10 ms·
Stop saying “They shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose”
- xwdv 4y agoI always find it amazing that when people make some large sum of money from a one time event like the sale of some NFT or an app going viral they seem to think they’ve stumbled upon some entirely new sustainable revenue stream.
- vandyswa 4y agoIf you invest, you own the gains. You also own the losses. If you think there can only be gains, you need to look more deeply.
- sieabahlpark 4y agoNo, because that's literally what investing is. You are investing hoping for a return. It's not a loan. You're not loaning money expecting to make back the premium and interest.
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoBack in what I'll loosely call "base reality," a loan is typically an investment, while ridiculous crap is typically not an investment.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agoThey shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoJust stop. The word "invested" doesn't apply at all when people are just setting fire to the money, or playing the lottery.
- cercatrova 4y agoThey shouldn't have gambled more than they could afford to lose
- dadoge 4y agoI’d rather this be “stop saying that XYZ will go to the moon, guaranteed money” not discouraging actually good advice “don’t invest more you can lose”. The real grift is all the false hope masked as certainty…and I say this as someone is is pro Bitcoin And also encourage “don’t invest more than your willing to put down and hood for 5yrs in case of a sudden downturn” Edit: P.S. my HN handle was created well before Elon was pumping doge and I now regret my HN handle
- majormajor 4y agoA couple knee jerk reactions to the headline in here, but the article makes a compelling case that in that case, there needs to be a lot more restriction on how wildly speculative "investments" can be advertised. It's a "stop blaming the people misled by overwhelming advertising campaigns instead of the sharks" claim. Especially the "shouldn't have" past-tense. Steph Curry telling people FTX made it so they didn't have to be a crypto expert, for instance. But maybe inexperienced non-experts tossing money into a whole bunch of random tokens is NOT a great recipe for success... A whole lot more time and money is spent on telling people you should put your money in this thing than is spent telling them to think twice, that there's no such thing as a free lunch, that promised double-digit rates of returns suggest it's not a safe investment, etc. So either turn down the volume on the one, or turn up the volume either louder on the latter. I'd pick the former, though.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago>that there's no such thing as a free lunch I would not believe anyone who said they did not already know this deep down. Even children learn this early on by just observing the world. Nobody gives away something for nothing. All these "investors" were aware they were gambling and hoping to earn something for nothing.
- majormajor 4y agoCan you point me to any well-broadcast government or expert warnings that it was a scam or that some of them in particular would fall apart much more quickly than others? Cause on the other hands, here's all the competing information you're wanting people to filter out: * government officials were getting on board with "pay me in crypto!" bullshit and similar * millions were spent on advertising campaigns about how actually, these days, you don't have to think about it * millions were spent on advertising campaigns trying to get people afraid of being left behind * government policy in the US, due to conservative politics, has made investing for your future an increasingly individual responsibility rat-race for several decades now * new computer technology, in the past five decades, has created something from nothing wealth-wise MANY times, often (but not always) in sustainable ways Even a relatively skeptical investor, who hadn't heard of it in 2012, and who sat on the sidelines in 2017, at this point may have looked at a ten-year chart of BTC, said "ok, there's some solid history now, maybe the chicken-littles are actually the same sort who say that the whole stock market is a scam, even the government is starting to get on board with crypto"... and then you want them to be able to dig deep enough to understand why they're all castles in the sky to some extent, but some are more or less guaranteed to fall apart more quickly than others?
- cercatrova 4y agoBut...they shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose. This article gives no reasons why the author's thesis should be true, besides people being desperate. > So “don’t invest more than you can afford to lose” is tough advice to swallow for the large group of people who are seeing the gleaming promises around crypto, but who also don’t _have_ money they can afford to lose. So if they don't have money, then they shouldn't invest it in speculative investments like crypto. > It’s apparently easy for people to castigate those who’ve just lost everything by repeating this refrain, in the same way it seems to be easy for people to only start pointing out the “obvious Ponzi” or “clear scam” projects only after everything crumbles. No, people have been saying since the beginning that crypto is a scam, not after these scams happen. And even if it were after scams happening, there have been so many [0] that surely people would understand that future scams are likely. Honestly, I have no sympathy for these people. If they want to be greedy and commit millions of dollars into these scams ([1] which the author hyperlinks to) then that's on them. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes, isn't that how the saying goes? [0] https://web3isgoinggreat.com/ https://web3isgoinggreat.com/ [1] https://old.reddit.com/r/Invest_Voyager/comments/vsj9nx/how_much_crypto_usd_did_you_have_on_voyager_ill/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Invest_Voyager/comments/vsj9nx/how_...
