4 ms·
Important to note this applies only to unvested stock. I'm not defending the move, but in reality the company could terminate the employees (at-will employment
by prostoalex 15y ago
Important to note this applies only to unvested stock.
I'm not defending the move, but in reality the company could terminate the employees (at-will employment in California), which would terminate their further vesting anyways.
This is not the clawback scenario that Silver Lake executed with Skype.
- alex_c 15y agoTerminating employees only to avoid their stock vesting - as opposed to valid performance reasons - is just as scummy. I also can't see how employees who give up their stock and remain with the company can possibly have a healthy relationship moving forward.
- elliottcarlson 15y agoEven if at-will employment, wouldn't such a threat possibly still be grounds for unlawful termination?
- darrellsilver 15y agoThat it's the unvested portion definitely makes a difference... But to be ethical you really can't just take unvested shares from employees because they have "too much", which is how the WSJ tells the story. Sounds like Pincus gave performance-based pay with a pretty transparent system, which should have worked well. Employees must know how management sees their performance, otherwise you're destined to have a bad breakup. If the story is accurate (hopefully it's not as who'd want to ever work at Zynga after this?) then the lack of stock for new hires was a management issue, and should be resolved from management, the investors and the board's pockets. After all, each investor saw the cap table before putting money in.