4 ms·
That only works if the users trust their government(s), where geopolitics are stable, and where freedom from censorship is a cultural norm. All of those things
by solardev 4y ago
That only works if the users trust their government(s), where geopolitics are stable, and where freedom from censorship is a cultural norm. All of those things are increasingly rare, and centralized domain names are an easy way for states or competing governments to block access to undesirable materials.
The allure of a supranational DHT network is that it is more censorship-resistant, requiring deep packet inspection or attacks to block certain lookups.
I think this hypothetical consensus-based DNS blockchain sounds nice at first glance, but really, it just means that DNS is changed from an authority-based model to a consensus-based one. But consensus of what? It's not of people, but of resources -- compute power -- which states will always have more of, anyway. Like TOR, it just means the state has to control/surveil more "trusted" nodes. So it doesn't really solve anything.
You can't "web of trust" a global network of 8 billion people who don't have any interest in this stuff, don't want to peg their individual identities to some online system, and don't agree on what truth is to begin with. You can't techno-topia your way out of the cultural differences inherent in geopolitical disagreements.
- agentultra 4y ago> You can't techno-topia your way out of the cultural differences inherent in geopolitical disagreements. Too true. Computers won't "solve" social/political/cultural issues. They're reflections of the creators' politics. Even blockchains that purport to be egalitarian reflect the political ideology of their creators -- often naive at best or tyrannical themselves at worst.
- woojoo666 4y ago> it just means that DNS is changed from an authority-based model to a consensus-based one. But consensus of what? It's not of people, but of resources -- compute power -- which states will always have more of, anyway. If a blockchain became the norm, there would be no way for the state to have more compute power than the rest of the population
- solardev 4y agoWhat do you mean? Blockchains are already heavily lopsided. Throwing state resources into the mix would only make that worse.
- woojoo666 4y agoYou think the government would have more than 51% of the compute power of the entire world? If that were true they could easily break TOR
- solardev 4y agoYes, quite trivially? Compute power is more a function of dollars than population. Don't they already surveil most Tor exit nodes?
- woojoo666 4y ago> Yes, quite trivially? Compute power is more a function of dollars than population. There is no way the government has enough servers and computers to come even close to 51% of the world's compute. And if they tried to print money and buy it all, it would be seen as ridiculous and the government would be sacked. Also, surveilling TOR exit nodes is very different from owning over 51% of all TOR relays. The former won't help you deanonymize users, the latter most definitely will