- wmf 4y agoI think Molly kinda buried the lede here which is that crypto companies and influencers explicitly encouraged people to invest money they could not afford to lose. The crypto "community" need to own up to this.
- dadoge 4y agoThat is true, esp with Michael Saylors comment about mortgage your house to buy buy BTC…I am pro BTC, but that is utterly horrible advice. That is indeed buried relative to many other points
- hammyhavoc 4y agoYep. Know an elderly couple that did exactly this, and so did their friends. It is shockingly common. They were all exploited. Someone should be held accountable.
- rvz 4y ago> The New York Times ran the headline, “They Made Millions on Luna, Solana and Polygon: Crypto’s Boom Beyond Bitcoin”, describing the “newly wealthy” crypto speculators.2 “Young investors are abandoning stocks for crypto — and making millions”, said the New York Post.3 CNBC profiled a woman who “went from living paycheck to paycheck to making over $109,000 selling NFTs”. And so the narrative of such news is also further boosted and manipulated by the media, poisoning the psychology of tons of retail investors. It would be better that these media organisations do not add any oxygen to these 'too good to be true' schemes and survivorship bias of a few winners just for retail investors to click their ads, as they attempt to get as many suckers FOMOing into schemes like Celsius, Stablegains, etc in the first place. The media, influencers, etc are all partly to blame for spreading this as well. It also isn't exclusive to crypto. It is also no different to the SPAC craze of many failed SPACs going under, high risk options on penny stocks and other highly speculative stocks that retail investors were sucked in by the mania and dumped upon recently. There is no change in what happened of these pump and dumps and the mania of Jan 2021 other than more people losing their whole investment. Yes. All of it needs to go under strict regulations. Include that for Stocks (SPACs), Crypto and Options as well.
- fiprofessor 4y agoExcept that what's being implied about the New York Times and New York Post articles in that quote is misleading. Yes, the headlines mention the flashy gains, but both of the referenced articles repeatedly mention the losses and scammy aspects of some coins. For example, here's a pull quote from the NYT piece: > But as some people mint millions from little-known cryptocurrencies, others have seen impressive gains disappear overnight. For every Solana or Luna, there’s an out-of-the-way token that shoots up in value, only for its price to collapse. Some of these projects are scams, or what industry experts call “rug pulls,” in which someone aggressively markets a coin, then immediately liquidates the holdings, leaving investors with major losses. The whole second half of the article is about such scams and how many gains are ephemeral "paper gains". Meanwhile, the New York Post piece quotes an expert who says "The volatility attracts people who like gambling, excitement and so forth ... They’re not so interested in underlying economics, but [rather] the chance of a very rapid, high gain, or a very rapid, sharp loss." It also profiles a TikTok influencer who uses astrology to predict coin prices -- with the clear implication that this is ridiculous. So while the overall message of the essay is on point (there was tremendous misleading and dangerous advertisement), a lot of "traditional journalism" was in fact extremely skeptical and quick to point this out.
- Xeoncross 4y agoI agree with the author, empathy is sorely missing from a lot of arenas these days and explaining the situation really helps put things in perspective. Why did they take the risk? Well, they were in a tough spot. Confronting them with hostile tones or name-calling is going to shut off more from the warnings. I'd rather young people learn about scams young than fall to a get-rich-quick scheme when they have a family to support or are about to retire. The reason old people call all get-rich-quick schemes 'scams' is that many have already been through these episodes.
- coldtea 4y ago>So “don’t invest more than you can afford to lose” is tough advice to swallow for the large group of people who are seeing the gleaming promises around crypto, but who also don’t have money they can afford to lose. If they don't "have money they can afford to lose", then there are no "gleaming promises" for them. At best there are lures... Though I'm down with the idea that it's partly fault of those advertising this as a surefire profit, and preying on the desparate and/or financially illiterate...
