8 ms·
What I Learned at Clubhouse
- nsxwolf 4y agoMaybe the real lesson is Clubhouse worked about as well as the idea would let it. It will never scale to billions of users because you’ll never get that many people interested in the idea of eavesdropping in live voice chats.
- jsemrau 4y agoLive streamed opinion panels are a popular thing on Youtube and can work really well if the topic works and the people know how to work the format.
- dylan604 4y agoIsn't that basically what call-in talk shows on AM radio are all about?
- nsxwolf 4y agoAM radio listenership in the US is measured in tens of millions a week, and falling. Maybe that can be a business? But I don't see how it could ever be even Twitter-scale.
- dylan604 4y agoIf you think that the demand for talk radio is going away, then I'm not really sure what market you're in. So sure, maybe broadcast radio audiences are losing listeners, but the content itself is not. The audience may be moving to other platforms. I did specify AM, but I should have put that in quotes as we are probably all familiar with the type of programming on "AM" radio.
- last_responder 4y ago>It will never scale to billions of users because you’ll never get that many people interested in the idea of eavesdropping in live voice chats. Billions on one topic? I agree. Millions on one topic? Sure that is possible. Just look at talk radio ,which is still alive. Many shows had listeners in the millions and still do,
- potatolicious 4y agoExcept talk radio evolved in a distinctly asynchronous direction - "talk radio" is now just "podcasts". Clubhouse's format was about synchronous audio - you have to be there at the moment something is said to hear it. They can add a recording feature to it, but then it's just a poor man's podcast platform. > Many shows had listeners in the millions and still do Citation needed? Actual radio listenership has plunged through the floor. Podcasts certainly command that kind of audience size regularly - but again, async, which is a key distinction from the Clubhouse format. More generally media has evolved from synchronous to asynchronous, and everywhere where they've competed the market has chosen in favor of async media. Broadcast TV is (mostly) dead in favor of on-demand streaming, talk radio is (mostly) dead in favor of podcasts. The merits of async are huge in terms of audience size - there's a reason the format itself has pivoted towards podcasts. It feels like Clubhouse's synchronicity is both its greatest asset (i.e., novelty, candidness, spontaneity) and worst liability (i.e., intrinsic limit to audience availability) - and honestly it seems pretty obvious at this point what the net viability of the idea was, given that constraint.
- zactato 4y agoIsn't that podcasts? There are certainly some more topic oriented podcasts, but the more popular ones are basically two famous people chatting on random subjects: eg Joe Rogan
- nsxwolf 4y agoThere was a spontaneity to Clubhouse that podcasts don't have. I'd get an alert that some neat-o celebrity was talking right now, and I could just tap on it and I'd be tuned in right away.
- olivermarks 4y agoExcellent list imo. Even though Clubhouse was a mortar shot up and down those are really good recent insights. Anyone know who 'Anu' is and what he was doing at clubhouse?
- pavlov 4y agoIt’s in the article: “…an early employee and Head of Community”
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoFrom the article: “…as an early employee and Head of Community…”
- mynegation 4y agoShe was a Head of Community at Clubhouse. Twitter @anuatluru
- olivermarks 4y agothanks! I missed that sentence somehow.
- donclark 4y agoCould it be... https://www.linkedin.com/in/anuatluru/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/anuatluru/
- digb 4y agoI see a lot of these retrospectives from companies that (to a certain degree) failed to live up to their hype. I don’t want to invalidate the sort of lessons you can only learn by living through these hyper scaling phases, but I sometimes wonder if some of the lessons folks learned are potentially why things went wrong?
- sytelus 4y agoMy lesson from Clubhouse is that if you want to make social media app then you either need to be lucky or able to enlist tons of celebrities. MySpace, Twitter and Clubhouse are all examples of how they skyrocketed as celebrities pulled in and how then fell to ground as they left the scene. In early hype, it was obvious that founders were able to leverage their connections to celebrities very effectively.
