3 ms·
How does RDOF test that? Speedtest.net? Fast.com? Rarely have I received 100Mbps via http transfer mechanisms, and that's the majority of what people do all day
by dylan604 4y ago
How does RDOF test that? Speedtest.net? Fast.com? Rarely have I received 100Mbps via http transfer mechanisms, and that's the majority of what people do all day. Websites, streaming video, etc are all small discrete downloads via lots of multiple requests. They don't have time to get "up to speed". What that 100Mbps is allow ~10 people to use ~10Mbps at the same time. That's the testing I'd be interested in seeing proof of their service being met.
- wmf 4y agoIf they do any testing it will probably be through SamKnows. I don't think 10 people has anything to do with a single household but maybe I'm just an out-of-touch liberal coastal elite. But seriously, one person can use around 25 Mbps which is why there's discussion of defining broadband to be 100 Mbps per household.
- dylan604 4y ago
- NelsonMinar 4y agoHistorically the FCC relied on self-reported numbers from ISPs to verify performance. Unsurprisingly, ISPs lied. Lately FCC has gotten smarter about verifying performance. The RDOF performance requirements are much more subtle than just average speeds though, there's details about percentiles and time of day and the like. I'm hopeful someone is being thoughtful at the FCC
- fomine3 4y agoI believe HLS chunk downloads reuses same TCP/QUIC connection.
- dylan604 4y agoTo be honest, that part of how the internet and browsers work is beyond my knowledge. I just know how to create HLS packages, and then see how the browser makes the multiple requests in the network tab. If browsers are smart and keep connections like that open vs renegotiating per request then it makes sense to me. Maybe this will be my today's TIL for me.