- burnished 4y agoGonna go ahead and quote the bit that people clearly have not read before commenting. " So “don’t invest more than you can afford to lose” is tough advice to swallow for the large group of people who are seeing the gleaming promises around crypto, but who also don’t have money they can afford to lose. They can take a big chance in hopes of the bright future they’ve been promised by an industry with a huge marketing budget, or they can risk missing out and staying in an already untenable situation. It’s apparently easy for people to castigate those who’ve just lost everything by repeating this refrain, in the same way it seems to be easy for people to only start pointing out the “obvious Ponzi” or “clear scam” projects only after everything crumbles. "
- rjmunro 4y agoWe don't need to stop saying "Don't invest more than you can afford to loose", we need to be saying it louder (in the future tense). To people who were sucked in by the marketing from influencers etc. I am sorry. We need to do better at regulation etc. I know that Crypto is mostly about avoiding regulators. That's not a good idea. Regulators are not the enemy. When done right, they level the playing field and protect the small investor.
- d23 4y agoYeah, the article's headline is an odd conclusion to draw from the evidence in its body. If the growing cacophony is "put everything into crypto," it seems the exact thing we'd want to do in response is say "don't invest more than you can lose."
- DevKoala 4y agoI agree that people shouldn’t invest more than they can afford to lose. I’ve invested in Crypto, and I am still mildly up on my total portfolio. I was even using one exchange that got shut down; that’s $2k I will never see again. I never put more than I would feel comfortable with losing and that’s why I have nothing to worry about.
- randrews 4y agoThis is hard to write. In 2015 I joined a local club for electronics hobbyists. It was great, we met every other week, had show-and-tell presentations of the things we were learning and building, I made a lot of friends and learned a whole lot. But, in 2020, it started getting taken over by crypto bros: where before we'd have presentations about a new IoT platform or how to generate some signal, now we'd have presentations about yet another bitcoin-trading thing, usually not even run by people who were regulars in the group. At each one of these, I and a couple others did try to explain, politely, that crypto wasn't what was being claimed (overnight guaranteed millions!) and that these people didn't seem to understand basic things about economics (bitcoin is not a "store of value"). And we got laughed out of the room for it. After a few times of that I just stopped going to the club, and I wasn't the only one because the whole thing disbanded a couple weeks after that. So, when you say that the crypto people lied about this and people got suckered in, well, no sympathy. Because you're ignoring all of us who tried to point out the lies and caught shit for it. Maybe you all shouldn't have invested more than you could afford to lose.
- throwaway5959 4y ago“Have fun staying poor” has really come back to bite them eh?
- boffinism 4y agoRight, but now imagine you weren't one of the people who had someone knowledgeable and sceptical pointing out the flaws. Imagine all you ever came across was crypto bros and people who believed, repeated and amplified their bullshit. Imagine the received wisdom all around you, from your family, peers, role models, was: this is the thing to do. Yeah, a bunch of people ignored you and ostracised you. But not everyone. Not most people. Most people never even got the chance to ignore you.
- randrews 4y agoI have a hard time believing that anyone actually falls in that category. No living grandparents who remember the great depression? No memories of 2008? And even if they were in a total vacuum, why wouldn't it occur to them, as it did me, to ask "what makes the line go up?" If people put X USD into buying Bitcoin, and then can sell that Bitcoin for Y USD, and Y is greater than X, then the extra money has to come from somewhere. Where? Without knowing that answer, even before I knew the first thing about blockchain or crypto, I was unwilling to buy any. I don't care who in your life was lying to you or pressuring you to invest, anyone who got suckered in without asking that basic question should have done more due diligence.
- semicolon_storm 4y agoAs somebody who lost money in the Voyager collapse, why can't we say both? People shouldn't have invested more than they could afford to lose, and the recent crypto situation is a massive systemic regulatory failure. Predatory companies were making impossible promises with zero transparency and accountability, BUT it's still on the investor to do their due diligence if they're going to be placing huge bets.
- jimmar 4y agoIt's not clear that due diligence is even possible in the crypto community right now. Crypto companies are very opaque about their operations. Here's a quick clip of Mark Cuban saying that Voyager was virtually risk free: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZYMtVBXUrE&t=119s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZYMtVBXUrE&t=119s. I'll give Mark Cuban the benefit of the doubt that he thought his words were true, but even being that closely tied to Voyager, he didn't really know what was going on. I pulled my little bit of cryptocurrency out of BlockFi because I have no way of really knowing if they'll be another Voyager. There are few players I trust on the cryptocurrency space.
