7 ms·
Why some young people are facing resistance from doctors to get sterilized
- Jiro 4y ago"To control my body" is an absurd political spin on "because they expect me to regret it". Can she imagine that a doctor might actually think "I don't want to perform an irreversible, life-alterring operation on someone who has a good chance of regretting it"?
- schnebbau 4y agoWhy does the doctor get to decide whether another person may regret it or not? That isn't a medical decision.
- oneoff786 4y agoOk devil’s advocate. Let’s say the doctor knows for a fact, magically, that they will want to have kids in 5 years. Is it ethical to do the procedure?
- kelseyfrog 4y agoLet's say that magically devil's advocates don't exist. What argument do you want to make?
- oneoff786 4y agoDeciding one wants kids later in life after thinking they would not is fairly common. Sterilizing young people means a great number of expected people who will be unable to conceive despite wanting to later on. The statistical expected utility of doing the operation may well be negative. Especially if abortion care is readily available (the fact that it is not is a key point here). People getting sterilized because they’re afraid of lack of birth control rights and abortions is tragic.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoPeople make choices and then change their priorities or at least their minds about a great many things especially as they get older. Many of these choices have higher regret rates than sterilization. Yet, it seems that sterilization has a special status that gives license for people to make decisions about others. Why is this? As a bodily autonomy absolutist it's hard to understand a willingness to accept someone else's authority over my body. And why should one operationalization of utility be chosen out of the multitudes of conceivable[1] operationalizations? 1. yes, intentional. yw
- oneoff786 4y agoLike what? (Has higher regret rates)
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThe first one that popped up is breast reconstruction after mastectomy, 47% of the sample at at least some regret[1]. Tubal ligation regret maxes at 20.3%[2]. While tubal ligation regret deminishes as age at the time of the procedure increases, my point is that it is still well below that of breast reconstruction. People seem to have no worries about reconstruction regret and large worries over people's sterilization regret. The paradox is hypocritical. There must be another factor at play. Prostate surgery has comparable regret rates(1 in 5)[3] to sterilization. Again, society seems to be perfectly ok with letting folks make decisions about prostate surgeries. Female sterilization in particular seems to be a lightning rod for public discourse. 1. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14768320601124899 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/1476832060112489... 2. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10362150/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10362150/ 3. https://archive.nytimes.com/well.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/08/27/regrets-after-prostate-surgery/ https://archive.nytimes.com/well.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/08/2...
- oneoff786 4y agoBreast reconstruction is reversible, minus some possible loss of nerves from the original tissue source.
- not2b 4y agoSince your premise is impossible (the doctor does not know this for a fact and cannot), the question isn't relevant. In any case, adoption is an option.
- mikestew 4y agoIf we're going to allow magic in this scenario, I suggest that the woman magically give herself a tubal ligation and skip the patronizing medical professionals altogether. Or if we're going to skip things, let's start with hypotheticals that will never happen.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- porkbrain 4y agoAnd herewith The Laplace's doctor is born, bound to plague medical ethics for centuries to come.
- Jiro 4y agoBecause the doctor is performing the operation, and people are always responsible for their own actions. "They told me they wouldn't ever regret it and I foolishly believed them" isn't an excuse for avoiding responsibility.
- sascha_sl 4y agoThat's the inversion of your prescription, not what anyone else is proposing. Nobody is telling anyone they will not regret an elective medical procedure. That's something you need to figure out. Stop being disingenuous.
- balfirevic 4y agoIs the doctor responsible in the case of unwanted pregnancy after the refused sterilization?
- gnicholas 4y agoIf the doctor lied about performing the procedure, then presumably yes.
- nisegami 4y agoThe common wisdom is that they're afraid of being sued. For example, imagine someone with Bipolar disorder in the midst of a manic episode scheduling and performing a tubal ligation. Then later on, they accuse the doctor of malpractice for not identifying them as being in a state of compromised decision making capacity and denying their request. It's really simple to say, that the patient asked for it and that the doctor acted as expected, but it doesn't prevent the lawsuit from being filed. If it's especially egregious, it might be dismissed with prejudice, but there's always a chance that it goes further than that.
- yboris 4y agoI think you're right. Though a solution to this problem seems simple. Just like we ought to have timeouts from the moment you want to buy a firearm to the moment you can have it in your possession, we could have a procedure "fill out this form and sign in, have a consultation with your doctor, and if you come back 3 months later with the same request, after you sign one more form, you can have the procedure".
