4 ms·
Ew. Why are all the chip manufacturers going along with this stupid plan? I want to buy a processor and then own it and have it work in my best interests, not
by metadat 4y ago
Ew. Why are all the chip manufacturers going along with this stupid plan? I want to buy a processor and then own it and have it work in my best interests, not consume electricity and generatie heat enforcing draconian 3rd party DRM policies.
- paxys 4y agoBecause Apple
- gjsman-1000 4y agoIt's tragic (especially if you care about general-purpose computing and the future of open platforms), and a sign that Microsoft's Palladium project was never really canceled. Boil the frog... Of course, Microsoft would say it's not about DRM (at least right now), it's for "security." Which... its secure as Microsoft's servers are, to be sure.
- intelVISA 4y agoNext-Generation Secure Computing my ass.
- kimmeld 4y agoThe market (software/system builders) say that locked down platforms like the iPhone are fabulously profitable. Sorry.
- metadat 4y agoLol, cargo-cult chip fabbing. What's next? I can't even fathom.. maybe this inability on my part is a blessing in disguise.
- arlcode 4y agoAnd that's why the road to a better software ecosystem is not some hackers smart trick to defeat the system for the moment but very clear rules of what is allowed to be done in the name of security and what isn't A legislative piece of paper (or many pieces of paper) have the power to reign in corporations far far beyond any technical solution or workaround. And yes, that requires limiting (intellectual) property rights and regulating what certain contracts can enforce. Sometimes it's needed if you ask me In my experience this sentiment is rejected primarily by many technical people because it feels like adding the human factor to a pristine world of logic. In reality it's humans all the way down and there is no reason to believe that Microsoft/Apple is a better steward than an elected body of representatives acting according to the rule of law
- 0xedd 4y agoSo is war. Don't reproduce.
- Ruq 4y agoDon't Reproduce?
- smaudet 4y ago
- metadat 4y agoSimple solution: don't care about up or down -votes. Believe me, Internet points are a sham and waste of time. Focus on interesting conversations and connections instead.
- smaudet 4y agoAgreed. However, interesting conversations are missed because of noise (e.g. down-votes) - I'm less likely to interact with a down-voted post, they usually are not as informative or interesting. Proposed solution - abolish negative points entirely, points should be per-thread, not per user. If a user is causing frequent problems (frequently downvoted), per admin review then issue ban/rate limits, etc. I view the positive/negative points mostly as a sentiment rating - if I receive downvotes I can tell my point is unpopular/uncontroversial, if not I know someone found it interesting. That does affect how I post in two ways: I make more effort to expose common context for posts which are down-voted, people who are lazy and don't care won't read the expanded post, people who are more open-minded (the ones I want to attract and start conversations with) are more likely to come around to my viewpoint, or at least offer more interesting conversation (disagreement is necessary to have a discussion). So I find both positive and negative votes to be useful, even on my own posts. Even the manner in which I've been down-voted recently tells me something, and it tells me valuable data about who has which opinions.
- throwaway14356 4y agoIt is much worse than he thinks. If I was to write out the worse case scenario the MS employee would have no choice but to consider it. Therefore win 13 will be a theme for ubuntu packaged with a FOSS version of office. MS will award large weekly prizes for the most useful FOSS app extending the eco system. It will be sold on multi TB external drives that work like live USB only daisy chained. Weekly new releases cramped with so much free stuff every neck beard around the world must own all of them. A few movies, some music, a game or 2. Each comes with a poster, a t shirt and a book. Prices go up and down using RNG making some releases rare and hard to get.
- MikusR 4y agoIntel started putting ME in their cpus 12 years ago.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoand yet, without any evidence, huawei is being blamed for "spying".... smh
- superchroma 4y agoIt's not mutually excusive. I think risks from hostile powers need to be called out, and I think we also need to be calling out this bad behavior on our side too.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe US is a hostile power everywhere else in the world. And then also for about 4-8 out of every 8 years to its own citizens.
