3 ms·
Why Arabs Lose Wars (1999)
- politelemon 4y agoSo, question for any armchair generals or otherwise, has the situation since 1999 changed much with regards to the same political and tribal influence on the military? --- Also this line caught my attention: > Even the much-lauded Egyptian crossing of the Suez in 1973 at its core entailed a masterful deception plan It's a reference to Operation Badr. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Badr_(1973) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Badr_(1973)
- wrp 4y agoOne researcher the author relies on, Kenneth Pollack, published his dissertation work in two books Arabs at War (2004) and Armies of Sand (2019). The first gives very good overviews of Arab combat performance over the 20th century. The second tries to place it all in a theoretical framework. While the 2019 book adds some recent history, I didn't feel that it improved on the understanding of Arab military performance that you get from just reading the first book. And no, it doesn't seem that things have changed much since the submitted article was written.