9 ms·
BMW’s Heated Seats as a Service Model Has Drivers Seeking Hacks
- techdragon 4y agoDid anyone think this wouldn't happen? The idea that an average car buyer won't understand that computer stuff can be "hacked" so they don't have to pay is pretty ridiculous. If your making money to buy a new BMW you probably don't live under a rock and have some idea of how computers work in a very high level way.
- izacus 4y agoHahaha, there's massive amount of BMW drivers that fail to pair their iPhone to the car, much less understand basics of computers. You are way, way, WAY too optimistic.
- 7thaccount 4y agoI don't understand why you'd buy a BMW when they treat customers this way. Vote with your money.
- winReInstall 4y agoThats the beauty of it. You can not. Because we do no longer have a free market. All car companies, belong by shareds to a few titanic entities, who will push this in lock step to all there companies. Welcome to the gilded age.
- jacquesm 4y agoBMW is a pretty recognizable brand and other than Mini / Rolls Royce (the latter of which you probably won't need to avoid and the former tries to sell you on the fact that they are a life-style rather than a vehicle for an entirely different demographic) voting with your feet may well have the desired effect.
- onethought 4y agoI think you under estimate how many OEMs there are. Which “few titanic entities” are you referring to? Tesla? BMW? Toyota? Volkswagen Group? Gheely? BYD? Hyundai? Honda? … the list goes on. Basically there isn’t a more competitive anti-monopoly industry than the car industry.
- 2143 4y agoBut don't they all cater to different segments of the market? Somebody who wants to buy a BMW will likely not be cross-shopping with a Hyundai, even if there's are models at the same price point.
- onethought 4y agoTrue so they only have: Audi, Lexus, genesis, infiniti, Tesla, Daimler, the list goes on… to choose from. The luxury car segment is also huge…
- petre 4y agoReally? I could always buy an Alfa Romeo instead, which not only comes with heated seats but also with leather as standard upholstery in the Giulia and Stelvio models. The Chinese car manufacturers are going to eat them alive soon anyway.
- rhexs 4y agoThe people who want a BMW to show the world they own a BMW are exactly who they are targeting with this. Same situation as Mercedes. Taking dumb money more or less.
- itsoktocry 4y agoTesla pioneered this nonsense via FSD subscriptions (which doesn't even exist) and limiting the battery. And yet everyone around these parts cheers them on.
- pavel_lishin 4y agoI know this is a rhetorical question, but presumably because the benefits outweigh the negatives in their case. If you're looking to buy a fancy car in Texas, you're probably not particularly interested in heated seats.
- atwood22 4y agoSomething about a monthly fee for basic functionality screams “low class” to me. It’s like the difference between renting and owning. “You don’t have enough money to buy outright, so you’re forced to pay for a basic thing in perpetuity.” That taints BMW’s brand. I’ll buy a Lexus, thanks.
- pavel_lishin 4y agoThere is probably a large percentage of BMW drivers who are renting or leasing their cars.
- ok123456 4y agoWhat happens when air conditioning is a monthly charge?
- AceyMan 4y agoTexas gets plenty cold in the winter months, particularly in the high plains; heated seats would absolutely be useful for a decent chunk of the year.
- bourbonjuggler 4y agoI agree. Why bother creating a workaround for this problem? The easiest resolution to this is to spend your money somewhere else.
- izacus 4y agoI'll bet you a barrel of beer that all luxury cars will have all features locked behind perpetual subscriptions within 5-10 years. "Great" thing about consolidated megacorporation dominated markets: you have nowhere to go if only three companies decide to squeeze more money out of you. And shareholders WILL demand that every car manufacturer squeezes more money out of you by locking equipment you own now behind subscriptions.
- chrismcb 4y agoI don't drink beer, but I would take that bet. No one has followed bmw into subscription model for Apple car pay. The only reason other companies works follow this model, is if it succeeds
- bastardoperator 4y agoLOL, locked. There is no such thing when I have physical access to the computer.
- izacus 4y agoBreaking DRM on that physical computer is illegal and good luck getting your modified vehicle insured if it fails the manufacturer bootloader lock check ;) It sounds like you missed last 15 years of developing DRM technology and IP law.