- oarsinsync 4y ago> And then also for about 4-8 out of every 8 years to its own citizens. And you can pretty much guarantee that ~50% of the population will always consider that statement true, no matter the government of the day.
- ahartmetz 4y agoPeople should generally be most afraid of their own government - it's the one that is allowed to use violence where they live.
- cesarb 4y ago> People should generally be most afraid of their own government - it's the one that is allowed to use violence where they live. Be careful to not forget the distinction between "being allowed to" and "being able to". There are documented cases of countries (including the USA) using violence against people even when they aren't the government where these people live.
- Analemma_ 4y agoThe conspiratorial answers here are emotionally satisfying, but ultimately wrong. The reason chip makers and OS vendors are adding this is customer demand, by which I mean enterprises. Companies want remote attestation and guaranteed-immutable OS images on their networks, and I honestly can't say I blame them. In a perfect world they could have it and we could somehow firewall it away from the consumer space entirely, but that's not going to happen.
- synapse26 4y agoHaven’t looked at the Intel space, but doesn’t AMD have an “PRO” tier available for OEM only? Ryzen Pro, Threadripper Pro… Or Nvidia and their segmented RTX/GTX vs Quadro. These hardware companies love segmentation, let them have it, do that for PRO enterprise only, leave my personal use, no remote attestation, immutable OS needed PC alone.
- walterbell 4y agoOn-premise, open-source, customer-owned remote attestation servers are possible. Avoid outsourcing integrity verification to 3rd-party clouds.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wmf 4y agoThe same enterprises asking for this stuff are also asking for it to be taken out of their hands because they don't trust themselves to operate it securely or reliably.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoIt sounds like you can still do that. Other people will get to decide if you can use their services with your device, but (unlike an iPhone, for example) it's still your device to do as you please with.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoBecause owning your device is a nice bedtime story we've been told for quite some time now since the iPhone became the norm.
- dragonelite 4y agoBecause China and Russia might be hacking your hardware. Don't people listen when a guy like Pompeo speaks he has pretty much outlined the plan with his Clean Network Initiative, I wouldn't be surprised that within a decade CloudFlare and other US cloud services will be used as the great firewall of the western sphere.
- fithisux 4y agoAre there proofs for the easterners? Because for the westerners they are plenty.
- goodpoint 4y ago> Why are all the chip manufacturers going along with this stupid plan? Because the music/movie industry benefits from DRM and made agreements with the software and hardware industry. Also NSA and the military complex benefit enormously from having control over hardware around the world.
- boppo1 4y agoAlphabet soup, probably, along with iphone profitability.
- autoexec 4y ago> Ew. Why are all the chip manufacturers going along with this stupid plan? Because if they don't add whatever garbage Microsoft orders them to include in their chips then Microsoft can simply require that shit for the next version of their OS to boot. They could even force an update on existing PCs to check for it. Nobody is going to buy a chip if having it means they can't run the OS that 99% of computers on the plant are using. If Intel dared to say no, MS could pretty much run them out of business.
- aquova 4y agoThis works both ways however. No one is going to buy the OS that can't even run on their latest chip. Microsoft can make all the demands they want, but the chip manufacturers still have the power to refuse to implement it; if Microsoft wants to brick their own OS, that's not their problem.
- autoexec 4y ago> No one is going to buy the OS that can't even run on their latest chip. Unless that latest chip is vastly superior to what we have today, almost nobody is going to care. Most people couldn't tell you which chip is in their computer right now. They don't even care what a processor is. They just want to be able to click on the little picture that makes facebook happen and they don't want to have to learn anything new to make that happen. If every chip manufacturer refused, you're right that we'd be pretty safe, but the moment they can get just one chip manufacturer on board every OEM will buy those chips or go out of business. Intel was "evil inside" decades ago for a reason, so we knew how this was going to play out.