4 ms·
Honestly: Does Glorifying Sickness Deter Healing?
- astrange 4y agoSeems misleading that this page talks about its own author in the third person.
- np_tedious 4y agoDefinitely weird. Perhaps the podcast summary was not itself written by Bari?
- gkoberger 4y agoIt's a podcast summary (the real content is the podcast), and those are almost always written in the third person.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI’ll be the first to admit that I don’t have my finger on the pulse of what’s chic, but this line: “…“the gentrification of disability,” how sickness became chic…“ is quite something.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoNot a big Twitter uswr
- kradeelav 4y agoIt's true. Certain circles of tumblr, tiktok, and twitter have made it "fashionable" to have mental disorders among themselves in an audience for victim points. (The uncharitable side of me would add "because physical disorders aren't so easily faked".) This obviously does not negate my sympathy for those with the real disorders - I have some as well. It's enraging to see the real stuff be treated so lightly though.
- Spivak 4y agoThis is such the wrong take, it feels trendy because those circles of social media / younger people have destigmatized talking about mental illness and sharing their experiences leading to a huge audience having a collective “oh shit that’s not normal” / “the normal amount of pain is zero” moment. And the communities that surround them adhdmeme or edanonymemes are spaces for people to commiserate that are now more visible than they previously were. “Teens faking mental illness” is a folk tale older than social media. The closest allegory is that mental illness is having its “pride” where it’s no longer a big shameful thing, you’re allowed to have it be visible, and it doesn’t make you less of a person. And just like pride you get similar “teens faking for attention”, “it’s just a phase”, “trenders” or “ugh people make it their whole personality.” If you want a not politically charged example of something being destigmatized suddenly increasing in prominence look at the graph of the percent of left handed people over time and guess when we stopped forcing kids to be right handed.
- codemonkey-zeta 4y agoWhile it's absolutely true that mental illness is being destigmatized, it's also true that large parts of this community are indeed "faking it", see /r/fakedisordercringe or search "fake disorder cringe" on YouTube. In totality this is probably just part of the pendulum swing, and as awareness of fake disorder cringe grows, and as mental illness actually becomes "just normal" we will also see this phenomenon slowly disappear. I just hope that all this doesn't lead to over-diagnosis of various mental disorders, because that would be a horrible outcome. We already see this with ADHD and autism, since those diagnoses are so fluid, and the nature of the "spectrum" is inherently fluid.
- TameAntelope 4y agoSee /r/adhdmeme as an example.
- cpsempek 4y agoAgreed. It also reminded me of the book Illness as Metaphor by Susan Sontag. In the essay she talks about the social perception and behaviors around illness and how those create real barriers to overcoming and curing disease. Specifically, the she writes about how consumption was at one time fashionable due to the gaunt physique and blasé attitude TB would often cause.
- diogenes_of_ak 4y agoI am somewhat “disabled” now (the hell with that moniker), there’s nothing chic about it. I’ll get better or die trying, but there’s a lot of confusion as to what all this means by both those well meaning and those who are assholes.
- ineptech 4y agoAnyone find a transcript? I'd be curious to read it but I really dislike podcasts.
- thrown_22 4y agoIt not only deters healing, it makes people act ill when they are not. Social media is filled with people pretending to be sick. If you want some of the most blatant see [0] the disability there isn't three broken ribs requiring a ventilator. Reminds me of Luis the 14th and his anal fistula [1]. Courtiers started faking anal fistulas after the king had an operation to remove his. It got to the point where they would get treatment for them, or fake getting the treatment, regardless of health. This was not a simple operation at the time. Chances of death were high, to the point where the first was performed on a condemned criminal who was pardoned if he survived. [0] https://www.insider.com/who-is-youtube-star-nikocado-avocado-2020-1 https://www.insider.com/who-is-youtube-star-nikocado-avocado... [1] https://tidsskriftet.no/2016/08/sun-kings-anal-fistula https://tidsskriftet.no/2016/08/sun-kings-anal-fistula
- thaumasiotes 4y agoSee also: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/book-review-crazy-like-us https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/book-review-crazy-like... > Around the Meiji Restoration, when everyone was obsessed with how great foreign stuff was, Japanese medical students went to Germany, learned psychiatry, came back to Japan, and told everyone they were neurasthenic. Being neurasthenic became first a fashion, then a class marker. The idea was that neurasthenics were people who were working too hard (good, admirable), and who were so smart and doing so much furious intellectual activity that it was straining their nerves (impressive). Also, they were probably sensitive souls too pure for this world. The most embarrassing extreme of this happened in 1903, when some photogenic Japanese youth carved a poem in a tree, went to a beautiful waterfall, and leapt to his death. Everyone praised him for how sensitive and artistic and neurasthenic this was, and turned him into a posthumous national hero. Meanwhile, “in 1902 an article reported that fully one-third of patients visiting hospitals for consultations were suffering from the new disease.” > Eventually Japanese psychiatrists got fed up, and started announcing that actually neurasthenia sucked and you should not have it. From a 1906 Japanese neurology journal: >> These days, young students talk about such stuff as “the philosophy of life”. They confront important and profound problems of life, are defeated, and develop neurasthenia. Those who jump off a waterfall or throw themselves in front of a train are weak-minded. They do not have a strong mental constitution and develop mental illness, dying in the end. How useless they are! Such weak-minded people would only cause harm even if they remained alive. > Finally everyone struck a compromise and agreed that most of the lower-class patients weren’t real neurasthenics (hard-working, intelligent, sensitive, admirable), but had a similar condition, imitating the symptoms of neurasthenia, based on being too weak and pathetic to cope. This seemed to do the trick, and people stopped coming to the hospital with neurasthenia symptoms. Watters writes: >> Looking back on the debate, it seems as if acceptance of neurasthenia had been so successful that psychiatrists felt obligated to restigmatize this mental disorder in hopes of limiting its adoption. By the end of World War II the diagnosis had almost completely gone out of style among both psychiatrists and the population at large. > He who has ears to hear, let him listen. Glorifying illness causes a lot of harm.
