3 ms·
This is arguably one of the big problems with the Internet today. On the one hand, browser automation is extremely effective and nearly indistinguishable from
by marginalia_nu 4y ago
This is arguably one of the big problems with the Internet today.
On the one hand, browser automation is extremely effective and nearly indistinguishable from human traffic, and bot traffic often eclipses that of human visitors, depending on what you're serving, consuming an enormous amount of resources.
On the other hand, using IP-reputation to decide who gets a captcha is one of the few methods that undeniably works. It's really unfair and I wish it didn't have to be that way, but at least for my websites, I can't serve traffic to human visitors if I don't discriminate against these IP blocks with captchas and whatever. I just don't have the hardware. The bot traffic I get is something like 50x that of sitting at #1 on the HN front page.
- humanistbot 4y ago> On the other hand, using IP-reputation to decide who gets a captcha is one of the few methods that undeniably works For a particular definition of "works." Giving everyone a captcha would also "work", but with different tradeoffs.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoWell of course, shutting down the server works too, I mean works in the context of reducing false positives while very effectively blocking most bots.
- 3np 4y agoI've been thinking a bit abut trying out something different here. What I have in mind would be an alternative method that the user can opt for instead of the captcha (if flagged). It would be for those privacy people on Tor or Mullvad or what have you and will not compromise on privacy but may be a bit more techy/involve some form of crypto (no investments or new coins etc tho). So you'd still have the CAPTCHA of today but with an alternative. Assuming it's something that would seem to be a usable and smoother solution for those people you are today locking out or providing a hassle for without significant increase of malicious bots (maybe you'll even get less if it works all right and it means you can tune up the aggressiveness in the rest of the system), about how much willing would you be to try something out? (I'm aware of PrivacyPass but IME while I did have it work at times, most of the time it works extremely poorly to the point of being unusable on both Cloudflare and hCapctcha, while maintenance and support seem on the backburner)