- semicolon_storm 4y agoYes, that's one of the systemic failures. Despite proponents saying blockchain tech brings a new level of transparency, it's now very clear there was near zero transparency for companies built around the blockchain. For the layperson, there is no way you could have done proper DD for these investments because the regulations to force disclosures that could have helped you did not exist. However, the inability to do proper DD on their claims due to the information not existing probably should have served as a form of DD.
- Ekaros 4y agoDue diligence in case of opaqueness is to not even try. If you can't understand how the money is made and how the whole thing can even operate it is better to skip the whole thing. You might lose, but it is not like crypto is only opportunity around.
- 4y ago
- clintonwoo 4y agoSo sick of reading all the time about people wanting to get rich from crypto grift. It's not providing any value to society to buy crypto and resell it at a higher price later to some sucker. These people don't even want to use crypto to make transactions. It's definitely not a good idea to put all your net worth in it for a number of reasons also. Principally being it's not a mature system. There's nothing that says a new crypto alternative will come out tomorrow that totally voids all the stuff that exists today.
- charcircuit 4y agoPlenty of people buy stocks hoping they can sell it for more to the next sucker before the business closes. Many don't even use their voting power that they get for owning part of the company. Someday another company could come along that does the same thing but better / cheaper. Cryptocurrency investing isn't unique.
- 1270018080 4y agoAt a certain point one can be so reductive and remove enough nuance such that all words lose meaning. We might as well call profit the greater fool theory. Now nothing matters. Equating crypto to investing in companies is nonsense.
- charcircuit 4y ago>Now nothing matters. That's my point. >Equating crypto to investing in companies is nonsense. Why? Even if you go back to "It's not providing any value to society to buy crypto and resell it at a higher price later to some sucker." It's not like me selling a share to someone else provides society value. Unless I do something for society with the money I made, but the same would apply to money based off profitable cryptocurrency investments.
- clintonwoo 4y agoA high share price allows companies to issue stock on the public market and raise money. Just so you know. So there is valid utility to buying stocks.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- labrador 4y agoI spent a lot of time in the Dec 2021, Jan 2022 time frame arguing against the crypto mania, often to be told that my generation were dinosaurs and didn't get it. I gave up after the Matt Damon super bowl ad and waited for the inevitable crash. Now Molly White wants me to feel bad, but like Rhett Butler at the end of Gone With The Wind, "Frankly my dear, I just don't give a damn."
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoYeah, Rhett Butler was another one of these reality-based people. What a buzzkill.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoThe purpose of virtually every cryptocurrency that has ever been created is to cash out to fiat. Everything that is sitting on someone else's network is just a way to take money from speculators, and the rate of success around these products usually has more to do with the quality of their ads than the quality of their product. What's the crypto community been saying for year? That transparency, identity, accountability, and regulation are for oldheads? How's that working out?
- fabian2k 4y agoThe main difference here is the sophistication of the investor, and the people this article is about clearly did not fully understand the risk they were exposed to. Molly White posted a whole bunch of letters to the Court on Twitter related to the Celsius bankruptcy, and the excerpt read pretty much exactly like when people get outright scammed. Of course nobody should invest a large portion of money they need into something as speculative as cryptocurrencies. But that doesn't mean that people that are not critical enough of outlandish claims and invested in stuff like Celsius deserved to lose it all. There are certainly people that understand the risk and participate anyway, and greed got the better of some of them. But there are also people that were essentially just scammed.
- oh_my_goodness 4y ago"Investment" by definition is a way of storing more money than you can afford to lose. Anything else isn't an investment. There are plenty of words for transactions that should be limited to money you can afford to lose: Las Vegas, lottery tickets, options, crap, toxic waste, street drugs.
- astrange 4y agoIt’s perfectly reasonable to keep money you’ll need in the next 10 years in a slightly risky investment (like 60 bonds/40 stocks) even if you couldn’t afford to lose 100% of it. It’s more sensible than keeping it in cash for that long. Money in risk-free liquid form is guaranteed to lose to inflation.
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoSure. Exactly. That is investment. How many people would say "don't put more money than you can afford to lose into a diversified mix of 60% bonds and 40% stocks"?
