5 ms·
The best version of GNOME was Gnome 2. Before Gnome 3, I used Gnome for years. They really burned a lot of users with that reduction in functionality and consis
by loeg 4y ago
The best version of GNOME was Gnome 2. Before Gnome 3, I used Gnome for years. They really burned a lot of users with that reduction in functionality and consistently user-hostile attitude.
The closest modern desktop environment to Gnome 2 is KDE’s Plasma. It’s easy to use out of the box and doesn’t require any configuration (unless you want to do that kind of thing, and then it’s available — unlike in Gnome 3+).
- squarefoot 4y agoWhat's much worse is that most of the problem is on GTK, whose terrible post V2 design affects lots of software outside of Gnome.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoPlasma seems like the worst part of KDE to me. It looks nice and has good functionality when it's working, but unfortunately it's riddled with bugs. Panels crash all the time and don't come back until I restart plasmashell. I gave up on Plasma. I still use kwin and several KDE applications, like Dolphin, but now I use those with LxQT instead of Plasma. It doesn't look as stylish, but it seems to be rock solid. Plus I still get all the nice compositing effects and configurability of kwin.
- seba_dos1 4y agoWorth noting that this approach would have been impossible to execute on GNOME Shell, which integrates its shell, compositor and window manager in a single component.
- silisili 4y agoI liked 2 the best, especially with a dock. I understand what they were attempting in 3, but it was such a letdown. Writing everything in JS was a weird decision. I remember for the first few releases, having to constantly restart the shell because the JS engine leaked so badly. You could watch RSS grow indefinitely everytime you moused over the top left corner. It's a lot better now, usable with a few extensions...but I still think what a waste it was tossing 2 like they did. Extensions are an OK idea, but because they're mostly JS and CSS, there doesn't seem to be much safety there. It's very common for them to break each release because of some obscure attribute change.
- jonkoops 4y agoPersonally I think GNOME 3 nowadays is one of the best DE I have ever used and I continue to use it every day.
- nebalee 4y agoWith GNOME 3 being the default on Fedora and Ubuntu (and others) I'm sure it has more users today than GNOME 2 ever had.
- behnamoh 4y agoWhy is it the default on most modern distros?
- Spivak 4y agoBecause it is far and away the most feature complete, polished, and stable DE that exists in the Linux ecosystem. It requires zero learning curve, has an app suite that isn’t riddled with bugs, everything for the desktop user can be done in the GUI. Like there is no alternative that does what GNOME does. It’s GNOME and forks of GNOME, a chasm, then KDE, another chasm, and then the DIY DEs/WMs dejour.
- skeletal88 4y agoUmm.. what does Gnome have that KDE doesn't? To me they are equal in functionality, just that KDE isn't forcing the opinions of their developers on me and lets me choose what and how I want to do stuff. And has more features (file selection with image preview, yes, it exists!)
- pjmlp 4y agoIn the beginning, the licence and being C instead of C++, that is why it was started in first place. KDE is older and Qt licence was different in the 1.0 days.
- samtheDamned 4y agobetter accessibility for one, which is a major reason it's the often the only option in many enterprise distributions.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoSurely the closest DE to Gnome 2 is MATE, which is literally just GNOME 2, but with development continued.
- Crysstalis 4y agoIt is not a "user-hostile attitude" to remove features. Every project that does some kind of user study will do this eventually, because: 1. Not every feature is equally useful 2. No one is using the feature, and so maintaining it is a waste of time 3. Sometimes developers discover a better way to implement a feature 4. Some features can turn out to be just harmful and misleading 5. There is no one available who wants to maintain the feature and so it slowly deteriorates and breaks over time, and must be removed to prevent further breakage And so on. If you program in your day job, I bet you can think of a few other valid reasons you have removed a feature at work, too. GNOME has not done anything out of the ordinary here, and it is incorrect to describe it this way. If you believe they have taken specific actions that were hostile towards you, then you should say what those actions are. But the mere act of changing or removing a feature that you happened to use is not a display of hostility, it is just the normal development process working as intended. >and then it’s available — unlike in Gnome 3+ This is incorrect, Gnome 3+ can be configured with shell extensions.
- ginko 4y ago
- Crysstalis 4y agoNo, I do not work for Red Hat and I have never worked for Red Hat. I am just a person who uses GNOME and systemd, and while I do have my own complaints about them, I have enough experience to respond to most of the common complaints. Are you aware that there are many Linux distributions besides RHEL and Fedora that are shipping GNOME and systemd? I also do not appreciate you looking through my comment history to try and pick something out to seemingly dismiss what I am saying. Is it inconceivable that I do not have a financial interest, and I just happen to be knowledgeable in these areas?
- tadfisher 4y agoThis is against the rules on HN.
- phkahler 4y ago
- linuxhansl 4y agoTotally agree. Used Gnome 2 some, then switched to KDE and never looked back - to be honest.
- asoneth 4y agoI just don't get these comments. It's perfectly reasonable to prefer KDE because you like Plasma or it has the functionality you need. It's a nice desktop environment with a lot of functionality so I can see why it appeals to many people. What I don't get is why so many people feel the need to diminish open source projects they don't even use. What is your end goal with a comment like this? Are you just expressing your opinion so that no one forgets that many people do not like Gnome 3? Are you hoping to better understand why the Gnome community has a different development philosophy than the KDE community? Are you trying to convince someone of something?
- traverseda 4y agoGnome has pissed a lot of people off, and this is the end result. I mean I think it's pretty reasonable for people to have ill will towards the project and I think that politely interjecting with the occasional "we don't like gnome" is reasonable. If only to encourage new projects to use a toolkit that isn't so closely tied to the gnome experience. That being said I do have to give them some respect for XDG-desktop-portal, which has made my main complaint (gnome's filepicker being bad and non-optional for even basic software like firefox) no longer an issue.
- asoneth 4y agoI get that their design direction wasn't everyone's cup of tea, and I get why many abandoned Gnome 3. > politely interjecting with the occasional "we don't like gnome" From my perspective these comments seem neither polite nor occasional, and they result in Gnome threads devolving into partisan arguments rather than technical discussions. Of course Gnome isn't the only lightning rod -- posts that mention Mozilla, Apple, Microsoft, US national politics, systemd, etc also seem to inspire an inordinate number of posts that are argumentative and off-topic. It's mostly just disappointing. I was honestly hoping for a discussion about what kind of people contribute to a large open source project instead of rehashing the endless circular debate about whether the Gnome Community is user hostile or not.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sebow 4y ago> The best version of GNOME was Gnome 2. Very much in agreement.If my unix* history is correct, even the apple design copied(or let's say "was influenced") a lot from the gnome 2 UI.