6 ms·

I raised my kids on the command line and they love it

65 points by CalRobert 4y ago

boberoni 4y ago
Raising a child to use computers via command line is very interesting. I would want my child to be tech-savvy, but most parents I see make the mistake of just giving their kids an iPad. I think it's very destructive to their attention span. On the other hand, having a cheap laptop with only access to TUIs could be used for improving reading skills and tech literacy. Add some TUI games like the good ol' days of BASIC, and it can be just as entertaining as an iPad.
- dzhiurgis 4y ago
  If iPad had ability to act like a screen for RPI that would awesome - portable, battery powered, versatile, etc.
  - tingol 4y ago
    You mean like a laptop?
  - maicro 4y ago
    I've installed noVNC on a Pi before, didn't try accessing it through an iPad and I don't recall if I was using desktop or just terminal, BUT, I think something like noVNC could get you close to iPad-as-RPI-screen. Add in some VPN functionality and you can keep the Pi running at home, but use the iPad anywhere you can get online (though now you're getting into diminishing returns).
  - vincent-manis 4y ago
    I use my iPad Pro as a remote terminal to an RPi 400 and an Odroid N2+. Both of these machines are running xrdp, and I use the Microsoft Remote Desktop client on the iPad. RDP seems somewhat faster than VNC.
    - rcarmo 4y ago
      RDP is much faster than VNC because it has improved compression and latency management. Also, it is its own X server generally, and not a bolt-on, so less overhead.
  - user00012-ab 4y ago
    what do you actually want to do? I have https://github.com/coder/code-server https://github.com/coder/code-server and https://jupyter.org/hub https://jupyter.org/hub running on a PI, along with tailscale on the ipad and pi. This allows the IPAD to have a full editor, and a shell onto the pi.
    - dzhiurgis 4y ago
      Have RPI as command line computer - keyboard & screen only and maybe gradually grow into gui. Probably easier to buy rugged laptop or old thinkpad and install linux)
themodelplumber 4y ago
Geez, it sounds like a really good bonding activity and discussion format they've got going there. I'd be excited too. My son once asked me as I was walking down the hall, "dad, how do I install Steam?" I walked in his room and he had a very prominently placed terminal open, where I saw that he was typing "sudo apt install steam". I practically core dumped in shock. "Whoa buddy! Wow!" and of course that's what he was going for, since he has the affinity-vibe concept absolutely locked down and has had this gift ever since birth as far as I can tell. Half or even most of that typing was just to synchronize with dad's values and build affinity. I respect it and I also, knowing that it's not _exactly_ 100% terminal love, don't push the terminal too hard unless it's related to a specific goal of his. Meanwhile my other kids get up and leave for a snack as soon as I open the terminal on their desktops (it saves me time, they get that). But they are on the other hand really good at introducing COTS thinking into our household. :-) Sometimes you gotta go with the social tech bell curve. Just go buy the thing that does what you want! Duh! And I agree, you can define this as rationality itself in fact. Tinkering, scripting...irrational in some ways for sure, so good thing we have other ways of discussing its value. Speaking of uh, typing, I was just today remembering one of the most scary experiences my kids and I have ever had, playing this roguelike game together... http://www.roguebasin.com/index.php/AliensRL http://www.roguebasin.com/index.php/AliensRL
- dvfjsdhgfv 4y ago
  > sudo apt install steam Kudos to the parent for teaching them the modern form; I still see people using apt-get for no reason.
  - booi 4y ago
    Same reason people keep using cat or dd, just habit and millions of old docs google has enshrined telling them to.
    - tpoacher 4y ago
      not me. I use tac | tac instead.
    - 4y ago
pomatic 4y ago
(2013) -- it would be interesting to know what became of those kids and where they are at today.
- CalRobert 4y ago
  He responded here! https://twitter.com/jgoerzen/status/1552128838339010562 https://twitter.com/jgoerzen/status/1552128838339010562 Sounds like they're doing well.
- darknavi 4y ago
  Some say they are still stuck in VIM after dad wouldn't tell them how to exit it.
remarkEon 4y ago
I also plan on doing this, but haven’t had the time yet to put together the actual “plan” per se, other than lots of raspberry Pis and a screen to connect to in the family room. My main motivation for doing this, I suppose, is that being a millennial I got to straddle the analog-to-digital divide growing up, and I think that experience path with technology is healthy because you tend to view it as a tool and less so the basis for your entire existence.
