6 ms·
What Happens When Texans Protest Their “Mind-Boggling” Property Taxes?
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- hippich 4y agoJust finished formal hearing for my property valuation protest at Travis arb (via phone). The district representative essentially reiterated same numbers they provided in the evidence. They did not bring any new evidence, not were able to clarify how these evidence relate to my property. My lot was assessed at $584k, while neighbors slightly larger one is at 100k. When I tried to probe why my lot is classified and appraised differently from the immediate neighbor's one, his answer was essentially "this is how we classify it". 3 acres lots with water access in my neighborhood appraised at $300k while my 2.7ac lot without water access appraised at $584k. Many lots around mine did not change appraised value at all. The lot that was sold two years ago for $120k (i know because I wanted to buy it but was too slow) - now appraised at almost $800k - no way it could increase that much.... Basically, numbers are all over the place and the representative couldn't really explain why. Yet, the independent panel after not hearing any meaningful explanation from the district representative and hearing my examples of how numbers been all over the place, in the 3 to 0 vote voted to side with district's valuation recommendation... I guess I will wait for the ARB's official letter and have to head to the court, since numbers just do not make sense.
- 3pt14159 4y agoThis is why appraisals for tax purposes should always come with the right to sell the property back to the city for 90% of this value. If you won't pay $900k for a $1m home, then it isn't a $1m home. Also, there should be carveouts (like we have in Toronto) for the elderly and disabled to have their taxes paid from the residual value of their home until they die, so our communities don't just push out our most vulnerable fifth of society when housing booms.
- duxup 4y agoHard to imagine a local city has the funds available to just buy up property. I’m also not sure “punishing” (well now you have to buy it) local municipalities results in better governance. Also sounds like an invite for corruption. Evaluate high, sell to the city… now the locals are all on the hook.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mmmpop 4y ago> Hard to imagine a local city has the funds available to just buy up property. Hard to imagine the US government has 1.5 trillion lying around to pay people to stay home, but they figured it out.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoUnfortunately the local city can’t just print more money. I suspect they could raise property taxes instead though.
- mmmpop 4y agoI'm sure they'll figure it out.
- duxup 4y agoLocal cities /= federal government.
- mech987 4y agoIf the city can buy property at 90% of appraised value, they can sell to the market at true market value. As long as their appraised value is accurate, they profit from this arrangement. It provides the proper incentive to align appraisals with market value and prevents the city from exploiting its citizens.
- hnhegde 4y agoWhat evidence did you present? Did you take comps - sales comps and/or equity comps? You may be aware already, but in general, people take photos of their property that need repairs e.g., cracks in slab/foundation, leaky roof, mold infection etc.
- hippich 4y agoThere were little conversation about the improvement itself. It was pretty spot on (I know, because we built this house). The problem was with their appraisal of the land. There are no comps in the area, and explanation why my lot has 275% multiplier while neighbor's one has 100% was "we assess their lot as a plot, and yours as acreage". My lot is slightly smaller then my neighbors. Two of these lots sit next to each other on the same street... No explanation why it is treated differently.
- TheChaplain 4y agoI feel property taxes are stupid, with 2 exceptions; If you own more than one apartment/house and don't use or rent out the other. Second, companies owning apartments/houses. Ah and third, property with foreign owners (not immigrants ofc but owners living abroad buying up property in the US). I'm not trying to come off as a communist or something, I just believe giving the widest opportunity for people to have their own home. So even if you are broke as a rat, you still have a place to stay safe.
- Volundr 4y agoIt's worth noting many states have a "homestead exemption" or similar that provides a significant tax break to the house you actually live in. It doesn't go quite as far as you want, but it does mean that all the entities you list already pay more in property taxes than an actual homeowner on the same property.
- pwinnski 4y agoIt doesn't go nearly as far is it should, indeed, and at least in Texas, you can't claim the homestead exemption the first year you own a property. So I bought a house from someone who had been claiming the homestead exemption and also a senior discount. I immediately filed for the homestead exemption as well, but that doesn't take effect until the second year you own the house. So the property take history looks like: very low, very low, very high, somewhat low, somewhat low. That rule about paying the full amount on year one is... odd.
- hnhegde 4y agoBeginning Jan 1st 2022, a homeowner can apply for HS exemption the same year and if authorized, can get a pro-rated exemption for the rest of the year, if the preivous owner hasn't already claimed it. Ref: SB 8/2021. Bettencourt. https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/872/billtext/html/SB00008I.htm https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/872/billtext/html/SB00008I...
- 4y ago
- stevenjgarner 4y agoPaywalled : https://archive.ph/wip/4zs6Q https://archive.ph/wip/4zs6Q
- pessimizer 4y agoThe only reason a lot of people have these homes is because property taxes pushed out the previous residents after they themselves pushed the property values up. This is what happens when you don't have an income tax.
