4 ms·
To me, this article reads like one where there is an elephant in the room and it is not being identified. And I don't think the article can give enough of the r
by roenxi 4y ago
To me, this article reads like one where there is an elephant in the room and it is not being identified. And I don't think the article can give enough of the rich detail of what is going on in Haiti to give us useful clues about what the elephant is.
But those satellite photos look like the North-South Korea divide, and that is due mainly to unworkable political philosophies in the North. So I lean towards assuming ineffective leadership philosophies here too. There are some hints of that in the article, but not enough to draw conclusions.
- dalbasal 4y agoTo an extent, all historical/geopolitical/megapolitical/etc analysis suffers from this. The process is (a) observe a bunch of facts about history, geography, economic policies, politics or whatnot (b) explain the present (or future) state as a consequence of these facts. If you're inclined to observe certain facts or emphasize certain fields (say history), then your conclusions reflect that. The "method" of analysis is hopelessly prone to biases, from professional biases to ideological or chauvinistic. As the article shows, ideological (anti slavery) can affect the geographic (soil erosion/smallholdings) affecting and being affected by other things. "Why is Haiti Poor?" isn't, perhaps, as important to answer as "How can Haiti become wealthy." You need a less comprehensive theory for that. If our theory-building practices are free-style and bias prone, IMO it's better to minimize theory zize.
- permo-w 4y agoI read the elephant as being: banning foreign ownership and handing over a state's land to a presumably largely uneducated populace of freed slaves