- txbuck 4y ago
  I don't plan on having kids of my own, but if life finds a way (or I end up with custody of a relative's children) I figured I would similarly put together some kind of loose "curriculum" to guide them along if they took an interest in computing. Never actually planned it out - is a pretty large domain of knowledge to cover for something I don't currently plan on using, but I wouldn't be surprised if there are already pre-existing FOSS resources along those lines. Anybody know of any projects in the same vein?
gwbas1c 4y ago
In other news: I taught my children how to hook up the buggy to the horse. Then I pulled out my great grandfather's Model T and worked them through how to adjust the spark and planning their stops because it didn't have normal brake pads. Then I taught them how to drive stick in a car that requires double-clutching because it doesn't have synchromesh... I honestly don't "get" this need to raise our children with a state of technology like we had when we were kids. My kids use tablets, and when they want/need to use a full powered computer I'll just show them how to use one.
- s_dev 4y ago
  >In other news: I taught my children how to hook up the buggy to the horse. Then I pulled out my great grandfather's Model T and worked them through how to adjust the spark and planning their stops because it didn't have normal brake pads. You joke but a lot of learning comes from things like this. >I honestly don't "get" this need to raise our children with a state of technology like we had when we were kids It's basically like if I want to understand unix better -- I actually find tutorials written in the 70/80s much better than some of the stuff you see on YouTube or more modern tutorials -- even with all there inaccuracies in terms of getting to grip the core concepts it often gets straight to the point.
  - omnibrain 4y ago
    >It's basically like if I want to understand unix better -- I actually find tutorials written in the 70/80s much better than some of the stuff you see on YouTube or more modern tutorials Or even the 90ies/early 2000. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32013779#32015159 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32013779#32015159
- olddustytrail 4y ago
  The real problem with your analogy is that the command line is more advanced than the GUI. That's why advanced users use it and beginners do not. To borrow an expression: reading and writing is more advanced than pointing and grunting.
- deleted 4y ago
  [deleted]
enriquto 4y ago
In my case, it started wonderfully, until they learned that they could just launch firefox from the terminal, and proceed to stupid prank videos on youtube. When they log-in, all that they see is an xterm (no menus, no icons). And they just arrow-up+enter to run their previous command that is invariably firefox. I tried disabling youtube on the hosts file and let them figure it out, but apparently is too large a step to make yet. Sigh.
- kibwen 4y ago
  Don't despair, you're on the right track. You just need to keep erecting increasingly elaborate artificial obstacles, one tiny increment at a time, and by the time they're teenagers they'll be manually linking together their own custom OS from scratch every time they want to watch stupid prank videos on their homemade reimplementation of Firefox.
  - nominusllc 4y ago
    mitm their requests and make everything render backwards or in 144p. Make it interesting. My parents would give me challenges like taking the cord to the computer, and they'd find increasingly elaborate improvised power cables. It took my mom 5 years to realize why the treadmill only worked 'sometimes'.
    - tym0 4y ago
      My dad (an IT person) had set specific time during the day when my computer was allowed to access the internet on the router. One day I asked him to login from my computer to whitelist my brother's connection, I had installed a keylogger to grab the login and change the config. Don't think he ever caught on.
- hulitu 4y ago
  You can help them a bit: alias firefox=lynx in .bashrc
stevenalowe 4y ago
That’s the saddest thing I’ve read in a long time. Children excited about a mouse … because they’ve never used an iPad.
gnicholas 4y ago
My kid is never more fascinated than when she sees me inspecting HTML or using the terminal. I wouldn't ever push a CLI on her, but she is genuinely more interested in learning about computers when she's staring at a screen of text she doesn't understand. We've started doing an HTML tutorial, and her initial enthusiasm seems to have generated enough momentum that she's now excited about what we can do using these previously-daunting text-based tools.
CalRobert 4y ago