- bastardoperator 4y agoMy insurance company doesn't care about the infotainment center in my vehicle and DRM hasn't stopped anyone ever. Look at all the farmers waiving their middle finger to John Deere. When has anyone in the history of buying insurance been forced into a bootloader check? Never, you're making stuff up. If I own the car outright, I own the computer and can do whatever I want to it. Seems like you missed all the DRM hacks, and think vehicle insurance companies do IP law.
- rowanG077 4y agoRemember non-smart TVs? I can vote with my money by not buying a TV at this point.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoYou still find them in the premium segment. TV for businesses often lack most smart features. Price range > 1000$ though.
- rapind 4y agoWe just lost the vote on TVs is all (for now). As the wolf sheds the sheep clothing though that might change (not optimistic). I doubt BMW is going to nail this on their first pass, but subscriptions are obviously more lucrative so they may keep trying (or others will). Regardless, software running everything is a nightmare in progress. The quality standards are atrocious and regulations haven’t even come close to keeping up.
- thfuran 4y agoIt seems unlikely that regular TVs will come back without some very stringent legislation preventing monetization. As it is, Vizio makes less money from selling their hardware than from other BS.
- highwaylights 4y agoAlso, customer service aside, they're not great cars in the first place. If you're buying a gasoline car and it's not a Toyota or a Mazda, you're doing it wrong.
- 2143 4y agoI guess you haven't heard about Toyota's subscription fee for enabling remote-start[1]. Eventually they're all going to jump on the bandwagon. [1] https://www.motor1.com/news/554620/toyota-subscription-fee-remote-start/ https://www.motor1.com/news/554620/toyota-subscription-fee-r...
- WkndTriathlete 4y agoMazda is doing the exact same thing. When my wife and I purchased our CX-5 that was an option and we said "hell no" even though it gets to -30 F in the winter in the Upper Midwest. The trend toward turning products into subscriptions has been in flight for at least 20 years. It was bullshit when it started and it continues to be bullshit today.
- highwaylights 4y agoAt least in your example you still have a lovely CX-5.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoI think its just as good to vote by hacking. Like when pirating music was a result of people just saying f-u to the way industry was trying to sell us music, why not have hacking car software be a way of saving f-u to the car industry trying to rent-seek us to death. The music industry changed and now we have reasonable streaming alternatives. See if the car industry gets the message as well.
- whoomp12342 4y agoIs now a time to start caring about RIGHT TO REPAIR?????
- CharlesW 4y agoWhat's the connection between charging for individual features and "right to repair"?
- michaelbuckbee 4y agoIt comes down to if we're buying products that we own and then can make any repairs or modifications that we want to with them or if we're merely licensing the product.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoNo idea what GP meant but here's my take: Right to Repair would imply that individual components of a vehicle can't be under a subscription to use because that implies you don't have full ownership of the part. Also Right to Repair usually includes some requirements on manufacturers to publish the schematics and repair manuals publically or at least provide them to owners. That means whatever piece controls the subscription would be known, and could be bypassed or removed more easily. I dunno though. This is just my thoughts
- Arrath 4y agoPresumably one would be able to 'repair' the lockout on a feature of the car that you own but are locked out from.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoThe connection is computer freedom. We should be able to replace their shitty defective-by-design subscription software with free software that does what it's told and it should be illegal for the corporation to put any barriers to stop us from doing it.
- EGreg 4y ago“In 10 years, you will own nothing and you’ll be happy” What if instead of owning cars, we rented them? Less garbage parked on all our streets when not being used. Less fossil fuel monopoly lockin. Self driving upgrades would be the norm. Then this approach by BMW would make sense. For me, the real racket has really been the pushing of ownership on everyone. Own a car. Own a house. To do so, RENT MONEY from a bank and go work to pay back millions of dollars over decades or we will reposess your house. You’re welcome, pleb!
- baggy_trough 4y agoRenting a car is a process that takes at least 10 times longer than it seems like it should. Also, rental car facilities are not on every street corner.
- GavinMcG 4y agoI think the comment is proposing a massive shift toward rental and away from ownership. The landscape would not look the way it does now.
- atwood22 4y agoHow would you pay the rent for your home in your theoretical world without working a job? You’re paying to live no matter what. At least when you own something you have something to show for your labor. Also, I think there’s a lot of truth to the old adage: “buy real estate, they’re not making any more of it.”
- tristor 4y ago
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoFunny I didn't read anything in GP's comment that supports this assertion, care to quote or are you simply being nasty?
