3 ms·
> Yes coal mines are horrible. However, reclaimed mines are not worse for the environment than literally replacing equivalent acreage with a blanket of monolith
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
> Yes coal mines are horrible. However, reclaimed mines are not worse for the environment than literally replacing equivalent acreage with a blanket of monolithic fused-silicon solar collectors (under which, there is no environment).
Citation very much needed.
For starters, assuming we're mining the coal in order to burn it, rather than just for rock collectors, then the pollution and waste from that activity alone is enough to make it worse than solar. Killing more people, and animals, and destroying more environment while also costing more money.
You claim you're not the kind of person to minimize how bad coal is, but that's exactly what you're doing.
We don't need to do what you're suggesting (there's plenty of sensible places to put solar PV) but even if we did I would be highly surprised if it was worse than coal mining.