- BrandoElFollito 4y agoThis is how vasectomy works in France. You have to wait four months and confirm your choice after that.
- causi 4y agoDoctors seem to have little hesitation regarding other life-altering modifications like sticking silicone balls in your chest, carving your face up because you don't like the outline of your nose, or slicing pieces off your kid's genitals.
- happytoexplain 4y agoI think sterilization is both more life-altering than your examples, and also that doctors, on par, absolutely have some amount of "hesitation" (i.e. making sure they really want it) regarding plastic surgery.
- causi 4y agoI would argue that anything up to and including assisted suicide performed with informed consent deserves less hesitation than performing arbitrary surgeries on unwilling and unconsenting children. Being willing to do that but not sterilize someone just makes you a hypocrite.
- YawningAngel 4y agoI'm not sure this argument really works, because it's different doctors in both cases. There are lots of doctors who would be unwilling to do what you reference, but they're selected out of that area of practice. The difference here is simply that this selection effect isn't present here because this procedure is a minority of the field
- jjeaff 4y agoAre you talking about male circumcision? It's hardly a blip on the radar of invasive procedures with no lasting side effects except some minor benefits.
- causi 4y agoCutting off an infant's outer ears or doing electrolysis on their armpit hair follicles or burning them with a hot iron also have no long lasting side effects but we don't allow those because of course we don't. Cutting off a male prepuce has just as much effect as cutting off a female prepuce. Can you imagine a doctor agreeing to removing a baby girl's clitoral hood? As someone who did have long-lasting effects from circumcision, I would delight in finding the son of a bitch that did it to me and seeing how he likes having pieces removed. You don't need a spreadsheet to know that causing agony to children is a bad thing.
- sascha_sl 4y agoLast I checked 26 was 8 years more than 18.
- Jiro 4y agoDoctors are not supposed to harm patients even if the patient is above the age of 18. If the patient is likely to regret the operation, doing the operation is causing harm.
- anikan_vader 4y agoOn the other hand, she is asking for a form of birth control. Given that abortion is banned in many parts of the US, it's easy to see why she views the denial of birth control as an attempt to control her body.
- ransom1538 4y agoAge matters. If someone wanted me to tattoo a snake on their forehead I would be taking account their age.
- advisedwang 4y agoSure, some doctors have a preference not to do it, but their stake in the situation is pretty low compared to the patient. Why do we let the doctors preference mean that the procedure becomes unavailable? Imagine if mail carriers could refuse to deliver to houses with the mailbox up stairs. Yes, its fair that they don't like it but the cost of that is people lose a vital service. In that case the mail carriers have to accept their job might include some elements they don't like.
- frumper 4y agoSome mail carriers do refuse to deliver at certain address for reasons that other carriers wouldn't refuse to deliver for.
- briffle 4y agoI have compared with a friend that wanted to get her tubes tied, and the doctor insisted she might change her mind, should wait a few years, and wanted her to speak to her partner about it. I asked for a vasectomy, and the doctor scheduled it 2 days later. It really is a double standard
- buscoquadnary 4y agoFrom my understanding vasectomies are much easier to reverse than the female equivalent that might account for some of it.
- celeritascelery 4y agoAnd on top of the reversibility, vasectomy is a much simpler out-patient procedure compared to tubal ligation (which means lower risk of complications). There is not a double standard here, just medical reality.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoThen why are all the refusal statements we're hearing about "regret" instead of risk?
- celeritascelery 4y agoBecause the biggest consideration is the reversibility as GP said. If you have Tubal Ligation your odds of getting it successfully reversed is 1%[1]. It is effectively a permanent decision. [1]https://www.fertstert.org/article/S0015-0282(15)00292-7/pdf https://www.fertstert.org/article/S0015-0282(15)00292-7/pdf
- hamburglar 4y agoMy vasectomy doc made it very clear that vasectomies are not always reversible and you should absolutely not count on them being reversible if you anticipate changing your mind.
- sophacles 4y agoYou can't have an abortion - you had sex deal with the consequences of your choice, even if it means your death from complications in pregnancy. vs You can't have your tubes tied - there might be consequences to your choice so you shouldn't have to deal with those. What's different here? Oh right, nothing if the goal is forcing birth.
- 28304283409234 4y agoIf only they applied the same logic to males then it would make sense. They don't. Men can get sterilized in the blink of an eye, while women are forced to "have time to think a out it" and such.
