5 ms·
Battery buses are a solution ahead of their time. Any old bus is better than car-based transportation, so shifting modes from car to bus is more important than
by jeffbee 4y ago
Battery buses are a solution ahead of their time. Any old bus is better than car-based transportation, so shifting modes from car to bus is more important than changing the energy source of the bus. If shifting from car to bus is impossible because of built environment, that's the first priority. Buses powered by batteries should be way down at the end of the TODO list.
If you absolutely insist on having buses that aren't direct sources of CO2, fuel cells are a more mature technology that makes more sense than batteries.
- txsoftwaredev 4y agoA bus is only better if it is full of passengers, which is not always the case.
- dumpsterlid 4y agoYah precisely the point. We should focus on making busses comfy and nice and on getting good coverage with bus routes so that people use them. Worry about them being electric later, the environmental impact of less people driving far overshadows the impact of ev vs gas busses.
- pineconebutt 4y ago
- absolutelynobo 4y agoThe stunning failure of Nikola or any other large-scale fuel cell company other than Toyota to deliver working FC vehicles really calls into question your characterization of hydrogen as “more mature” than batteries. Every FC vehicle is also an EV, just FYI. One would also wonder why China has ~0 fuel cell buses and tens of thousands of electric buses if FC is the more mature tech.
- jeffbee 4y agoMy city has a large fleet of fuel cell buses and has had them for over a decade, which suggests you don’t know what you are talking about.
- absolutelynobo 4y agoSo you’re saying that the the unnamed town you’re in bought a few FC buses 10 years ago and is still maintaining them today? That’s great, but it’s also an anecdote. Have they bought any recently? Have neighboring towns bought in as well?
- jeffbee 4y agoI see that you are doubling down on the “don’t know what you’re talking about” aspect of this debate. My local transit agency is AC Transit. It serves millions of people in several large cities. Last year it ordered fifty more fuel cell vehicles from its suppliers. https://www.actransit.org/zeb https://www.actransit.org/zeb
- absolutelynobo 4y agoThank you for sharing that link, Jeff! It’s neat to see that ACT is going for a 70% hydrogen, 30% electric mix. Their page has a unbiased-sounding section on it: > We will be running hydrogen and battery electric vehicles in identical service to collect real-world performance data for comparison—and to determine which technology performs better to meet the needs of our service as we move towards a complete zero-emission fleet by 2040. It looks like they started the hydrogen bus project 20 years ago, not ten.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoBuses and other "same route local delivery" type vehicles are a prime candidate for electrification TODAY because the short and known daily mileage plus always returning to the same spot at downtime sidesteps a lot of the range/charger problems that push EV to be just barely not viable enough for other cases.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KaiserPro 4y agoI suspect that you don't live in europe. In london, buses are a massive source of particulate and nitrogen pollution. We've had hybrid buses for a good 5 years, some hydrogen ones as well (but only one or two routes) However london has rolled out 100% electric buses in the last 3 years, and they've not caught fire at a faster rate than the diesel ones.
- jeffbee 4y agoIn London that makes sense because they already have a decent mode share. I suspect the bus mode share in Hamden, Connecticut is 1% or less.
- KaiserPro 4y agofor demand that makes sense, for justification of using EV or not, I don't think it really makes a difference.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- velcrohacker 4y agoAny sources to support the claim that fuel cells are more mature? Looking at another aspect, how many hydrogen generation facilities are there in CT, vs. facilities that can charge an electric bus?