- XorNot 4y agoThis seems like an example of taking the giant ocean of people that is Twitter and Tiktok and pretending even 100 crazy people in a population of literally billions represents a "trend" or societal phenomenon.
- majormajor 4y agoOne might hypothesize that the most active users of Twitter might not be the most representative of the greater population, even... However, any idea along the lines of "people need help, not acceptance" needs to be very carefully discussed, because in the world I grew up in, you didn't get help or acceptance: you got punishment, you got shame, you even sometimes got violence as "treatment." A lot of people out there who will latch onto anything telling them they don't need to be accepting of difference.
- pawsforthought 4y ago> you even sometimes got violence as "treatment." For example, electroconvulsive therapy in its early days. To quote the Mayo Clinic [1]: > Much of the stigma attached to ECT is based on early treatments in which high doses of electricity were administered without anesthesia, leading to memory loss, fractured bones and other serious side effects. [1]: https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/electroconvulsive-therapy/about/pac-20393894 https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/electroconvulsiv...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- XorNot 4y agoI very much agree: my point was that the people who push ideas like this do so by misrepresenting occurrence rates and motivations (social media isn't an insight into people's lives at scale, it's as real as "reality" TV). Ultimately it's yet another "think of the children!" variant.
- antifa 4y ago
- lr4444lr 4y agoThe placebo effect to my knowledge has been demonstrably shown powerful enough even to shrink cancer tumors, so why would such a question even be posed at this point? We are just beginning to understand the mind body connection, but it's clear that negativity doesn't help much more than getting one's self to an actual doctor.
- TameAntelope 4y ago> Placebos won't lower your cholesterol or shrink a tumor. Instead, placebos work on symptoms modulated by the brain, like the perception of pain. "Placebos may make you feel better, but they will not cure you," says Kaptchuk. [0] https://www.health.harvard.edu/mental-health/the-power-of-the-placebo-effect https://www.health.harvard.edu/mental-health/the-power-of-th...
- stevenhuang 4y agoI would agree. However I've just read Dean Radin's Real Magic and now I'm not so sure. It would seem, if the ANOVA studies referenced in the book are real, that there really is something unexplainable about mind over matter. It's crazy yes. But all the studies are referenced in the book, and it sounds persuasive.
- TameAntelope 4y agoWhy "unexplainable" and not "thus far unexplained"?
- stevenhuang 4y agoWell, that's implied. I'm certain we'll get to the bottom of it eventually, whatever it is.
- seba_dos1 4y agoMy unscientific head-canon is that it's exactly the same thing that a person who usually struggles with their self-esteem experiences once it improves: suddenly many things become easier and fate seems somewhat kinder. Not because there's some magic involved, but because your own behavior influences your outcomes in multitude of ways you don't think about or notice.
- gumby 4y agodang, could you add a [podcast] or [audio] label please?
- NullIsland 4y agoAs someone with diagnosed mental illness and a degree in Psychology, I feel I can add something to this discussion. My personal experience growing up was difficult. As a middle age adult, I have developed skills that make my life seem pretty normal. I no longer need psychiatric medication. One thing I tell my kids that I didn't understand when I was young is, much of what you feel and experience is the human condition. We all feel depressed, anxious, behave neurotically at times etc.. it's a matter of degree. Does it keep you from having normal relationships, a job, being financially responsible? The problem with this is there are many people I have worked with or known who couldn't keep relationship's or a job but were not mentally ill. I would have been diagnosed on the spectrum had been born a couple decades later. My issues were blamed on being left handed, being "right brained". I think when we live in a society where we have time to spend on social media sharing our mental health challenges in lieu of just trying to find food and shelter, it's a sign of advancement. I am also hopeful that the current pattern of glorifying illness and sympathy seeking behavior will diminish as we all become comfortable talking about it.
- aaron695 4y ago
- KerrAvon 4y agoCan we stop linking commonsense.news, please? It’s no better than an alt-right hate site.
- thenerdhead 4y agoWhile the placebo effect definitely does exist, I do wonder if a sense of agency (i.e. having the sense of control over your sickness) also has a similar positive effect? The reason I ask is I've read many books about mental health over the last couple years. The more modern ones are all about acceptance and wearing them as a badge of honor. The timeless ones tend to talk about overcoming/controlling them by having a sense of agency. I'm not particularly proud or fond of wearing my problems as an identity. I think thoughts are more powerful than we believe. Sure we should absolutely talk about them openly, but how many people make themselves more sick because of their thoughts? I found myself in this pattern for awhile because I instilled the identity that I was sick. We all face the vicissitudes of the human condition. We all get to choose how we perceive them.