- pavel_lishin 4y agoI'd love to see some stats on how many doctors turn down men who are looking to get sterilized. I'm assuming men looking to get a vasectomy get much less pushback from doctors.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoThat would be interesting, for sure. If men do turn out to get less pushback, I wonder if a contributing reason is that it's less medically risky to reverse a vasectomy than reversing e.g. tubal ligation. (I don't know that it is less risky and/or more likely to succeed. But the vas deferns is incredibly accessible.)
- pavel_lishin 4y agoBased on the article, that doesn't seem to be the reason for pushback.
- onepointsixC 4y agoAren't vasectomy reversals much more common and successful? If the procedure of "sterilization" is much more irreversible then it would follow that there would be more push back as there is more risk.
- sascha_sl 4y agoNowhere is this double standard more obvious than in trans healthcare. Everyone has horror stories, but someone else being gatekeepy because of your (supposed) loss of fertility and implied sexual availability as a woman is really common and honestly kind of disgusting. You can see this with people posting pictures of pre-transition Elliot Page and captions like "remember what they took from us" all the time on social media.
- joshstrange 4y agoThey get much less pushback. It's anecdotal but I know a couple where the wife tried for like 3 years in a row to have a tubal ligation ("tubes tied") and her doctors (I believe she tried multiple) all told her she should wait, had she talked to her husband, what if she changed her mind, and the list goes on. After the 3 or so time her husband went into his doctor and had the vasectomy on the books by the end of the checkup. When I was talking to the wife she made it clear this was not at all unusual according to her friends/acquaintances. Everyone needs to be their own advocate when it comes to medical care but I've heard multiple horror stories from my female friends that would never have occurred to me ("You're overreacting", "It's not that painful", "Maybe it's just cramps", "Have you tried X?").
- Pinegulf 4y agoMaybe altering your biology for the rest of your life is not a good way to make political statements of the day.
- jtode 4y agoWhen the politics of the day, though, are to forcibly modify the rest of your life by using your biology against you, this is clearly about life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
- swammie 4y ago
- frumper 4y ago"Isa Ruiz has always known children are not part of their plan. But the 22-year-old Orlando communications specialist" Anyone that says they know their plan that early is just hoping their plan works out. Life is chaotic and full of many surprises.
- swatcoder 4y agoThat never stops being true, but we still make decisions and then work within the consequences. Choosing not to make strong decisions in fear of some possible regret is it’s own decision, and just as subject to its own possible regret.
- Arrath 4y agoAbsolutely, but on the same token: bearing a child isn't the only path to being a parent.
- powerhour 4y agoFewer surprises after sterilization, though.
- jkingsman 4y agoWell, when it comes to having kids, it may be full of many surprises but mainly and nearly exclusively, only if they can't have their wishes for sterilization respected. Kids don't tend to just pop out of thin air, but they can happen by accident which is what she's trying to avoid.
- 8note 4y agoIts an alternative to the new forced birth policies. With abortion made illegal, sterilization is the only way to 100% not have children. Likely the forced birthers will make sterilization illegal too, so the race is on.
- jmyeet 4y agoThis is a difficult subject. The first and most obvious point is that I, personally (FWIW), fully support body autonomy so if people want to get sterilized if they want. The article points out the issue with regret. I'm not sure how you handle that other than maybe coming up with a more easily reversible procedure? Either way, if someone may end up regretting a decision is no reason to take that choice away from someone. But you can't talk about this issue without talking about how the medical profession treats women. Women are often ignored and their pain and concerns are downplayed or outright dismissed, sometimes catastrophically. Some women are sterilized without consent for reasons with little or even no medical basis. If you're not aware, look at the "husband's stitch" for an example of misogynist medical barbarism. You also can't ignore the politics of this and how the fight against reproductive rights sprang out of "Great Replacement" fears [1]: > In an 1865 essay issued by order of the AMA, Storer went so far as to say of white women that “upon their loins depends the future destiny of the nation.” If you think that's ancient history, it isn't [2]. Rep. Mary Miller (R-IL) called the defeat of Roe v. Wade a “victory for white life.” This is the same Miller who said "Hitler Was Right on One Thing" [3]. [1]: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-the-fight-to-ban-abortion-is-rooted-in-the-great-replacement-theory/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-the-fight-to-ban-ab... [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtdOAdmqqIY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtdOAdmqqIY [3]: https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/chicago-politics/illinois-congresswoman-says-hitler-was-right-on-one-thing/2409325/ https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/chicago-politics/illin...
