4 ms·
I don't think this problem should be solved by Cloudflare. Cheap domains will always exist and they shouldn't be a problem. The problem lies with Google and its
by jeroenhd 4y ago
I don't think this problem should be solved by Cloudflare. Cheap domains will always exist and they shouldn't be a problem. The problem lies with Google and its failure to detect these spam sites.
Surely Google can spare an engineer or two to do a deep dive into the way any one of these spam sites manages to get itself to the first page of Google, work out their scheme, and fix the algorithm? This problem isn't exactly hard to reproduce!
- Hrundi 4y agoThe fact that this has been going on for several years makes me believe Google either doesn't care or the problem is particularly hard to fix (less believable)
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoGoogle has at the very least neglected its search for many years now and recently has also actively made it worse through all the censorship and thought control stuff. I find it rather surprising because essentially all of google’s success is lynchpinned by search. All it would take is for a narrative to dominate that the best results can be found elsewhere, which does not seem particularly remote, considering how much damage google has done to its search.
- ehnto 4y agoIt has been an ongoing battle for 10-15 years at this point. Search engines are constantly battling people trying to game their systems. I have to wonder if Google hasn't lost the thread a bit, inside their surely quite complex algorithm black boxes. For a while now Google has suggested that the best way to rank well is to have human readable content and focus on user experience. At the same time, natural language generation has come leaps and bounds, to the point where sometimes even I, a human, can't tell if an article has been spun by a bot or not. So if Google starts ranking human readable content, and robots can now produce human readable content, what is the next ranking signal they can use to differentiate spam from humans? Are we going to end up with "Verified Websites" ala verified Twitter handles? A huge portion of the web at this point is just bots communicating with eachother, and legitimate business systems having to process bots participation on the internet. I imagine the portion of the web that Google crawls that is legitimate versus that which is bot generated would surely be majority bots, just because of how fast they can generate content. One thing they can't do as easily though is register domains, so it may be one of the better points of defense.
- pixl97 4y agoThe dead internet theory.
- jaimex2 4y agoIt's incredibly easy to fix. They don't care as they have a monopoly.
- worldofmatthew 4y agoAllow people to report AI generated website to a human at Google.
- robocat 4y agoAnother comment links to a blacklist, which works. If it can be effectively blacklisted, then Google is dropping the ball. This isn’t difficult algorithm foo failure. I don’t agree with your sentences, but I do agree with your point.
- worldofmatthew 4y agoI noticed issues since Matt Cutts left. No one care anymore. There are AI generated website that have been running for years, ranking highly in Google.
- hericium 4y ago> I don't think this problem should be solved by Cloudflare. Cheap domains will always exist and they shouldn't be a problem. The problem lies with Google and its failure to detect these spam sites. The problem exists outside (Google-controlled) web: with (not fully Google-controlled) email, too. Around 2020 I did a per-tld checks on wanted/unwanted messages (ham and spam). With thousands of messages sent from .xyz domains (envelope sender host or PTR record of sending host; I ignored the From header) there wasn't a single legit message. 100% SPAM.
- axsharma 4y agoThe irony, Google/Alphabet uses ABC.xyz.
- johnklos 4y agoI really don't get why so many people are willing to give Cloudflare a free pass on stuff like this. Why is it OK for a company to facilitate and host (1) thousands of scam domains, making reporting arduous and ineffective? Anyone trying to infect others with Trojans and viruses just need to check user agents or use dynamic redirect URLs, and suddenly this clearly illegal activity becomes black magic that is way beyond the comprehension of the folks at Cloudflare. Cloudflare is basically making the shittiest parts of the Internet safe for scammers and spammers, and this is just one example. If that's not bad enough, they're trying like crazy to become a monopoly. If this what they do now, imagine how bad it'll be when they control even more and feel even more immune to making money from scammers. (1) Hosting is providing services on the Internet without which a site would not function. Providing DNS is hosting. Providing proxy is hosting. Providing email is hosting. Don't fall for Cloudflare's "we don't host" bullshit.
- Nextgrid 4y agoI disagree. For example, SO copycats are legitimate in that they respect the license and otherwise just serve the content to whoever sends them an HTTP request. As far as I know they don't spam links to their domain anywhere. They are low-quality and of dubious utility for sure, but I'd rather not make the Internet a place where you need to prove quality & utility to someone to be able to host an HTTP server. The real problem is that a dumbass like Google comes along, sees this and decides that it should rank higher than the source content.
- mod 4y agoExactly. Similarly, I think any dumbass should be able to fix cars in his own yard, including for a fee and calling himself a business. But Google maps better not drive me to someone's yard when I ask to navigate to a nearby mechanic. If it did, it would be hard to blame anyone but Google.
- abbe98 4y agoIs it common that SO and Wikipedia copycats respects open licenses? Most times I run into them they do not. It's really tricky to enforce open licenses on this scale as it's each contributor that licenses their content rather than the platform host.
- nousermane 4y ago"Cheap domains" is not a thing. $25/year domain for a personal website is kinda pricey. But scam/spam operator can pay that and more pretty darn easy.
- worldofmatthew 4y agoWho is charging $25/year for domains?
- dark-star 4y ago$25/year for an .it domain is pretty cheap actually, usually they sell for more like 40€ per year
- thiht 4y ago.it are around 10 bucks a year. No idea where you would find them at 25 or 40 a year.
- smcl 4y agoDepends on the TLD, I searched gandi with a very random set of characters the keyboard (to ensure I could probably get many results) and here's a selection of country-level ones which are above $25/yr: - abcedasdfff.io = €59.29/year - abcedasdfff.tw = €25.20/year - abcedasdfff.nz = €25.40/year - abcedasdfff.mx = €48.28/year Most of them appear to be €10-20/yr, but it's certainly not uncommon to see them go for €25 or higher. Note: EUR and USD are roughly at parity so I don't think it's really necessary to do a conversion.
- worldofmatthew 4y agoMost common TLDs are not in that price range.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]