3 ms·
The roles that the federal legislative branch has assumed over the past 100 years are misguided and mostly based under an interpretation of the interstate comme
by yieldcrv 4y ago
The roles that the federal legislative branch has assumed over the past 100 years are misguided and mostly based under an interpretation of the interstate commerce clause and how much power can be delegated away from the legislature.
I can hold that observation and also realize that it will be wildly disruptive to make an adverse ruling on that power. I can also see there are other ways to reach the same result, its really not rogue or illegitimate for a court to simply say "leave that to your elected representatives", and thats what the court is going to do. Its extremely predictable and does not require any circular logic to do so.
I don't think the disruptive nature is a reason to avoid doing it, as a consensus bridging solution would be resilient as well, antifragile.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> mostly based under an interpretation of the interstate commerce clause The case that established the federal government’s wide Commerce Clause powers is truly bizarre: “An Ohio farmer, Roscoe Filburn, was growing wheat to feed animals on his own farm. The U.S. government had established limits on wheat production, based on the acreage owned by a farmer, to stabilize wheat prices and supplies. Filburn grew more than was permitted and so was ordered to pay a penalty. In response, he said that because his wheat was not sold, it could not be regulated as commerce, let alone ‘interstate’ commerce (described in the Constitution as ‘Commerce... among the several states’). The Supreme Court disagreed: ‘Whether the subject of the regulation in question was 'production', 'consumption', or 'marketing' is, therefore, not material for purposes of deciding the question of federal power before us.... But even if appellee's activity be local and though it may not be regarded as commerce, it may still, whatever its nature, be reached by Congress if it exerts a substantial economic effect on interstate commerce and this irrespective of whether such effect is what might at some earlier time have been defined as 'direct' or 'indirect.'’” In essence, not buying or selling wheat that is grown and consumed locally was somehow interstate commerce. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn
- colinmhayes 4y agoBuying less grain obviously effects grain prices, and since the grain market is interstate it effects interstate commerce.
- UIUC_06 4y agoSo "commerce" takes place even when you don't buy or sell anything? Is that what you're saying?
- CogitoCogito 4y agoI'd like an example of any action that doesn't affect interstate commerce by that line of reasoning.
- colinmhayes 4y agoThat’s the secret, there are none. People are arguing congress can make abortion laws now because of the interstate commerce clause, anything goes at this point.
- origin_path 4y agoHuh wow. How many of these totally illogical scotus judgements are out there exactly? No wonder the US left is freaked out by the new supreme court. It feels like they could pretty deeply change how US law and government works in favour of state's rights just by vacating obviously abusive rulings from earlier eras.
- yieldcrv 4y agoThere is usually a pattern, and there is a pattern now. As you notice, it is unnecessary hyperbole to consider the current court to be the odd one. The only thing “activist” about it is which cases it chooses to accept to rule on at all, as there are circumstances where the court can deny to hear a case under its appellate jurisdiction. But when choosing to hear a case, it is predictable what it will do to vacate an “abusive” interpretation that was in the benefit of the federal government subjugating all of the states. Many of these benefits can be recreated by Congress, and that is the process necessary to do it. If consensus within Congress is not possible, then the people will have to focus on something else for the time being.