5 ms·
I think Molly kinda buried the lede here which is that crypto companies and influencers explicitly encouraged people to invest money they could not afford to lo
by wmf 4y ago
I think Molly kinda buried the lede here which is that crypto companies and influencers explicitly encouraged people to invest money they could not afford to lose. The crypto "community" need to own up to this.
- dadoge 4y agoThat is true, esp with Michael Saylors comment about mortgage your house to buy buy BTC…I am pro BTC, but that is utterly horrible advice. That is indeed buried relative to many other points
- hammyhavoc 4y agoYep. Know an elderly couple that did exactly this, and so did their friends. It is shockingly common. They were all exploited. Someone should be held accountable.
- bagacrap 4y ago...really? what were they hoping to gain? By the time you're elderly I feel like you should understand that there's no such thing as low risk high reward investing.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoTo beat inflation. Simple as that. Interest rates aren't moving in line with the rate of inflation, ergo running out of money before they croak becomes something to be concerned by, thus most folks make investments in retirement to compensate for this. Lots of folks online saying that crypto is the only way to beat inflation. We both know that's bullshit, but with so many people huffing the laughing gas, it's easy to get taken in, especially with influencers and the Crypto.com Stadium et al.
- dehrmann 4y agoI like this thought and buy the motivation, but why not stocks?
- hammyhavoc 4y agoStocks aren't anywhere near as hyped, and countries aren't making stocks into legal tender ala Bitcoin, and Chivo. Not that I'm advocating for any of this BTW. It just seems like a perfect storm of massive hype, a lot of very convincing marketing, and the wind blowing in the right direction between a pandemic, Brexit, war, and a possible recession. When desperate, and many big names are involved, it can obviously look quite seductive. Used to work in this predatory niche about 7 years ago. Never again.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI heavily disagree with this. My generation's elderly people cannot read nor write. Of my one grandparent who can read, they have an 8th grade education. Only a minority of 60+ people were literate worldwide, much less financially literate. This also applies to my parents' generation, who grew up primarily subsistence farmers. They don't understand finances or markets or anything like crypto. They understand business investment as mutual actions of trust, where they lend their neighbor money and their neighbor buys something to benefit the town. Cryptocurrency hijacks those avenues of business investments by forming parasocial bonds and fake communities.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoIf I could underline your comment repeatedly, I would. We take our access to knowledge for granted.
- Animats 4y ago"They understand business investment as mutual actions of trust, where they lend their neighbor money and their neighbor buys something to benefit the town. Cryptocurrency hijacks those avenues of business investments by forming parasocial bonds and fake communities." Exactly. The crypto promoters built a community, acted trustworthy, and then they exploited it for an affinity scam.[1] The promoters gave the impression they were on your side. They weren't. Just like Madoff. [1] https://www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/affinity https://www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/affinity
- oarabbus_ 4y agoWas there some form of coercion involved? How is taking a loan against your home to gamble on risky, speculative assets the fault of someone else? If someone borrows against their home to try to double their money in stock trading or the casinos, were they exploited by Wall Street or Las Vegas?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> If someone borrows against their home to try to double their money in stock trading or the casinos, were they exploited by Wall Street or Las Vegas? Actually, yes. There are laws regulating loans for the purchase of securities. Most jurisdiction ban lending for gambling.
- oarabbus_ 4y ago1. Citation needed - which jurisdictions? This is certainly not true in the USA where you can use home equity for investment purposes multiple ways via HELOC, equity loan, or cash-out refi. Additionally, brokerages themselves offer margin, and margin investing/trading is a loan. 2. This doesn't address the point of where the coercion was involved to make this "exploitation". [0] https://www.lendingtree.com/home/home-equity/home-equity-investment/#:~:text=Yes%2C%20you%20can%20use%20your,a%20variety%20of%20financial%20uses https://www.lendingtree.com/home/home-equity/home-equity-inv.... [1]https://www.thebalance.com/can-i-invest-in-stocks-with-a-home-equity-loan-5324194 https://www.thebalance.com/can-i-invest-in-stocks-with-a-hom...
- dahdum 4y agoNon-purpose loans like SBLOC aren't allowed to be used to purchase or carry securities. I believe HELOC usually don't carry that restriction, so it would be legal. Probably a terrible idea, but legal.
- dahdum 4y ago> Actually, yes. There are laws regulating loans for the purchase of securities. Most jurisdiction ban lending for gambling. How is Wall Street exploiting them in this case? It sounds like they are committing some sort of fraud (perhaps even criminal?) against the lender by breaking the terms the loan by investing in speculative assets.
- drexlspivey 4y agoThis attitude led to attestations like “accredited investors” that locked anyone but the top 3-4% out of private markets where the majority of wealth creation is happening
- dehrmann 4y agoI'm not convinced a lot of opportunities open to accredited investors are that good. 2 and 20 takes a lot out of your returns.
- foogazi 4y agoBut are you owning up to this ?
