3 ms·
"The Internet interprets censorship as damage and routes around it." -- John Gilmore I think we need to do some routing work. Attempts at regulation suggests
by JoshTriplett 15y ago
"The Internet interprets censorship as damage and routes around it." -- John Gilmore
I think we need to do some routing work. Attempts at regulation suggests that we haven't made the Internet sufficiently robust.
We can't easily stop countries from regulating the activities of entities which have a legal presence within those countries; anyone who wants to have an online identity tied to their offline identity risks having their online activities regulated through offline coercion. We also can't easily stop infrastructure providers from simply disconnecting all traffic at the infrastructure level, at least not until we have reliable mesh-networking protocols.
However, we can stop countries from regulating the activities of any individual entity which doesn't have a presence in those countries, or which avoids tying their online identity to their offline identity.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoThe Internet interprets censorship as damage and routes around it. The bureaucrats are coming to realize this. That's why part of the bill is to make such routing illegal. So, unsatisfied with just chilling our right to free speech, they also want to break the robustness of Internet itself.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoWe can fix that, permanently, and we should.
- waqf 15y agoYou can? How? Who is 'we'? How many people, how much time and how much money do you need?
- rwmj 15y agoEncrypt everything. Not much money required.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoA bit more complex than that, but yeah, it doesn't really require funds so much as hacker labor. A few examples of technologies that would help: - Pervasive use of end-to-end encryption by default, at the host level in addition to any application-level security. - Virtual Ring Routing: layer-2 mesh networking that scales to Internet-sized networks and never needs to floodfill the network with packets. Use encryption key fingerprints as the host addresses, so that this works well with end-to-end encryption. - Tor-like onion routing. - Key-fingerprint-based host naming, making DNS an optional (and selectable) directory service rather than a required core component. Of course, having end-to-end encryption means you can easily select a DNS server which gives you correct results, rather than one with various entries redirected to governmental agencies. With all of the above, you have a network where you can't prevent or intercept any communication, without pulling the plug on the entire infrastructure at the hardware level. And even then, the pervasive availability of mesh networking means that packets can find and use any available egress, which includes satellites, cell towers, and long-distance wifi.
- __david__ 15y agoSounds a lot like D. J. Bernstein's DNSCurve[1] and CurveCP[2]. CurveCP in particular seems like a good idea and supports some cool stuff like connections transparently moving across different IP addresses. [1] http://dnscurve.org/ http://dnscurve.org/ [2] http://curvecp.org/ http://curvecp.org/