4 ms·
The Ad Hominem Fallacy Fallacy
- lfpeb8b45ez 4y agoThis piece makes some interesting points, but then I realized the author is an internet pedant so none of it is worth reading. /s
- Maursault 4y agoAuthor begins essay with an ad hominem: > It is most often introduced into a discussion by certain delicate types, delicate of personality and mind, whenever their opponents resort to a bit of sarcasm. And fails hard with informal logic: > attempting to undermine a speaker's argument by attacking the speaker instead of addressing the argument. The mere presence of a personal attack does not indicate ad hominem: the attack must be used for the purpose of undermining the argument, or otherwise the logical fallacy isn't there. FALSE. Ad hominem fallacy certainly does not require intent! All that is required for ad hominem fallacy to be committed is 1) the argument is ignored, and 2) the speaker is characterized (doesn't even necessarily have to be a personal attack; could be complimentary and still be ad hominem). None of the author's examples indicate what the author claims. The author is apparently attempting to change the meaning of ad hominem fallacy to permit personal attacks without committing fallacy, so long as the purpose of the attack is not undermining a speaker's argument. But people are inscrutable, and it is exceedingly difficult to determine why anyone does anything. Fallacy is committed constantly without intent. Intent is not necessary for any fallacy, let alone ad hominem.
- eurleif 4y agoYou're equivocating between intent and purpose. It doesn't matter here why someone makes a personal attack; it matters what role the personal attack plays in their statement. That doesn't require reading their mind, merely reading their statement.
- Maursault 4y agoYou're ridiculous. Please describe the purpose of my statement. Am I trying to undermine your argument? Or am I just trying to characterize you for the purposes of characterizing you and it is unrelated to any argument you may have? How could you, or anyone who is not a mind-reader, possibly tell one way or the other? You can't, and no one can, not here, not anywhere, not ever. This is called a counter example, and it neatly destroys both your's and the OP's flawed arguments. Ad hominem quite literally means, "to the man." It does not mean, "to the man only for the purposes of x, y, z." An ad hominem fallacy is any statement whatsoever about the man. If you said, "circles are round," and I said in reply, "you are blue," this is an ad hominem fallacy regardless of purpose because it specifically regards you. idk where the author got their definition of ad hominem, but they're misinterpreting the meaning in the same exact way I would be misinterpreting the meaning of tires if I argued that "tires are tread for wheels for vehicles for the purposes of sticking to the road," so any object that has no purpose for sticking to the road can't be a tire... like what's tied to that rope hanging from a tree branch that people swing on. Can't be a tire because there is no road sticking here. This is the same mistake. Ad hominem is merely arguing "to the man," and the extra stuff, "for the purposes of undermining their argument" is not strictly part of its definition, but merely explains, when one's informal and formal logic is not strong, why the fallacy is employed: if I can't attack your argument, I can attack you... just not validly or soundly. And fwiw, I was not equivocating because I did not introduce ambiguity with a word having one meaning in part of the argument and the same word having a different meaning in another part of the argument. When one acts with purpose, then one acts with intent. It could not be otherwise, because the definition of purpose is to have as one's objective or intent. I employed logical equivalence, not equivocation. It's not as though I used "purpose" to mean a marine mammal misspelled later in my argument, but if I did, that would be equivocation.
- eurleif 4y ago>Please describe the purpose of my statement. Am I trying [...] It doesn't matter what you were trying to do. For all I know, you were trying to say an ancient incantation that will make my head explode. It matters what you did, which was to call me ridiculous without any implication that my ridiculousness undermines my argument. >Ad hominem quite literally means, "to the man." It does not mean, "to the man only for the purposes of x, y, z." An ad hominem fallacy is any statement whatsoever about the man. By this logic, "Socrates is a man; all men are mortal; therefore Socrates is mortal" is an example of the ad hominem fallacy, because it is a statement about Socrates the man. Perhaps you are willing to reconsider your assumption that the literal definition of the phrase "ad hominem" is the only thing one needs to consider in determining what it means? >And fwiw, I was not equivocating because I did not introduce ambiguity with a word having one meaning in part of the argument and the same word having a different meaning in another part of the argument. You introduced ambiguity between the purpose of a statement itself -- its role in an argument -- and purpose of a person in making that statement, also known as intent. Consider the statement: "The purpose of plant leaves is to photosynthesize food for the plant." Perfectly ordinary thing to say, and it doesn't imply that there is some person (or deity) who designed the plant with intent. It merely describes the role that leaves play for a plant. We can use the word "function" instead if you prefer. Arguing about whether the author is allowed to use the word "purpose" in the way that he did is not productive, and does not address his actual meaning.
- _8j50 4y agoEven in the author's example most of them are ad-hominem. The author's enlightened view is that in order for the argument to be ad-hominem it needs to be explicit. If you make an argument and my response is "you are an asshole" it is implied that I am replying to your argument and I am attacking your character. Those are the only required criteria. My response does not have to directly relate to the argument being made, it just has to be an attack of character instead of the substance of the argument. My calling the person an asshole maybe a bad argument made because I lack anything better or it could have been made to imply that the person making the argument did so with an ulterior motive of expressinf their asshole character.