2 ms·
In the case of organ donation, Thaler has written that he actually prefers mandated choice--i.e. there is no default but you have to either opt in or opt out--i
by ghaff 4y ago
In the case of organ donation, Thaler has written that he actually prefers mandated choice--i.e. there is no default but you have to either opt in or opt out--in this case. [1] But I'm not sure why a system where the government creates a default of either opt-in or opt-out (which you can change) wouldn't be a nudge.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/27/business/economy/27view.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/27/business/economy/27view.h...
(The issue being that in countries that are opt-out, doctors still often ask families for permission on the grounds that the deceased never made an affirmative choice to donate.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tgv 4y agoThe system is that you're by default in some register. The choice has already been made. Many people aren't even aware of it, or only remotely. You have to undertake action to change it. That's not a "choice architecture" in the nudge sense. That would require that you are presented with both options simultaneously, and are forced to choose. A nudge, e.g. on a web form, would then be to have one option already checked.
- ghaff 4y ago>A nudge, e.g. on a web form, would then be to have one option already checked. Yes. But an alternative is to present choices on a web form without one being pre-selected but with a choice mandatory. Which is essentially what I understand Thaler to be arguing for. >The choice has already been made. I'd say that still is a default but one which requires more effort to change than a pre-selected option on a webform. And arguably sufficient effort that it may no longer be reasonable to default to organ donation in that manner.
- Nasrudith 4y agoWouldn't it not be a nudge because it outright changes the unspoken costs? If the public is largely apathetic about what happens to their bodies post death, if the situation would leave them viable having to take an action vs inertia is an added costs. This could make deciding "not worth it" for low rewards, let alone preferring not to think of the possibility of their own demise.