I'm surprised how many people are dismissive of learning the command line like it's obsolete. I still use the command line constantly and would be lost without it, and I'd like my kids to understand what's going on better than they can with a desktop environment. I have a 4 year old and found an old Raspberry pi earlier and decided to hook it up to the TV. She was thrilled (and spent plenty of time using a keyboard and mouse for the first time. She liked it! And we don't hide her from technology) Just because we have calculators doesn't mean learning to do math on paper is a bad idea. I was only slightly older than her in the late 80's when we got a 286 and I learned to do `cd games` `dir` `some_game.exe` etc. and I learned the very basics of what a file/directory structure (something a lot of young adults don't understand) is, among other things. Some games meant editing autoexec.bat and that was helpful for understanding system config. Obviously I'm not looking for autoexec now but just understanding that such a config exists is useful.
- gnicholas 4y ago
  > the very basics of what a file/directory structure (something a lot of young adults don't understand) My dad is confused by the false-skeuomorphism of the word "file". He thinks of them as containers, since this is how "file" is used in the paper sense ("hand me the file on Mrs. Anderson"). So when he's describing something on the computer, he will often refer to a folder as a "file", which can be confusing even though I know he uses this term in this way.
  - mixmastamyk 4y ago
    True, and yet computer files can be containers as well.
    - gnicholas 4y ago
      Good point, thought not as far as my father's computer use is concerned!
      - mixmastamyk 4y ago
crusty 4y ago
Without passing judgement on the value of the approach, I'd caution against taking to much away from those method, considering the sample bias of the forum here. I can't help but think the relevant distinction between leading paths of easing your kids into computers with a bash shell vs. hanging them an iPad and a Chromebook might have more to do with the manner and knowledge of the person they turn to when they have questions. The OP's kid asked "what does install mean?" Does it really matter whether he was trying to install htop, ncdu, Zoom, Roblox, or TikTok? Or does it matter more the positive affect of the OP's response and the deep well of knowledge and understanding that he could pull from in formulating an answer? A busy mostly tech-illiterate parent may interpret that question as a "how" question and simply respond, "go to the app store - that's the blue button with the weird 'A' - open it and type R O B L O X. Let me know if you still can't get it." that's not the answer to the question and offers no opportunity for follow on questions, but if you don't really know yourself, you can't really answer.
pcthrowaway 4y ago
I'm astounded that the author's 2-year old son is not only reading, but typing. Is this not outrageously young to be capable of reading, writing, and typography? I thought age 6 is the standard age at which children start reading, but perhaps this has changed with so much socialization happening online now
- qayxc 4y ago
  According to some parenting sites, "But before their third birthday, most 2-year-olds are able to put three-word sentences together." So yeah, I call BS on that one.
- rowanG077 4y ago
  Might just be a very early learner. Although 2 is very young I think.
- BackBlast 4y ago
  My three year old could log into her user account on the computers. She was a month shy of 4. It was the first letters of her name. She could also click on her name. And get into Minecraft from there. I thought it was pretty early for the feat. She is well into 4 now, still can't really "read" yet but she can identify surprising individual words. Plays Minecraft as well as her older siblings for the most part. Still a favorite.
- schwartzworld 4y ago
  I learned to read at 2, if my mother is to be believed.
user00012-ab 4y ago
You'll be able to tell when it really clicks for them when they end up removing xmonad from their machines replacing it with i3.
Protostome 4y ago
I think this is a super cool idea. I have been thinking how to introduce my children to a computer for some time now. They are both also very young - 3 and 5 and currently have very limited interaction with screens. No tablets/console/PCs at all and TVs only during the weekend for 2-3 hours. I love the fact that their favorite games are LEGO and board games and I'm concerned that introducing a PC to their life will immediately take over everything else. I want them to be familiar with other STEM based "toys" before they put their hands on a PC - A couple of days ago I ordered a microscope from Amazon (the expensive kind that is able to view individual cells) and we are going to prepare slides from samples that we'll take from a nearby pond. At the end of the day, I want them to develop curiousity and fascination towards nature and science. I still haven't figured out completely how to do it with PCs/tablets without getting down a slippery slope