- nharada 4y agoYes. Saying "don't invest more than you can afford to lose" while building an entire industry around convincing people to do exactly that is allowing these people to absolve themselves of responsibility by pointing out they offered a disclaimer at the start. It also fits in well with the generally libertarian nature of the crypto culture, allowing blame to lie with "personal responsibility" rather than grifting or scamming. It's like when the tobacco industry sponsored ads to "prevent kids from smoking" while investing millions in targeting them anyway.
- oarabbus_ 4y agoHow is this different than trading equities on the stock market (a decidedly non-libertarian culture)? Stock brokerages provide the exact same disclaimers - equities are inherently high-risk assets in which you can lose everything you've put in.
- nharada 4y agoI actually think the stock brokerages have done a similar thing -- it used to be that sophisticated and risky products like high leverage options were not available to retail traders who didn't have the money to lose, but with the rise of meme stocks and Robinhood things have changed. I'm not saying I think that's okay either. And look, I'm not defending the current banking system. Should average people have no options while the wealthy can use complex derivatives to increase their wealth and power? Probably not. I'm just pointing out that the crypto world shouldn't be doing this specific thing.
- oarabbus_ 4y agoI agree that brokerages have done similar lately, with massive ad campaigns targeting retail traders, gamifying their apps, and generally obfuscating the risks involved to less-informed individuals. And as you mention in the second part, it is a very difficult and tricky balance between protecting retail traders while preventing them access to instruments that the wealthy can use to further increase wealth. As an example, it used to be that USA-based customers could leverage trade (short trade or margin leverage long trade) on crypto exchanges, for example Kraken. However, due to regulatory pressure, Kraken now requires registering as an Eligible Contract Participant in order to margin/leverage trade - the key requirement being proof of $10M in discretionary assets. On one hand, this is probably a net "good" - short trading or leveraged long trades are _extremely_ risky, with the former having infinite loss potential and the latter resulting in margin calls or a greater loss than the account is worth (i.e. you're in debt to the exchange). I have little doubt that retail traders would've lost more money were this restriction not in place. On the other hand, this reeks of "you must be this rich to enter; peons need not apply". A wealthy person can 66
- superchroma 4y agoAlso worth noting that ordinary investors were cheated by proxy through no effort of their own as the firms investing their money have taken crypto on to their investment portfolios.
- sobkas 4y agoIf you believe entities* on the internet to do anything(that includes investment) you have bigger problem than some random crypto investments. A lot of parts of internet looks safe, but it's always one step away from a hack, so don't overestimate it safety. Also people lie to get your money, that includes "celebrities" and companies. *Most of the time you don't have idea if you talk to(or receive information from) real person, some hacker who hijacked their account, a program pretending to be a human(from emacs doctor to gpt3 and beyond), etc.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yucky 4y agoPersonal responsibility is a thing. Where does this idea that everyone must be protected from themselves come from? More importantly, where does it end? Should your barber be held accountable for providing a bad stock tip too?
- jollybean 4y agoYes, but accountability for spreading false information is a thing as well. What if someone says to take some drug 'because it's safe' - when it's not? I say let the lawsuits begin. Or better yet, have some kind of basic regs. Whenever anyone talks about 'health' or 'finance' in the commons, they had better be very clearly indicating that 'they don't know what the F they are talking about' and that people ought to 'talk to a doctor/accredited financial advisor' first and that 'following this advice could lead to illness/bankruptcy' etc.. I would love to see theses turds have to follow the same regs drug companies do: "This diarrhea medicine may cause X, Y, Z and A, B, C etc."
- yucky 4y ago>What if someone says to take some drug 'because it's safe' - when it's not? Well it depends on who it is (which goes back to personal responsibility). If I'm taking drugs that my barber recommended I deserve the same fate as if I buy the stocks or crypto he recommended.
- jollybean 4y agoYes, but some people present themselves as being credible. Authors, bloggers, etc. make it their professional interest to give such advice. The guy saying 'sell your home to buy BTC' is one such person. We need credible groups and institutions.
- yucky 4y agoHow does that work though? Does the government need to regulate what we can talk about? Who determines who is "Credible"? >The guy saying 'sell your home to buy BTC' is one such person. Almost nobody did that though. Which means 99.99999999% of people saw that to be bad advice and acted accordingly. For the handful who decided it was a great idea, that's on them. We don't need to regulate the speech of everyone to protect the biggest idiots from themselves.
- caeril 4y ago> crypto companies and influencers explicitly encouraged This wasn't Jim Cramer or some vetted CNBC talking head talking P/E ratios or future earnings potential. These are carefully-engineered social media accounts with follower counts blown up by obvious market-engineering campaigns. Again, to OP's point, if you're putting your life savings into speculative investment X, from the word of a rando instagram "influencer", you get what you deserve. Anybody in 2022 who doesn't understand that most social media presences are carefully curated, engineered, and biased, is a fool. Live or die by the word of the shoeshine boy, it's a tale as old as time. We all learned of 1637 and 1929 in high school history. If you didn't pay attention, that's on you.