- 4y ago
- disruptiveink 4y agoI'm torn about this. One one hand, the slippery slope of this is car microtransactions, so the pushback is very much needed and understandable. People had to vote with their wallet until manufacturers gave up on charging subscriptions for Apple Carplay/Android Auto. On the other hand, the use case BMW is presenting is actually quite reasonable: making car extras available to second hand buyers (and presumably, making their pipeline more effective and flexible so they don't have to customize cars at build time). I'd be thrilled if I bought a used car without heated seats and was able to "add" heated seats and other upgrades on the spot, by paying one-time fees for the extras that the original owner didn't purchase. Car extras are already very much a thing and always have been – the alternative is that BMW physically has to remove the heater components or disable them permanently, so as a second hand buyer, I'd be permanently locked out of the upgrade. Forcing the car maker to have to physically neuter the hardware out of "purity" strikes be as something a bit silly.
- zwog 4y agoBut if it's cheaper for them to add the necessary hardware and deactivate it, then they could add the hardware and activate it for free for every car.
- jacquesm 4y ago> the alternative is that BMW physically has to remove the heater components or disable them permanently, so as a second hand buyer, I'd be permanently locked out of the upgrade No, the alternative is to simply sell what you have 'as is', and not to try to graft a subscription model onto every sale. Rather than selling unnecessary services BMW should focus on selling cars. And with the number of software issues their vehicles suffer from (a friend of mine was an avid BMW fan for many years his cars spent more time in the shop for software issues than mine ever did for all of their maintenance put together over the same 20 year period) they should strive to have less software related components rather than more of them. Finally, what do you think the chances are that they are able to keep that service up and running over the service life of their vehicles?
- Bancakes 4y agoYou would be thrilled for purchasing a car with heated seats, and paying a redundant subscription for heated seats?
- Overtonwindow 4y agoI think subscription services for hardware features is a bad idea, and I will only be motivated to hack it rather than ever accept it. It reminds me of the overpriced pay to wash machines you see in large apartment complexes that don't put them in units.
- onethought 4y agoIf it’s cheaper for the production line to have fewer spec changes, but marketing can still create tiered products through software unlocks… how is this different to a normal saas subscription? They are just software unlocks as well?
- pc86 4y agoLet's stick with this specific example. I buy a car with heaters in the seats. I own the car. I own the seat. I own the heater. I'm still waiting to hear any reasonably cogent explanation about how I should be prevented from using the heater I own that's inside of the seat I own.
- onethought 4y agoBecause you don’t own the software that activates it. Similar to how you can’t modify the gear ratios or the traction control system on the ecu of the car you own. Because you don’t own software, you license it.
- more_corn 4y agoJust boycott BMW.
- honestduane 4y agoBMW is in the wrong here. The doctrine of first sale says I own the car, and I own the heated seats in it. And once its ours, they do not have the right to charge us for something our car has the capability to do without them. And its unethical for them to try to add microtransactions on something we already physically own. This is a form of fraud, IMHO. BMW is losing the trust of buyers; they will not last long if they continue this.
- highwaylights 4y agoOn one hand, they're following industry into your-purchase-is-really-a-license-and-subscription-model-all-the-things. On the other hand, the public and legislators have been pretty clear about this never having been OK and cut it out right now (e.g. right to repair).
- gwbas1c 4y ago> The doctrine of first sale says I own the car, and I own the heated seats in it. What about leasing? If you lease (rent) the vehicle, is it okay to enable / disable features based on what you pay?
- soco 4y agoYou don't lease it from BMW. You buy it from BMW through some leasing company. The difference might be essential.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> doctrine of first sale says I own the car, and I own the heated seats in it You own the hardware. You don't necessarily own the license to operate it. I agree this is a bullshit difference, but it's a legally material one.
- 2143 4y agoWhy don't they just offer rent-a-BMW instead of making you buy the "entire" car upfront, and THEN charging you for individual features in that car?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LeifCarrotson 4y agoJoel Spolsky on price segmentation, back in 2004: > And God help you if an A-list blogger finds out that your premium printer is identical to the cheap printer, with the speed inhibitor turned off. As it turns out, you don't need divine help if every manufacturer has the consumer already conditioned to accept abuse in the form of EULAs, subscriptions, and microtransactions from all directions... [1]: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-duckies/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-...
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> BMW has priced heated seats at £15 ($18) a month, £150 a year, £250 for three years, or £350 “unlimited" This looks less like a subscription and more like financing.