65 points by CalRobert 4y ago

Raising a child to use computers via command line is very interesting. I would want my child to be tech-savvy, but most parents I see make the mistake of just giving their kids an iPad. I think it's very destructive to their attention span. On the other hand, having a cheap laptop with only access to TUIs could be used for improving reading skills and tech literacy. Add some TUI games like the good ol' days of BASIC, and it can be just as entertaining as an iPad.

dzhiurgis 4y ago
If iPad had ability to act like a screen for RPI that would awesome - portable, battery powered, versatile, etc.
- tingol 4y ago
  You mean like a laptop?
- maicro 4y ago
  I've installed noVNC on a Pi before, didn't try accessing it through an iPad and I don't recall if I was using desktop or just terminal, BUT, I think something like noVNC could get you close to iPad-as-RPI-screen. Add in some VPN functionality and you can keep the Pi running at home, but use the iPad anywhere you can get online (though now you're getting into diminishing returns).
- vincent-manis 4y ago
  I use my iPad Pro as a remote terminal to an RPi 400 and an Odroid N2+. Both of these machines are running xrdp, and I use the Microsoft Remote Desktop client on the iPad. RDP seems somewhat faster than VNC.
  - rcarmo 4y ago
    RDP is much faster than VNC because it has improved compression and latency management. Also, it is its own X server generally, and not a bolt-on, so less overhead.
- user00012-ab 4y ago
  what do you actually want to do? I have https://github.com/coder/code-server https://github.com/coder/code-server and https://jupyter.org/hub https://jupyter.org/hub running on a PI, along with tailscale on the ipad and pi. This allows the IPAD to have a full editor, and a shell onto the pi.
  - dzhiurgis 4y ago
    Have RPI as command line computer - keyboard & screen only and maybe gradually grow into gui. Probably easier to buy rugged laptop or old thinkpad and install linux)

themodelplumber 4y ago

Geez, it sounds like a really good bonding activity and discussion format they've got going there. I'd be excited too. My son once asked me as I was walking down the hall, "dad, how do I install Steam?" I walked in his room and he had a very prominently placed terminal open, where I saw that he was typing "sudo apt install steam". I practically core dumped in shock. "Whoa buddy! Wow!" and of course that's what he was going for, since he has the affinity-vibe concept absolutely locked down and has had this gift ever since birth as far as I can tell. Half or even most of that typing was just to synchronize with dad's values and build affinity. I respect it and I also, knowing that it's not _exactly_ 100% terminal love, don't push the terminal too hard unless it's related to a specific goal of his. Meanwhile my other kids get up and leave for a snack as soon as I open the terminal on their desktops (it saves me time, they get that). But they are on the other hand really good at introducing COTS thinking into our household. :-) Sometimes you gotta go with the social tech bell curve. Just go buy the thing that does what you want! Duh! And I agree, you can define this as rationality itself in fact. Tinkering, scripting...irrational in some ways for sure, so good thing we have other ways of discussing its value. Speaking of uh, typing, I was just today remembering one of the most scary experiences my kids and I have ever had, playing this roguelike game together... http://www.roguebasin.com/index.php/AliensRL http://www.roguebasin.com/index.php/AliensRL

dvfjsdhgfv 4y ago
> sudo apt install steam Kudos to the parent for teaching them the modern form; I still see people using apt-get for no reason.
- booi 4y ago
  Same reason people keep using cat or dd, just habit and millions of old docs google has enshrined telling them to.
  - tpoacher 4y ago
    not me. I use tac | tac instead.
  - 4y ago

pomatic 4y ago

(2013) -- it would be interesting to know what became of those kids and where they are at today.