- kuldeep_kap 4y agoi'd change the keyword 'celebrities' to 'top of the social pyramid'. You want to start the social group at the top of the social pyramid of the respective social circle. Create a social clique, which everyone would be jumping off the ground to join. Facebook was started at Ivy League, which allowed it to spread like wildfire in colleges. Similarly Clubhouse was started in Silicon Valley with top VCs and Founders. Of course, each social app goes through various inflection points and arguably celebrities is towards the peak end of it. Celebrities usually catch on once it's already going mainstream or has a mainstream appeal. For example, Twitter had already created strong base of engaged users before celebrities caught on.
- billllll 4y agoFrom an outsider's perspective (I never got into Clubhouse), it really seemed like its success was getting the right people on the platform (like you mentioned), plus the fact that the pandemic put a temporary stop on in-person meetups and talks. I'm sure this was partially due to the hard work of the people at Clubhouse, but to me it seems also like being in the right place at the right time. What I don't get about articles like this, is that the growth is just taken for granted as if it's easily replicated. It's all about hard-fought learnings about product/ops/GTM, and none of that is relevant if you don't come up with an initially compelling product. How can you nurture growth if there is no growth in the first place? Maybe I'm a dumbass who just doesn't "get it," but it seems to me like a premature victory lap to celebrate these learnings before proving that they are fundamental to repeatable success.
- ALittleLight 4y agoI just skimmed this - but I didn't see any reference to the fact that clubhouse basically failed. I think you can absolutely learn a lot from failure, but doing so does require you to realize that failure has happened. The vibe I get from this is more "how to recreate the success I experienced at clubhouse" which doesn't seem quite as valuable to me. Clubhouse is in a rare position - they exploded, were definitely in hyper growth, and then disintegrated. Clubhouse seemed like it hit an effect where the network stopped being a positive. When they were small and used by elite people, they were super popular and exclusive. When everyone got in there it was basically clubs for... I don't even know how to name the people, but not really that valuable. Basically like a nightclub - cool if it's exclusive and lame if everyone can go in. I'd much rather read an insider's take on this unique perspective.
- nsxwolf 4y agoIt was definitely neat for awhile. I heard some great panels and conversations and learned some things that you'll never be able to find on Google - like did you know Tony Hawk learned to program on a TI-99/4A? Only way you'd know is if you were there when he said it in a forum with no record! But I never found any groups I could participate in. There were vast deserts of interests - either because search was bad, or people simply weren't discussing those topics. I'd try to create my own rooms, but no one would ever join.
- Swizec 4y ago> Only way you'd know is if you were there when he said it in a forum with no record And now here we are. Knowledge is memetic. The good shit spreads.
- macintux 4y agoSome of it, sure, but good luck capturing that knowledge in, say, Wikipedia. [Citation needed]
- Macha 4y agoI mean, that's the thing, I heard a lot of PR about people interacting with celebrities, VCs etc. And people saying the _format_ was great as it attracted all these people. But the reality was the novelty attracted these people, and a VC that spends all day chatting with randomers won't be managing their investments very well so they would need to dial back, and the celebs who were enjoying the novelty were going to realise that any venue to interact with fans is capable of consuming "all their time", and want to go back to putting it back in its time limited box, so that aspect of the appeal was never going to last. Then for the randoms talking to randoms type groups, voice chat is a big increase in commitment over Reddit/HN/whatever. You could argue that encourages better contributions, but it also discourages frequent contributions, which in turn helped the "fizzling out" effect
- jeffbee 4y agoNot brevity, it seems.
- peter422 4y ago> In recent months I craved more time to explore new ideas again as a founder, and decided to leave Clubhouse while staying on as an advisor. Just at an FYI to the author, this is a bad idea. Once you have left a startup, your opinions are going to be valued much less by everybody still there because, well, you quit. Your incentives are now not aligned fully, you aren’t part of the mission anymore, and this was because you decided you didn’t want to be. And from your perspective, you quit. Don’t waste your time on them anymore, fully focus on your next project.
