3 ms·
I never understood why CDE/Motif was chosen over OLVWM/OpenView since the latter was both nicer looking and much easier to use.
by rwmj 4y ago
I never understood why CDE/Motif was chosen over OLVWM/OpenView since the latter was both nicer looking and much easier to use.
- shrubble 4y agoSun was the big gorilla in the marketplace and CDE was based on non-Sun technology. CDE rose out of HP Vue window manager. Motif was considered to be a good choice; some say it is easy to program.
- ben7799 4y agoMotif was pretty horrific to program. It was full of what we would recognize as pointer abuse today. I was always a little upset when Gtk took off in the late 90s, because it had a bunch of similar pointer abuse. It seemed to be heavily influenced by Motif. Qt seemed much better at the time. Java UI (Swing) clearly seemed a big step forward at the time. Tk was pretty nice at the time. A lot of the X stack back then had this kind of stuff. At some point it probably got cleaned up.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoYeah and Sun was never really seemed fully on board with the whole CDE thing anyway. They dropped it for their horribly slow Java desktop environment as soon as they could. Not sure how IBM fared but I think HP-UX had it for longer until they dropped it in 11i
- technothrasher 4y agoBack in the 90's, I felt the exact opposite. Motif was much better looking and easier to use than Open Look. These days they both look pretty dated.
- hulitu 4y agoAs far as i remember there were 2 organizations which tried to standardize UNIX: X/Open and Open Look. One had IBM, DEC , HP in it the other SUN and AT&T. One choose Motif/CDE, the other OpenLook. In the end the OL people gave up and everibody went CDE under the OpenGroup umbrella.
- occoder 4y agoTo me it's the exact opposite, OpenLook was just UGLY. CDE/Motif didn't look that great either, but it was at least serviceable. It's very telling that no one at Sun would look at OpenLook and recognize it as ugly. Sun was an engineering company, the entire company, from the CEO on down, had no taste. Exhibit #2: the Java Metal look and feel, almost repulsively ugly, yet no one at Sun saw anything wrong.
- pipeline_peak 4y agoIf I had to guess it's because CDE had a more modern, desktop oriented design that the newer generation of Unix users, specifically PC users would be attracted to. Straight window managers require a lot more tinkering and have steeper learning curves.