- slavboj 4y agoIt is quite possible to own property in a given county while having no actual income in that area. If you wanted to get deep into the economics, you can consider a property tax as a tax on imputed rents (which is a standard appraisal method anyway).
- pessimizer 4y agoI said this is what happens when you don't have an income tax because I think it's true, not because I don't think this is better. People with property should pay proportionally more taxes because services go to people proportionally to the amount of property they have. I'm all for wealth taxes, and property taxes are wealth taxes. This is the gentry getting gentrified.
- roschdal 4y ago" in this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- leoedin 4y agoFor someone who lives in a different country without this type of tax - is the amount paid directly proportional to the assessed value? (Ie tax is 0.1% of value, or whatever) Or is the value just used to decide the relative amounts of tax each house pays? (ie there's $100m in property tax raised, split over all the properties proportionally to their value).
- criddell 4y ago> is the amount paid directly proportional to the assessed value? Yes. In many places most of that money goes to schools and is one of the reasons why public schools in wealthy suburbs are better than schools in less affluent areas.
- meepmorp 4y agoIt's a percentage of the assessed value of the property. Some places have different rates for commercial vs residential property, etc. In addition, there may be overlapping jurisdictions that separately impose real estate taxes - the local city/town, the county, possibly the state.
- WkndTriathlete 4y agoWell, it's a little more complicated than that. The municipality (the county, in the region of the country I'm in) sets the budget for the year, then each property's owner pays taxes in the amount of the fraction of the property's assessed value divided by the total assessed value of all property in the county times the annual budget. E.g. if the county's annual budget is $1,000, and there are three properties in the county assessed at $200,000, $300,000, and $500,000, then the property taxes for each property are $200, $300, and $500, respectively. Our county happens to have pretty conscientious governance: all properties in the county are re-assessed every two years and budget increases are in-line with inflation, so property taxes have increased very gradually since we moved in ~17 years ago. If the county doesn't have the workforce to assess all properties in the county as frequently and there are large increases in assessed values then property taxes can (temporarily) be significantly increased, which might be what is happening around Austin.
- hiram112 4y agoI get tired of those claiming property taxes are unjust with the claim that one never truly "owns" their own home, but instead just rents it perpetually from the state. Property taxes are a significant share of local and state tax revenue and pay for schools, roads, police, courts, etc. Similarly, I'm not too sympathetic to those (often elderly) who claim they can no longer pay taxes due to fixed incomes while home prices increase. The amount their taxes have increased are a fraction of the equity they've gained - they should be able to obtain some sort of "reverse mortgage" that pays the taxes in exchange for partial ownership of the home, which would then be settled at time of death by the heirs who'd just not inherit the home 100% clear. What does bother me about ever increasing property taxes is the entitlement of the localities and states on that increased revenue without justification for the improved services they'll provide to taxpayers in exchange. In a city like Austin where home prices have increased close to 50% in just the last two years, that must mean the city and county's gross tax revenue has also increased by some proportion of that. I think most states and localities should be forced to run like a typical well run HOA where all costs and planned expenditures are 100% transparent. Taxes should only rise on properties when there is a justified cost increase, and should not automatically go up when values do.
- technofiend 4y ago>Similarly, I'm not too sympathetic to those (often elderly) who claim they can no longer pay taxes due to fixed incomes while home prices increase. The amount their taxes have increased are a fraction of the equity they've gained Each time a house sells, property value jumps to the newly appraised value the following year. Sale prices are not public record in Texas, but oddly enough the amount borrowed can be found. So it's possible to impute sale price if you're willing to assume a given percentage down. Once you get the "homestead" exemption, appraised value may not go up more than 10% a year. And it does. Like clockwork. There are exemptions for over 65, disabled, etc, but they are flat dollar amounts instead of percentages or freezing annual tax increases. In short your assumption that gentrification drives valuation increases isn't wrong - any property sale regardless of the reason (in a rising market) does exactly that - but as a property owner in Texas I can personally state that every year I didn't protest my valuation always went up the maximum allowed by law, not matter what was happening. Including during the 2008 crash! And thanks to the rule of 7, this means that every 7.2 years taxes double. Realistically has the cost of supplying services from the state, county and city doubled over seven years? No, arguably not. We're only now seeing inflation that somewhat mirrors those cost increases. The assumption that taxes increase only as needed and required by the taxing entities is flawed. They will always find a use for any increase. The elderly are already allowed to defer taxes to when their estate is settled, no need for a reverse mortgage. But should they have to for arbitrary and capricious tax increases?
- AinderS 4y agoBut I was told homeowners love seeing their "assets" (American for "home") appreciate in value, and that this was the cause of NIMBY-ism?