4 ms·
Everything is pay per view in Xanadu. It's a micropayment model. When you read, you pay, and the payments are distributed, word by word, to all the creators of
by Animats 4y ago
Everything is pay per view in Xanadu. It's a micropayment model. When you read, you pay, and the payments are distributed, word by word, to all the creators of the input text.
It's for storing expensive information in expensive computers to be sold expensively.
Think of it as a successor to Mead Data Central, Lexis, and Nexis[1], early centralized and expensive information retrieval systems. (Those are still around, merged into Reed Elsevier, publisher of expensive books and journals.)
The technology became cheap enough that such a business model was unnecessary. Although it was considered in the early days of the Web. Early thinking was that you'd have to subscribe to everything, and there would be charges on your Internet bill for each service, like cable TV. You'd pay to subscribe to a search engine. The New York Times went that route successfully, but few others did.
I knew some of the people behind Xanadu in the 1980s. They were mostly everything-is-a-market libertarians.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LexisNexis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LexisNexis
- kwatsonafter 4y agoA very informative post. I think a lot of the young people hip to Nelson miss this point. I'm no longer a, "free and open everything" kind of person but Nelson is far more of a BioShock character than you'd think. He's not a baby boomer in any sense; he's a child of Welles, Hawks, and Howard Hughes. I could see him being old enough not to freak out over Birth Of A Nation. God bless that crazy bastard. We used to make Americans so well.
- uncletammy 4y agoIts not about cheap vs expensive. It's about overall incentives within the system. A read should be as valuable as a write. At the very least, a read shouldn't be completely free.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoDepends what I am reading. If it is useful to me, then incentive modelling would suggest I should pay. If I get useless information, then I won't want to pay. If I get advertising, then they should pay. But how do I tell what value I will extract from it before I have read it? Information/concepts/ideas are not like physical objects at all.
- hutzlibu 4y agoYup, that never made sense to me, either. There might be ways to help with that, by free trial of x amount of words etc. but this would be hard to consistently implement. Also, there is clearly information so dense, it is way more valuable, than some shallow, mindless post. So the creators would have to up a price for every sentence? And the readers get that information, before they read and link? Alltogether just way too complicated and impractical.
- tadfisher 4y agoThis sounds eerily like web3.
- jdougan 4y agoNot exactly. It is a lot closer to pay for first view. https://xanadu.com/xuTco.html https://xanadu.com/xuTco.html is Ted's most recent thoughs on thematter.
- leadpan2 4y agoAnimats, bless you for posting this every time Xanadu comes up. There's always plenty of discussion on the man himself and his peculiarities. Not enough looking at the context of the times this was conceived, the problems Xanadu was expected to resolve, or the perspective and philosophies of the developers that ended up baked into the very structure written into it.
- Xanni 4y agoNote that prices could always be zero - the reason to include micropayments was to try and get access to the vast majority of existing culture that is currently only available for a fee. Ted wanted to bring in existing rightsholders rather than fight them. Unfortunately as it turned out that was never going to work. Just look at how hard the film industry fought home video, among many other examples of established industries fighting disruptors! Ted once called me a libertarian, and I immediately set him straight. Not even close, dude.