CalRobert 4y ago
He responded here! https://twitter.com/jgoerzen/status/1552128838339010562 https://twitter.com/jgoerzen/status/1552128838339010562 Sounds like they're doing well.
darknavi 4y ago
Some say they are still stuck in VIM after dad wouldn't tell them how to exit it.

remarkEon 4y ago

I also plan on doing this, but haven’t had the time yet to put together the actual “plan” per se, other than lots of raspberry Pis and a screen to connect to in the family room. My main motivation for doing this, I suppose, is that being a millennial I got to straddle the analog-to-digital divide growing up, and I think that experience path with technology is healthy because you tend to view it as a tool and less so the basis for your entire existence.

txbuck 4y ago
I don't plan on having kids of my own, but if life finds a way (or I end up with custody of a relative's children) I figured I would similarly put together some kind of loose "curriculum" to guide them along if they took an interest in computing. Never actually planned it out - is a pretty large domain of knowledge to cover for something I don't currently plan on using, but I wouldn't be surprised if there are already pre-existing FOSS resources along those lines. Anybody know of any projects in the same vein?

gwbas1c 4y ago

In other news: I taught my children how to hook up the buggy to the horse. Then I pulled out my great grandfather's Model T and worked them through how to adjust the spark and planning their stops because it didn't have normal brake pads. Then I taught them how to drive stick in a car that requires double-clutching because it doesn't have synchromesh... I honestly don't "get" this need to raise our children with a state of technology like we had when we were kids. My kids use tablets, and when they want/need to use a full powered computer I'll just show them how to use one.

s_dev 4y ago
>In other news: I taught my children how to hook up the buggy to the horse. Then I pulled out my great grandfather's Model T and worked them through how to adjust the spark and planning their stops because it didn't have normal brake pads. You joke but a lot of learning comes from things like this. >I honestly don't "get" this need to raise our children with a state of technology like we had when we were kids It's basically like if I want to understand unix better -- I actually find tutorials written in the 70/80s much better than some of the stuff you see on YouTube or more modern tutorials -- even with all there inaccuracies in terms of getting to grip the core concepts it often gets straight to the point.
- omnibrain 4y ago
  >It's basically like if I want to understand unix better -- I actually find tutorials written in the 70/80s much better than some of the stuff you see on YouTube or more modern tutorials Or even the 90ies/early 2000. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32013779#32015159 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32013779#32015159
olddustytrail 4y ago
The real problem with your analogy is that the command line is more advanced than the GUI. That's why advanced users use it and beginners do not. To borrow an expression: reading and writing is more advanced than pointing and grunting.
deleted 4y ago
[deleted]

enriquto 4y ago

In my case, it started wonderfully, until they learned that they could just launch firefox from the terminal, and proceed to stupid prank videos on youtube. When they log-in, all that they see is an xterm (no menus, no icons). And they just arrow-up+enter to run their previous command that is invariably firefox. I tried disabling youtube on the hosts file and let them figure it out, but apparently is too large a step to make yet. Sigh.

kibwen 4y ago
Don't despair, you're on the right track. You just need to keep erecting increasingly elaborate artificial obstacles, one tiny increment at a time, and by the time they're teenagers they'll be manually linking together their own custom OS from scratch every time they want to watch stupid prank videos on their homemade reimplementation of Firefox.
- nominusllc 4y ago
  mitm their requests and make everything render backwards or in 144p. Make it interesting. My parents would give me challenges like taking the cord to the computer, and they'd find increasingly elaborate improvised power cables. It took my mom 5 years to realize why the treadmill only worked 'sometimes'.
  - tym0 4y ago
    My dad (an IT person) had set specific time during the day when my computer was allowed to access the internet on the router. One day I asked him to login from my computer to whitelist my brother's connection, I had installed a keylogger to grab the login and change the config. Don't think he ever caught on.
hulitu 4y ago
You can help them a bit: alias firefox=lynx in .bashrc

stevenalowe 4y ago

That’s the saddest thing I’ve read in a long time. Children excited about a mouse … because they’ve never used an iPad.

gnicholas 4y ago

My kid is never more fascinated than when she sees me inspecting HTML or using the terminal. I wouldn't ever push a CLI on her, but she is genuinely more interested in learning about computers when she's staring at a screen of text she doesn't understand. We've started doing an HTML tutorial, and her initial enthusiasm seems to have generated enough momentum that she's now excited about what we can do using these previously-daunting text-based tools.

