5 ms·
While this has a nice UI, it suffers from a ranking system that fails to weight prefixes correctly. For those of us in Canada, typing "ca" should probably rank
by mmastrac 15y ago
While this has a nice UI, it suffers from a ranking system that fails to weight prefixes correctly.
For those of us in Canada, typing "ca" should probably rank countries that start with the "ca" prefix first, followed by countries that have a word that starts with "ca", finally followed by countries that just happen to contain "ca".
I don't see much use in showing "United States" as the first match for a user who has typed "c" and "a".
The same problem exists for the prefix: "uni". The list in that case is:
United States
United Kingdom
Réunion
Tanzania, United Republic of
Tunisia
United Arab Emirates
United States Minor Outlying Islands
- steadicat 15y agoI typed 'ita' and the first option was 'United Kingdom'.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- raldi 15y agoThe full name is the United Kingdom of Great BrITAin and Northern Ireland.
- afterburner 15y agoWow, I think this autocomplete is too smart for its own good.
- benjoffe 15y agoPrecisely, I can't think of any situation where a user would search for a substring of a single word in the country name. If there is some edge-case where the first letter or so can be omitted that should be handled with the alternate-spellings feature.
- vacri 15y agoThat's not good enough to explain why United Kingdom (or "the united kingdom of greAt britAin And northern ireland") sits up near the top when you type in 'A'. Who the hell formally refers to the UK with any word starting with 'A'? Anyone claiming to be from 'Albion' in a web form is just intentionally being difficult...
- mooism2 15y agoBut still, Italy should come before the UK for "ita", except maybe if geoip lookup places you in the UK.
- ramy_d 15y agoindeed, still doesn't beat typing 'c' 3 times.
- AlexC04 15y agoI actually laughed at this. It's a total Canandian "in joke"
- larrik 15y agoIt also works for Connecticut on state selections!
- sjs 15y agoThat seems odd, I always just type "can".
- astrodust 15y agoIt depends on your OS. On some you can type and have it pick the best match, on others 'C' goes to the first C, then 'A' would go to the first A. C+C goes to the second C.
- ibelimb 15y agoPerhaps adding a geo-ip look up to help weight the results would make this better? None the less this is a huge improvement then a drop-down with every known country.
- craz 15y agoI've always wondered why more sites don't do this. Even without the fancy auto-complete, just set the default country using a geo-ip lookup.
- mwexler 15y agoDouble Edged Sword. While many times I am interested in the country I am in, in many cases, I'm getting info for the next country I am going to. It's frustrating to have to change a default box from where I am to where I want to go, or even not notice that it's set wrong. The real question is: how many people do I annoy compared to how many people are helped? If I help most people, and don't annoy my best customers, then that's a great idea. If my site is used by folks to find out info about countries other than their own, then it might turn out to be a bust. I would say: test it and see.
- ajankovic 15y agoThat seams as a minor mistake compared to not be able to type the name of the country in my native language. I guess that is not so obvious to the native English speaking users but it's the required feature if you are considering usability improvement as a goal of redesign.
- jisaacstone 15y agoYes this is missing the oft-overlooked option of synonyms. There is no reason why the auto-complete cannot have something like this: <option value="DE">DE</option> <option value="DE">Germany</option> <option value="DE">Deutschland</option>
- kbatten 15y agoThis has alternate spellings (data-alternative-spellings). So you can type America and it will show United States.
- Someone 15y agoA reason for not doing that is that it looks ugly to show multiple options for the same country. Another is that that can be confusing. Suppose I want to enter a country whose spelling/native name I am not sure of, and after a few characters, four options remain, three of which are correct, but I do not know that. That can cause a needless google to find out, say, the difference between Liberia, Libya, and Libië.
- thatjoshguy 15y agoIn this instance it wouldn't look ugly as they are just three different results that could show up in the search.
- ceol 15y agoIt would be confusing to the user to give three separate options for the same country and expect them to know they are the same. What it should do is if you type "deuts", it should return Germany (Deutschland) or if you're on a German site and type "germa", it should return Deutschland (Germany) The default/preferred language should be the same as the language of the website, and it should tell the user why it's returning a value that's different than what they're typing.
- samgro 15y agoCan anyone explain why 'United States' could possibly be an autocomplete result for 'CA'? I am staring at United States and just can't see a 'C' anywhere... have I totally lost it?
- jqueryin 15y agoFunny enough, I already proposed the same problem and solution with a blog post and sample code for "Re-thinking the State Dropdown with Autocompletion" back in May. Same issues applied, but there was at least some feedback on reddit and optional changes. http://skookum.com/blog/re-thinking-the-state-dropdown-with-autocompletion/ http://skookum.com/blog/re-thinking-the-state-dropdown-with-... http://www.reddit.com/r/Design/comments/h37gb/rethinking_the_state_dropdown_with_autocompletion/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Design/comments/h37gb/rethinking_the... My blog post links to jsbin sample source so feel free to optimize it with all of your proposed fixes. http://jsbin.com/oxifa3/18/ http://jsbin.com/oxifa3/18/
- raldi 15y agoUnited States of AmeriCA
- Gormo 15y agoFor the same reason 'sco' and 'eng' both autocomplete to 'United Kingdom'.
- stuaxo 15y agoCame here to say the same thing, it's annoying United Kingdom not coming top when I'm here + typing Uni...