- Ekaros 4y agoI don't think there even is risk-free way to keep money. Physical money can burn, money in bank is insured up to certain limit or government can simply decide to bail-in it...
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoI guess since nothing is risk free I should just put everything into crypto. [Sarcasm notice: This is sarcasm.]
- astrange 4y agoThe limit on FDIC insurance isn’t a problem, you just get more than one account.
- jollybean 4y ago? Sorry Molly, it's not even 'investing'. It's totally arbitrary ridiculous speculating'. Nobody should be putting anything into crypto unless they could afford to literally burn it and not care. I mean, instead of responding to these people as 'giving poor investing advice' it should be more along the lines of 'they are all giant scammers, liars and hustlers, along with 99% of all crypto activity'. It's kind of interesting how well she documents everything as if it needs to be documented. Just assume crypto ads/services are a scam until there is evidence otherwise. Edit: yes, yes, fine, there might be some value in crypto, there's some intellectual goodwill there, but it's full of giant hustles, frauds and scams, and the pragmatic reality is the rational, default purview should be 'it's a scam'. The industry has completely burned any goodwill, it will take something else to recover it.
- lesam 4y agoIt’s not just bitcoin. People are told to “invest for retirement” and to do their financial planning based on 4-8% per year growth after inflation, when the risk free rate has been 2% or less for 20 years. If the US stock market stagnates for the next 20 years like it has in other countries, people will be blamed for buying ETF’s too. “Don’t invest money you can’t afford to lose”, say the people who profited from 20% annual growth on houses while mortgaged to the hilt. But also, “why can’t millennials afford houses?”
- dahdum 4y ago> People are told to “invest for retirement” and to do their financial planning based on 4-8% per year growth after inflation, when the risk free rate has been 2% or less for 20 years. You're trading risk for reward, so the standard advice of de-risking your portfolio as you approach retirement age is quite reasonable. Doesn't make much sense for a 24 year old to stick to the risk free treasury rate for 40-50 years.
- kkielhofner 4y agoWhat about greed on all sides? Madoff’s “unusually consistent” returns of 10% were a huge red flag but even his allegedly savvy clients were happy to keep getting statements. Their greed enabled his. Greed is a real thing and at a certain level it seems to shut off higher reasoning functions in the brain. “If it seems too good to be true it probably is” That said fraud is fraud and there really are perpetrators and victims, more or less.
- wmf 4y agoSome people are making a distinction between greed (having enough money and wanting more) and desperation (having no money and wanting enough).
- stephc_int13 4y agoThe appeal of easy money is an huge and highly destructive cultural issue, we can't simply blame corporations on this, there is a problem with everyone involved. It is much more difficult to scam someone honest.
- robcohen 4y agoI am very pro crypto, and I am also in many ways a libertarian, but I do agree that most people are simply not smart enough to handle their own investment decisions. I think picking stocks, investing in crypto, buying specific bonds, investing in anything other than market ETFs should be banned by anyone who isn't an accredited investor. The nice part about the definition of an accredited investor is you can now just pass exams if you aren't wealthy enough. For me, that is enough to ensure sufficient liberty exists for those who want it. You do need sponsorship though, which should change. I consider myself someone who is pretty adept at investing. I have a degree in economics and I've studied finance on my own time for many years. I've had many conversations with friends who simply lack the discipline to learn about finance, make a strategy and stick with it. Many friends have been hurt by investing in crypto, panicking, then taking their money out. People are simply too stupid to make these kinds of decisions. If you want to take those risks, go pass Series 7, Series 65, and Series 82 exams. At least then you're somewhat competent enough to know why you make a bad call.
- RickJWagner 4y agoThose people weren't investing in crypto. They were speculating in crypto. The difference is that investments have some rational reasoning behind hoping for a future profit, beyond 'the greater fool' theory. Bonds have a solvent business's pledge to repay them. Stock represent ownership in some business, hopefully one that makes profits for its owners. Crypto seemed only to hope that someone else would come along and pay more for it. See what Charlie Munger and others have said. For a long time.
- skyzyx 4y agoTLDR: 1. Scammers exist. Fuck those guys. 2. Dumb people are dumb. Both things are true. You can’t call-out one without calling-out the other.