CalRobert 4y ago

I'm surprised how many people are dismissive of learning the command line like it's obsolete. I still use the command line constantly and would be lost without it, and I'd like my kids to understand what's going on better than they can with a desktop environment. I have a 4 year old and found an old Raspberry pi earlier and decided to hook it up to the TV. She was thrilled (and spent plenty of time using a keyboard and mouse for the first time. She liked it! And we don't hide her from technology) Just because we have calculators doesn't mean learning to do math on paper is a bad idea. I was only slightly older than her in the late 80's when we got a 286 and I learned to do `cd games` `dir` `some_game.exe` etc. and I learned the very basics of what a file/directory structure (something a lot of young adults don't understand) is, among other things. Some games meant editing autoexec.bat and that was helpful for understanding system config. Obviously I'm not looking for autoexec now but just understanding that such a config exists is useful.

gnicholas 4y ago
> the very basics of what a file/directory structure (something a lot of young adults don't understand) My dad is confused by the false-skeuomorphism of the word "file". He thinks of them as containers, since this is how "file" is used in the paper sense ("hand me the file on Mrs. Anderson"). So when he's describing something on the computer, he will often refer to a folder as a "file", which can be confusing even though I know he uses this term in this way.
- mixmastamyk 4y ago
  True, and yet computer files can be containers as well.
  - gnicholas 4y ago
    Good point, thought not as far as my father's computer use is concerned!
    - mixmastamyk 4y ago

crusty 4y ago

Without passing judgement on the value of the approach, I'd caution against taking to much away from those method, considering the sample bias of the forum here. I can't help but think the relevant distinction between leading paths of easing your kids into computers with a bash shell vs. hanging them an iPad and a Chromebook might have more to do with the manner and knowledge of the person they turn to when they have questions. The OP's kid asked "what does install mean?" Does it really matter whether he was trying to install htop, ncdu, Zoom, Roblox, or TikTok? Or does it matter more the positive affect of the OP's response and the deep well of knowledge and understanding that he could pull from in formulating an answer? A busy mostly tech-illiterate parent may interpret that question as a "how" question and simply respond, "go to the app store - that's the blue button with the weird 'A' - open it and type R O B L O X. Let me know if you still can't get it." that's not the answer to the question and offers no opportunity for follow on questions, but if you don't really know yourself, you can't really answer.

pcthrowaway 4y ago

I'm astounded that the author's 2-year old son is not only reading, but typing. Is this not outrageously young to be capable of reading, writing, and typography? I thought age 6 is the standard age at which children start reading, but perhaps this has changed with so much socialization happening online now

qayxc 4y ago
According to some parenting sites, "But before their third birthday, most 2-year-olds are able to put three-word sentences together." So yeah, I call BS on that one.
rowanG077 4y ago
Might just be a very early learner. Although 2 is very young I think.
BackBlast 4y ago
My three year old could log into her user account on the computers. She was a month shy of 4. It was the first letters of her name. She could also click on her name. And get into Minecraft from there. I thought it was pretty early for the feat. She is well into 4 now, still can't really "read" yet but she can identify surprising individual words. Plays Minecraft as well as her older siblings for the most part. Still a favorite.
schwartzworld 4y ago
I learned to read at 2, if my mother is to be believed.

user00012-ab 4y ago

You'll be able to tell when it really clicks for them when they end up removing xmonad from their machines replacing it with i3.

Protostome 4y ago

I think this is a super cool idea. I have been thinking how to introduce my children to a computer for some time now. They are both also very young - 3 and 5 and currently have very limited interaction with screens. No tablets/console/PCs at all and TVs only during the weekend for 2-3 hours. I love the fact that their favorite games are LEGO and board games and I'm concerned that introducing a PC to their life will immediately take over everything else. I want them to be familiar with other STEM based "toys" before they put their hands on a PC - A couple of days ago I ordered a microscope from Amazon (the expensive kind that is able to view individual cells) and we are going to prepare slides from samples that we'll take from a nearby pond. At the end of the day, I want them to develop curiousity and fascination towards nature and science. I still haven't figured out completely how to do it with PCs/tablets without getting down a slippery slope