3 ms·
> I have already been warned about engaging in flame war arguments Instead, posted insults. But it's fine if you want to start taking the high road. I'll forgi
by WalterBright 4y ago
> I have already been warned about engaging in flame war arguments
Instead, posted insults. But it's fine if you want to start taking the high road. I'll forgive you :-)
> your very incendiary claims that the land taken from other peoples was not in involved in wealth creation.
First off, if you read the known history of the indigenous peoples of America, they were constantly engaged in taking land from each other. (For example, read "The Commanche Empire" by Pekka Hamalainen.) Secondly, they lived at a subsistence level. This is not much in the way of wealth creation.
The Aztecs, Mayans, and Incas did go much further, and did create wealth from the land, but far less effectively than the Europeans did. They were also in Central and South America, not North America.
> also don’t think plundered land had anything to do with wealth creation
This is not what I wrote. I wrote that land is not required for wealth creation. It is not the common factor among wealthy economies. And whether it was plundered or not is irrelevant. (All land has been taken at some point in time.)
> It is not a reductio ab absurdum argument to ask you to give proof to a statement that you declared.
That's a misrepresentation of what I wrote about an office requiring land. Also, it is impossible to prove anything about economics. But what we can do is examine history. When we do, the common theme for highly wealth creating economies is free markets. Not land.