4 ms·
Categories are an excellent idea if the system is small enough and everybody using it is familiar with the convention. It's just that you have to accept they ar
by BiteCode_dev 4y ago
Categories are an excellent idea if the system is small enough and everybody using it is familiar with the convention. It's just that you have to accept they are flawed, unaccurate, partial and biased.
That doesn't mean they are not useful.
Think about supermarket scales: each vegetable or fruit is in a single category. The category is flawed, but nobody wants to have to type a precise list of tags to filter what they need. You want to go to vegetable and chose tomatoes, not to have a inner debate about the tomatoes taxonomy. Isn't a fruit? Wait, is fruit a biology thing or a commercial concept? I don't care, give me my damn tomatoes!
It's the same for my notes. Some stuff are in weird directories. But I know how I sort them out, so I can find them quickly. I don't want to have to be precise or accurate, only find what I need.
Category don't replace tags, buts tags are mainly useful for advanced searches and filtering. Anyway, the best systems out there consider a category as a tag, just the main tag.
- ethbr0 4y agoIs anyone aware of classifiers that work well on {content text} + {tag collection} + {search history} and generate categories? Specifically something that would be usable on personal notes. Categories seem incredibly useful at exploration-time, but impossible to write at creation-time. Tags seem incredibly easy to write at creation-time, but aren't useful at exploration-time. Why not both, with a fuzzy link between them?
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoMy go to is to consider that the first tag is the category, or the directory it's in. Depending on the system, you may reverse it: the category is the main tag.
- xhevahir 4y agoI don't have any kind of system for notes, but I've found the "tagmash" feature on LibraryThing to be useful: https://blog.librarything.com/2007/07/tagmash/ https://blog.librarything.com/2007/07/tagmash/