- bena 4y agoWhile it is true that anyone saying at 22 that they know for sure definitely that they will never have children might change their mind, it doesn't matter. We let people make all sorts of regrettable, life-altering decisions at 22. At 22, you can be 4 years into your service contract with the armed forces. You could have already died or have been permanently disabled due to these choices. At 22, you can be a few years into a college education in a major you now know you hate. At 22, you can be 4 years into a marriage to an abusive partner. Or just an asshole. These are just a few of the choices you can come to regret later in life. Choices that you cannot change. Choices you will have to live with for the rest of your life. That fundamentally alter all of the choices available to you later in life. So why should potential regret stay our hand here? Yes, she may regret getting her tubes tied and making conception for her impossible. Oh well. Actions have consequences.
- trasz 4y agoNo idea about USA, but in Poland a large number of those refusals is due to catholic bigotry. In Poland this is correlated with many fundamentalists choosing this field due to readily available prey. Should be easy to determine comparing the number of refusals between the fundamentalist states and the rest, I guess.
- Spinnaker_ 4y agoI sort of get it. Looking back, I had 6 friends who were adamant that they would absolutely 100% never have kids. A decade later 3 are happy parents and a 4th is expecting. Now from a 22 year old's perspective, this is a terrible argument, and I understand they would be upset.
- web007 4y agoSterilization is a big deal. Doctors make a big deal out of it because of history - forced or unwanted sterilization has been a problem in the past, especially for marginalized people. The difference between men and women's experiences are infuriating and MUST be addressed, but the sentiment is correct. A successful vasectomy ends in a 50-50 reversal-to-conception ratio, including not just pregnancy via intercourse but by any means necessary (fertility treatments, IVF, etc.). Even this minimally-invasive and "easily-reversible" action is considered permanent. Any permanent sterilization (in CA, not sure about rest of US/world) has a default 30-day waiting period, with the ability to waive down to a minimum 72-hour required delay between consent to permanent sterilization and having the procedure. Making a permanent decision is not something to be taken lightly, it will be interesting to see what other outcomes of Roe v. Wade change behavior and expectations of large populations.
- balfirevic 4y ago> The difference between men and women's experiences are infuriating and MUST be addressed, but the sentiment is correct. Are you saying it would be better if men received the same kind of pushback? > Making a permanent decision is not something to be taken lightly For sure. And yet - people often have children without too much thought and nobody bats an eye. (To be clear, that's fine as it's their own business - but the same should be true for sterilization.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gumby 4y agoWhen you go for the equivalent upgrade as a male they ask the same absurd questions ("what would you do if your child died") as if kids are fungible.
- the_third_wave 4y agoOne of the first, if not the first mantras learned by aspiring doctors (and, most likely, others in the medical profession) is First of all, do no harm. This sounds like a simple and logical rule but implementing it is not as straightforward as it may seem. Does sterilising a man or woman who has a 25% chance of later in life wanting this procedure reversed [1] - which, in contrast to what is commonly thought is not easily reversible if at all - do harm to this person or not? For the ~60% who will not come to regret their decision it clearly does not but those who come to regret their decision will have to come to terms with their self-induced infertility. Unsurprisingly the younger a woman gets sterilised, the bigger the chance that she will come to regret it later in life [2]: Study results showed that the younger women were at the time of sterilization, the more likely they were to report regretting that decision. Women undergoing sterilization at the age 30 years or younger were about twice as likely as those over 30 to express regret. They were also from 3.5 to 18 times as likely to request information about reversing the procedure and about 8 times as likely to actually undergo reversal or an evaluation for IVF. Results of studies that examined risk by continuous age showed a consistent inverse relationship between women's age at sterilization and their likelihood of regretting having had the procedure. Given these facts it would be surprising if young people did not face resistance when requesting sterilisation. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6203343/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6203343/ [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16413851/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16413851/
- advisedwang 4y agoMost of the objection to allowing someone to sterilize themself (either from doctors of this thread) is centered around the potential for regret later. But guarding people from regret is nanny-state BS. People regret tattoos, people regret having kids, people regret getting married, people regret quitting jobs and all kinds of irreversible decisions, and unless you're hurting someone else society rightly defaults to letting them decide for themselves.
- josephcsible 4y agoThe only one of your examples that's actually irreversible is having kids. People get tattoos removed, get divorced, and return to former employers all the time.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoSeem related to this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32222063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32222063