- jnwatson 4y agoIt isn’t about giving advice. The advisor role is simply about saving face on both sides. Neither the company nor the founder want to admit they lost faith in the other party.
- allenu 4y agoThat's a great explanation. I've seen the "[Person] will stay on as an advisor for the next N months." so many times when execs or leaders at companies decide to leave. It's a kind of "[Person] has decided to spend more time with their family" statement.
- peter422 4y agoAgain, it’s a waste of time. The company nor the former employee should be wasting their time with saving face. The startup has actual important things to do and the former employee has new projects to start. When a founder leaves it isn’t even that big a deal, nobody cares about a former employee.
- jhchen 4y agoIn a lot of situations, no additional time is spent (and thus wasted). This happens with advisors in the general case too: they become an advisor and never meet again.
- 4y ago
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoI think the real lesson here is effectiveness is more important than efficiency. The author made all the right decisions on the wrong thing.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThe app I'm writing now, marries a fairly basic social graph to a location-based database. When we began, Clubhouse was the new "hotness," and I was getting a great deal of pressure to mimic it. I resisted, as it did not actually work with the model we had established for the app. I also had a rather pessimistic outlook on its chances. It did not make me popular. Glad I did.
- sirspacey 4y agoThe lesson missing is; community building requires curation tools Clubhouse added many features to encourage growth & adoption, but not one easy UX for curation When I would visit the apps there was no quick and easy way to “mute” the algorithm where content was being surfaced that I didn’t want Consequently my notifications were useless & I turned them off So the magic of “this real person I want to hear from is in a room right now!” disappeared It seems an obvious lesson to learn given the other comments here? OP, very curious to hear your take on this.
- leviathant 4y ago>community building requires curation tools And when the people who want to monetize the community take over, curation tools are deliberately hobbled, and the community changes accordingly - always, IMO, for the worse.
- alexklarjr 4y agoAnd nothing of value was lost
- fareesh 4y agoWe co-incidentally launched "Mentza" - a social audio platform in India with 20-minute timed live audio conversations early last year. The community is close-knit and we've had some success at getting the "sometimes you want to go where everybody knows your name" vibe going for our power users. Most of our content & culture is averse to casual chit-chat and more focused on peer to peer learning about something that's mutually of interest, or enjoying some local poetry & music. We've been fairly editorial from the start with a focus on meaningful conversations which will always be a core proposition. We raised about $300K in seed in September and we have been humming along since, with monetization coming next month. I'm obviously biased but I think our format is simpler - it's 20 minutes, you set the context, say your piece and talk to upto 5 others and unlimited listeners who can chime in from the live chat. If you want, you can extend for another 5 minutes to wrap up. All the conversations and chat transcripts are publicly available and recorded, so you don't really miss out if you join late or can't make it. The Clubhouse story is great because it's like a lens into the future for similar apps in terms of the challenges that one can expect - curation, spam, lewd content, crypto nonsense, harassment, etc.
- uxcolumbo 4y agoCongrats on launching. I like the time constraints. What’s the tech stack? And how are you planning to monetise this? Sponsored chats or membership fees? Btw, website layout is screwed on smaller screens… I’m on an iPad 10” screen.
