4 ms·
Chernobyl wasn't hiding the negative effects of making money. edit: I think Communism, or at least Soviet communism, is as bad or worse for the environment as
by pessimizer 4y ago
Chernobyl wasn't hiding the negative effects of making money.
edit: I think Communism, or at least Soviet communism, is as bad or worse for the environment as capitalism. The difference is that the benefits of Soviet environmental disasters flowed to the nation in general. The benefits under capitalism generally go to fewer people than I could fit in my bathroom.
- WalterBright 4y agoChernobyl hid the fact that the reactor was highly unsafe, because it was too expensive to fix it. So yeah, it was about money. Socialism is not immune to having things require a positive return on investment, and is hardly immune from forces that cause them to hide costs and risks. As for the benefits of capitalism, it's the only system that has managed to lift millions of poor people into the middle class and beyond.
- pessimizer 4y ago> Chernobyl hid the fact that the reactor was highly unsafe, because it was too expensive to fix it. And that is bad. But it is different. > As for the benefits of capitalism, it's the only system that has managed to lift millions of poor people into the middle class and beyond. That's because capitalists take credit for China. Take China out of it, and capitalism is a no-op.
- jcranmer 4y agoSo who was responsible for poverty reduction in the nineteenth century?
- WalterBright 4y ago> But it is different. Nope. Even socialism has to run at a net surplus (i.e. profit) because you cannot subsidize everything.
- 8note 4y agoI don't think there's such an easy attribution to capitalism. If anything, it's ignoring property rights when people become richer. If you consider the settler colonial projects like the USA, the wealth comes from ignoring the property ownership of the indigenous people, and then also the slavery, and the ignoring or intellectual property for inventions and arts. If you look at Europe, there's the extreme wealth transfer of living and shifting the Indian economy into Europe, along with you know, stealing the world's gold, silver, and other valuables. For more modern times, you also need to contend with unions and government regulations(including socialist policies), along with more wealth redistribution from things like the GI Bill. The people(and descendents) who benefited from the GI Bill are significantly wealthier than the people who didnt. Wealth and land redistribution, especially at the expense of poorer people gives a clearer direction for what has lifted people out of poverty.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat you posted is certainly the prevailing modern opinion. Looking a bit deeper, though: 1. if wealth comes from owning property, why weren't the indigenous people wealthy? 2. In South America, the indigenous people were pushed off their land, too. Why did South America remain poor up to the present? 3. How did Japan become such an incredible economic power despite having little land and no natural resources? 4. The American slave states were never particularly wealthy, and what wealth there was was erased in the Civil War. Literally burned to the ground. Slavery did not build the wealth in the US. 5. The GIs earned the benefits from the GI bill. It is not wealth redistribution. They risked everything for yours and my freedoms. 6. The Spanish indeed took tons of gold & silver from S. America. Do you know what happened? Inflation! The same thing that happened after every gold rush. The reason is simple - gold is not wealth. Gold represents wealth.
- mlsu 4y agoThe historical record soundly contradicts you wrt Japan. It modernized and became powerful on the backs of colonies in Manchuria and the Korean peninsula. Japan was a backwater prior to the Meiji Restoration, when those projects began. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_East_Asia_Co-Prosperity_Sphere https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_East_Asia_Co-Prosper...
- alehlopeh 4y agoLook at what the Soviets did to whale populations. I don’t think you can argue those benefits flowed to anyone.