2 ms·
Amusing. Second-hand experience[0] with "exciting science areas" led me to this belief already. It's one of those interesting things. For folks outside of scien
by renewiltord 4y ago
Amusing. Second-hand experience[0] with "exciting science areas" led me to this belief already. It's one of those interesting things. For folks outside of science, they think most of this stuff is backed. You can see it in the fact that people will quote "there is evidence that X is Y" using some random study, commonly on HN.
There's a common reaction to this sort of thing where people act like it is some betrayal of a sacred pact, etc. etc. but there is so much fake science out there that it is really hard to believe that there is actually some betrayal and it's not just the reality of the field.
And always there'll be some guy who comes up with a "I've never heard of this and neither has any of the ten guys I talked to about it". Just do the math. At a 10% fake rate (which I would consider extraordinary) there's a 1 in 3 chance that you wouldn't detect it with just independent observations of you and 10 friends (and that's assuming you and your friends are independent here, which is very generous). At a 5% fake rate (which is still horrible), there's a 1 in 10 chance that even you and 40 of your friends would not detect it.
The thing with not-so-rare things is that you can fail to detect it through sheer chance.
0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25926188 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25926188
P.S. hn.algolia.com is excellent. I managed to find this comment in a couple of seconds on it.
- bhk 4y agoThe "I've never heard of this ..." comment can also be explained by the possibility that the person making the comment is one of the fraudsters. This adds 10% to the 1/3 chance in your example. So no matter how high the rate of fraud is, we would expect to hear comments like this.
- renewiltord 4y agoI did not think about that, but you are right (with appropriate maths modifications)