that, Western economies are trying to raise their central-bank interest rates to rein in inflation -- but the economies are all so dependant upon debt and deficit to remain afloat that monetary policy is heavily constrained (if interest rates were raised to the inflation rate -- generally the minimum intervention that would actually stop inflation -- then the interest on the debt would immediately decimate the government budget, due to catastrophic debt levels (which have little to do with the war)) So, ya, it's not like we are doing that well over here either -- but our propaganda says we are on the verge of victory -- just like Russia's propaganda says about them.
- gvb 4y agohttps://archive.ph/98879 https://archive.ph/98879
- bediger4000 4y agoThis is refreshing. Lately we've just been seeing "ruble best performing currency year to date" type of articles. It's always good to read a myth busting article, especially from a credible source like Foreign Policy
- unmole 4y ago> credible source like Foreign Policy I'm sorry, isn't much of Foreign Policy opinion pieces? I mean, it wouldn't be difficult to find pieces that make diametrically opposing claims. I don't understand why you'd consider it a credible source.
- coldtea 4y agoI think this one is similar to the "a dime a dozen" stories we get about how "China economy's collapsing" (either "already" or "any day now") which we've been getting also from "credible sources" like The Economist or Forbes, for 20 years... More wistful thinking than actual reporting, never mind, myth-busting. Quite similar to the "Apple is doomed" stories we were getting several times a year from major outlets (even NYT and such) from 2001 to circa 2018 or so (the seem to have slowed down now). There was always the "MacBook killer", the "iPod killer", the "iPhone killer", the "iPad killer" etc, which rarely ever gotten anywhere...
- bediger4000 4y agoThank you for noting that The Economist isn't always credible.
- coldtea 4y agoI admit it's no big feat ;-)
- Veliladon 4y agoThat's because the easy way to make your currency the best performing currency in the face of crisis is to stop as much capital outflow as possible. Sure your populace isn't going to have iPhones and some might starve but can you put a value on a propaganda victory?
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- verdverm 4y agoWhat does this do besides punish the general population? We know that a dictatorship can survive massive reductions to a country's economy, look no further than North Korea. Given Russia's vast reserves of natural resources, they will be able to build munitions, maybe not quality ones, but they aren't using those extensively anyhow. They can still rubble Ukraine, if they decide to mobilize and treat the "special operation" as a war. ...something I heard people smarter than me debating...
- Arnt 4y agoWhat it does, more than anything else, is diminish Russia's ability to replace the weapons, ammunition, trucks and other things it has lost, destroyed or worn out in the war. Russia has munitions stored. It lacks trucks to get that to the front.
- Veliladon 4y agoIt also attenuates or stops things like maintenance and parts manufacture. You can have as many shells as you want in storage but if the artillery keeps blowing the barrels out because they been used for 4000 shots without maintenance it the number of shells in the warehouse doesn't matter.
- verdverm 4y agoYou don't think they can start building trucks and tanks again, over the next few years? Do you think sanctions will hold up longer or prevent cooperation with China & India? It's not like it's a full, world-wide cancellation of Russia. More of a step in the direction of bifurcation
- Arnt 4y agoIn a few years, that is to say after the war, I'm sure they'll be able to import Bosch gearboxes again, and resume building the vehicles they built with those gearboxes. But not during the war. As part of a peace deal, yes. Something like "Ukraine gets all its territory back, Russia gets permission to buy gearboxes, bearings and other unexciting wonders of modern engineering".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]