- fareesh 4y ago> Tech Stack The mobile apps are Flutter and the rest is a mix of Ruby, Go, node.js, postgres, redis and various AWS offerings. > Monetization Probably membership fees > Website Thanks I'll check it out
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agoI wonder whether the developers/owners of that thing even realize that its very only attraction was the boutique aura of being an iphone exclusive. they should have. maybe it's not something you admit out loud, but they had to realize it at some level
- smcin 4y agoThat's a very interesting observation: Clubhouse's valuation had already peaked before they finally decided to let a tsunami of Android users on in 5/2021; the 3/2021 Davison quote below pretty much says as much in coded language, that it wasn't a priority and tries to blame it on discovery/UX/engineering. In any case by then, they had walked away from Twitter's $4bn offer, and Twitter was bringing up Spaces rapidly. Also, by then the world was planning for post-Covid reentry. So, from then on the valuation was going south, and the elite userbase was inevitably going to leave. (Anyone got some numbers on Customer Lifetime Value, by segment? What happens to your valuation when the 10% of users with highest CLV leaves? How much lower is the CLV of non-US-based Android users?) I find the OP's "25 Lessons Learned" is kind of a smokescreen that covers all earthly eventualities other than meteors and solar flares, and I can't see which of the 25 are the primary excuse for not deploying Android and scaling up the platform engineering in 5/2021 when they urgently needed to. Should have just sold out to Twitter unless they had a rock-solid plan to execute that in 2021. Consider that $4b would have been 13% of TWTR's valuation today. (How much of Twitter's bid would have been cash?) See their trail of statements [1]: [1/2021 said “soon, but no definite timeline”. Instead, most of [Clubhouse's] statements about Android have been vague mentions of the importance of supporting the Android user base and making its app more accessible to a wider audience.... co-founder Davison explained the company’s approach to scaling to a larger market — like one where Android users participate — as an effort that requires a slower pace, when it comes to opening up access to more users. He noted that when Clubhouse grows, the discovery experience inside the app can be negatively impacted as a result. Users today are seeing more foreign language groups in their feeds, for instance, and are having a harder time finding friends and some of the best content, he said. [blaming the lack of selectivity on engineering and UX isn't credible] [1] https://techcrunch.com/2021/03/22/clubhouse-says-its-android-launch-will-take-a-couple-of-months/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/03/22/clubhouse-says-its-android...
- rdl 4y agoI'm curious which was the biggest factor in the decline of Clubhouse: "everyone's now invited" effect (especially globally); "pandemic boost now over + clubhouse fatigue"; or Twitter Spaces creating something just as good but on top of an existing social network. I joined in August 2020 and it was already declining at. that point; really hit the inflection point into the ground in late Q3/early Q4 2020.
- Barrin92 4y agoClubhouse was broken right from the beginning. The alleged value was in the cringe-inducing attempt to emulate an exclusive, elitist social club, but to sell that to the masses with a startup-style model, which was contradictory in and of itself. Startup companies function by scaling up and that's literally the only thing your secret society cannot do. Overall though good riddance because that entire idea is antithetical to what digital tech can do. I remember that Elon talk where people 'did not fit in a room', and they broadcasted it to other instances. Literally like an overflowing conference room in a virtual space that has no need for these limitations if you weren't trying to desperately sell access.
- somenewaccount1 4y agoI think he missed the number 1 lesson: when you finally do get traction, don't wait an eternity in order to let people in. I think they have clubhouse for android now, but without it essentially 1/2 the population was at best left out, but at worse (and very realistically) made to feel they weren't a wealthy enough consumer for the product. He essentially told 1/2 of the globe that they weren't a good enough customer, most of them just shrugged, said ok, and then never looked back at the product.
- kingofheroes 4y agoI feel like that was deliberate
- alttab 4y agoWere there 23 lessons, or none? Seems like the author couldn't focus on what they "learned," which likely suggests the post is simply a way to increase their profile after what is largely considered a failure. This article would have been way more valuable if distilled into a poignant lesson or insight about why Clubhouse failed.
- snarkypixel 4y agoSeems like a lot of shit happened if you read between the lines. IMO the lessons would have been more impactful with insights into what really happened. For instance: "#1 Earn the right to build the next thing" --> A.K.A we built the wrong thing. What did you build and why didn't it work? Still, overall great lessons. In the end, it seems like Clubhouse is more of a feature that can be added to an existing product rather than a full product by itself. That doesn't necessarily make it a failure but much harder to turn into a long-term company. Reminds me a bit of Dropbox in that sense.
- solardev 4y agoWhat is Clubhouse?