3 ms·
Isn’t this stuff typically specially built HW? I feel like an ASIC can accelerate this stuff fairly quickly although the volumes/pricing may not warrant buildin
by vlovich123 4y ago
Isn’t this stuff typically specially built HW? I feel like an ASIC can accelerate this stuff fairly quickly although the volumes/pricing may not warrant building that. Also if you’re matching on host name there’s no reason you even need to keep up with line rate. All you need is to do is keep up with the connection establishment rate and you can always do the processing in the background and just issue a TCP reset after the fact.
- vbezhenar 4y agoCan you update ASICs with new firmware?
- mytailorisrich 4y agoNo but I suspect many hardware products use FPGAs, which can be updated as you would firmware, and indeed are often updated during firmware updates.
- guardiangod 4y agoYour suspicion is wrong. Sorry.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoI actually work in the field (networking) and FPGAs are very common in professional telecommunication equipments, hence my suspicion/guess that DPI are the same, especially since I'm also guessing that this is the sort of thing that may be updated often. So I think my 'suspicion' is at least as good as yours.
- guardiangod 4y agoAs long as we are pulling ranks, I worked in a DPI/firewall company and my work ran on the ASIC accelerator, so nah, my 'guess' is probably better. FPGA is not worth the trouble. You get neither the (line) speed of ASIC, nor the flexibility of running everything in the CPU. Most serious DPI hardware vendors have stopped using it. But you are right that it's no fun trying to workaround ASIC bugs.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoWell you made a laconic, non-substantive reply so you ought to expect pushback. FGPAs allow near-ASIC speeds with effectively the flexibility of software in that they can be updated via firmware upgrades, with much cheaper dev. costs than ASICs. They do have a higher unit cost than ASICs but only at high volume. For anything that is 'low' volume an ASIC may not make financial sense at all in any case. I am no expert in DPI specifically but Google suggests that using FPGAs for DPI is an active commercial topic.