3 ms·
This doesn't strike me as quite as ridiculous as it did on first glance. One, you've got a giant vertical wall that can have building integrated PV for windows
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
This doesn't strike me as quite as ridiculous as it did on first glance.
One, you've got a giant vertical wall that can have building integrated PV for windows.
TWo, you've got a shaded area on the north side.
Three, they're building it partly undergound, which is good for hot climates.
Four, it's planned as a post-car, walkable city which in general is an exciting concept.
Five, it appears to be going for an enclosed living area, which is seen as dystopic by people who live in moderate climates, but has always made sense to me for regions with extreme weather (hot or cold) and doing it on a scale that might avoid the downsides of feeling like you're shut in.
Redundancy of infrastructure in a linear city strikes me as a potential problem, as is the fact that one end is near the sea and the other end just seems randomly inland. If there's some purpose to the location that I'm not aware of (joining two important places for example) then it's an interesting response to the 'organic' growth of sprawl that occurs when you have two cities linked by a fast communication route, by planning it in advance.
- wizwit999 4y agore location: Look at what country the city is nearest. hint I'm not talking about Jordan.
- lven 4y agoYes interesting. There are also good reasons to build cities in circles/squares. 1. Minimize the perimeter to area ratio. This minimizes the interface with the outside, such as protective walls and access points. On the other hand, in linear city, everyone gets a nice view, albeit basically the same view. 2. Minimize distance between points. Putting everything on a line means increases the distance for point to point trips. In a 2d city, things are closer together. In a 3d city, even more so. This affects travel, networks, etc. Important / highly frequented things will cluster in the middle. 3. Enhance resilience. If there's a roadblock or problem in a linear city, the whole thing gets blocked. In a 2d city, you can usually just reroute around. This applies to travel, sewage, grid, etc blockages. Linear city is just asking for single point failures. Many of these points fall apart when you consider American cities are built kind of like 1d cities around highways and such. The linear city is just admitting it upfront.
- Ekaros 4y agoOn 1. now I wonder what is the optimal width for this type of city in place it is build. If we are thinking of protection from things like sand storms or other effects. As at somepoint the walls stop covering what is on other side of them. Unless we are talking about old-school fortications.
- ncmncm 4y agoOne micron. Needs flat people, though. Flatten people!
- s1artibartfast 4y ago>2. Minimize distance between points. Putting everything on a line means increases the distance for point to point trips. In a 2d city, things are closer together. In a 3d city, even more so. This affects travel, networks, etc. Important / highly frequented things will cluster in the middle. higher dimensions also increases the length public infrastructure laid down and number of routes. connecting a 5x5 grid needs twice as as many lines as a 1x25 grid.
- ncmncm 4y agoSomebody looked at elevators and thought, "This is perfect: everything that moves should be an elevator!" But the whole world would need to be in a straight line. "This is perfect: we'll make everybody live in a line!" And, not realize that elevators move in a straight line because they hang on a cable. If you lay it on its side, it becomes a train, and can go anywhere the tracks bend to.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoGenerally train tracks bend because they have to, not because they want to. One of the things holding high speed rail back is the turning circle needed at high speed not fitting in existing rights of way, which were as straight as they could get away with at the time of building. And the inability to now just purchase a right of way directly between the two points of interest because it's owned by lots of different people. If you were building a traditional circular city and rail at the same time, the main trains would radiate out in lines as straight as the terrain allows and you'd probably spend a great deal of money building bridges and tunnels to make that possible if the terrain wasn't flat. If you were building two cities from scratch, and owned all the land between them, you'd almost certainly build a direct train line as straight as possible between them.
- estiaan 4y agoAny light that is passing through a pv/window is not being converted into electricity, a solar panel that is both a window and a PV cell is not good at doing either If you make that window reflective, now you have a bad mirror, a bad solar panel and a bad window
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoDo you like the new tinted windows I fitted to my car? That's just weak light transmission! You made a bad window, Petey!